Estudio incluido
Integrating Lean Manufacturing and TPM for Production Efficiency Improvement: A Peruvian Case Study in the Bottled Water Industry
1Ficha bibliográfica
- Autores
- Salvatore Balza Tassara-Chumbiauca, Mateo Rodrigo Gordillo-Egúsquiza
- Año
- 2024
- Publicación
- International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Operations Management (IEOM)
- País
- Peru
- Segmento
- Refrescos, agua embotellada y jugos
- Familia de procesos
- Línea de llenado y envasado
- Tipo de estudio
- Intervención antes/después
- Alcance de la extracción
- Texto completo
- Tamaño
- 1 plantas · 1 líneas · — máquinas
- Periodo de observación
- 180 días
- Recolección de datos
- manual_logs
- Intervención
Ver el contexto tal como lo describe el estudio
This case study concerns a company involved in the bottling of table water in 20-litre containers, including polyethylene, polycarbonate and polypropylene drums.
2Riesgo de sesgo
Puntuado con la rúbrica del protocolo: 2 preocupación baja, 1 algunas preocupaciones, 0 preocupación alta.
Puntuación total 13Riesgo bajo
| Ítem | Puntuación |
|---|---|
| Is the observed line, machine or plant described well enough to classify its segment, process and equipment?Product, process and equipment are all described. | 2 / 2 |
| Is the observation period long enough and reported?Period reported and at least 30 days of production (or at least 100 recorded events). | 2 / 2 |
| How were loss data collected?Manual logs or maintenance records with unknown completeness. | 1 / 2 |
| Are OEE, loading time and the loss categories defined explicitly?A standard definition is cited but its application is not shown. | 1 / 2 |
| Does the loss breakdown account for the total loss it claims to explain?The reported causes or categories sum to at least 90% of the stated total, or an explicit "other" class closes the balance. | 2 / 2 |
| Is there evidence of selective reporting of favourable results?Observational study, or intervention study that reports baseline and post-intervention data with the same method. | 2 / 2 |
| Are the reported numbers internally consistent?Small inconsistencies (2 to 10 percentage points) or values that cannot be cross-checked. | 1 / 2 |
| Could conflicts of interest or the source of the data bias the result?Academic or independent study, or conflicts declared and unrelated to the result. | 2 / 2 |
3Datos extraídos
Cada dato con su clasificación y la cita textual que lo establece.
| Causa reportada | Categoría de pérdida | Métrica | Valor | Extracción |
|---|---|---|---|---|
material shortagesVer cita textual (Section 4.3, Inventory Management Improvements)The downtime caused by material shortages was reduced by 80%, from 15,558 hours to 3,111 hours. | Paros organizacionales o externos (falta de material o personal, corte de servicios) | Tiempo perdido | 3,111 h | Ambos extractores coincidieron |
unplanned stoppagesVer cita textual (Section 4.3, Implementation of Total Productive Maintenance (TPM))the total downtime due to unplanned stoppages was reduced from 3.79 hours to 2.46 hours per week, representing a reduction of 35.09%. | Fallas de equipo (averías) | Tiempo perdido | 2.46 h/week | Ambos extractores coincidieron |
material shortagesVer cita textual (Section 4.3, Inventory Management Improvements)the lack of proper inventory management was responsible for 15,558 hours of downtime due to material shortages, resulting in a financial loss of S/33,760.86. | Paros organizacionales o externos (falta de material o personal, corte de servicios) | Tiempo perdido | 15,558 h | Ambos extractores coincidieron |
unplanned machine stoppagesVer cita textual (Section 4.3, Implementation of Total Productive Maintenance (TPM))The bottleneck analysis revealed that unplanned machine stoppages accounted for a total downtime of 3.79 hours per week, which had a direct impact on the overall production capacity and efficiency of the plant. | Fallas de equipo (averías) | Tiempo perdido | 3.79 h/week | Ambos extractores coincidieron |
—Ver cita textual (Table 1, Results of validation of the proposed model)Real production rate bottels/hr 74.06 99.60 92.93 25.48% | none | Capacidad de producción | 74.1 bottels/hr | Ambos extractores coincidieron |
—Ver cita textual (Table 1, Results of validation of the proposed model)Quality rate % 96.87% 99% 99% 2.20% | none | Calidad | 99.0 % | Ambos extractores coincidieron |
—Ver cita textual (Table 1, Results of validation of the proposed model)Quality rate % 96.87% 99% 99% 2.20% | none | Calidad | 96.9 % | Ambos extractores coincidieron |
—Ver cita textual (Table 1, Results of validation of the proposed model)Performance rate % 76.83% 95% 94% 22.35% | none | Rendimiento | 94.0 % | Ambos extractores coincidieron |
—Ver cita textual (Table 1, Results of validation of the proposed model)Performance rate % 76.83% 95% 94% 22.35% | none | Rendimiento | 76.8 % | Ambos extractores coincidieron |
—Ver cita textual (Section 4.3, Standardization of the Washing Process)The production rate increased from 74.05 to 92.37 botellones per hour, which resulted in a substantial improvement in overall plant efficiency. | none | Capacidad de producción | 92.4 botellones/h | Ambos extractores coincidieron |
—Ver cita textual (Section 4.3, Implementation of Total Productive Maintenance (TPM))The plant's OEE increased from 54.67% to 71%, reflecting the gains in efficiency achieved through the implementation of TPM. | none | OEE | 71.0 % | Ambos extractores coincidieron |
—Ver cita textual (Section 4.3, Implementation of Total Productive Maintenance (TPM))The plant's OEE increased from 54.67% to 71%, reflecting the gains in efficiency achieved through the implementation of TPM. | none | OEE | 54.7 % | Ambos extractores coincidieron |
—Ver cita textual (Section 4.3, Implementation of Total Productive Maintenance (TPM))This led to a significant improvement in the availability of equipment, which increased from 73.45% to 76%, allowing the plant to operate at higher efficiency levels. | none | Disponibilidad | 73.5 % | Ambos extractores coincidieron |
—Ver cita textual (Section 4.3, Standardization of the Washing Process)the total process time for washing was calculated at 13.81 hours, with a production rate of 74.05 botellones per hour. | none | Capacidad de producción | 74.1 botellones/h | Un solo extractor |
—Ver cita textual (Section 4.3, Standardization of the Bottling Process)The overall equipment effectiveness (OEE) in this process increased from 54.67% to 68.19%, reflecting the substantial gains in efficiency achieved through the implementation of the standardization procedures. | none | OEE | 54.7 % | Un solo extractor |
non-value-added tasks (manual inspection, placement of caps, storage of finished products)Ver cita textual (Section 4.3, Standardization of the Bottling Process)The analysis showed that these inefficiencies resulted in an excessive time consumption of about 2.59 hours in non-value-added tasks. | No clasificable a partir del reporte | Tiempo perdido | 2.59 h | Un solo extractor |
—Ver cita textual (Section 4.3, Standardization of the Bottling Process)The production yield increased from 76.83% to 94.02%, and the quality of the final product improved from 96.87% to 99.22%, bringing it closer to world-class standards. | none | Rendimiento másico | 94.0 % | Un solo extractor |
—Ver cita textual (Section 4.3, Standardization of the Bottling Process)The production yield increased from 76.83% to 94.02%, and the quality of the final product improved from 96.87% to 99.22%, bringing it closer to world-class standards. | none | Calidad | 99.2 % | Un solo extractor |
—Ver cita textual (Section 4.3, Standardization of the Bottling Process)The overall equipment effectiveness (OEE) in this process increased from 54.67% to 68.19%, reflecting the substantial gains in efficiency achieved through the implementation of the standardization procedures. | none | OEE | 68.2 % | Un solo extractor |
discardsVer cita textual (Table 1, Results of validation of the proposed model)Discards rate % 3.13% 2% 0.96% -69.33% | Defectos de proceso (desecho y reproceso) | Tasa de defectos | 3.13 % | Un solo extractor |
—Ver cita textual (Section 4.3, Implementation of Total Productive Maintenance (TPM))This led to a significant improvement in the availability of equipment, which increased from 73.45% to 76%, allowing the plant to operate at higher efficiency levels. | none | Disponibilidad | 76.0 % | Un solo extractor |
—Ver cita textual (Table 1, Results of validation of the proposed model)Real production rate bottels/hr 74.06 99.60 92.93 25.48% | none | Capacidad de producción | 92.9 bottels/hr | Un solo extractor |
discardsVer cita textual (Table 1, Results of validation of the proposed model)Discards rate % 3.13% 2% 0.96% -69.33% | Defectos de proceso (desecho y reproceso) | Tasa de defectos | 0.960 % | Un solo extractor |
product defectsVer cita textual (Table 1, page 118)Discards rate | % | 3.13% | 2% | 0.96% | -69.33% | Defectos de proceso (desecho y reproceso) | Tasa de defectos | 3.13 % | Un solo extractor |
washing process cycle time including non-value-added activitieswashing equipmentVer cita textual (Section 4.3 Standardization of the Washing Process, page 108)the total process time for washing was calculated at 13.81 hours, with a production rate of 74.05 botellones per hour. | No clasificable a partir del reporte | Tiempo perdido | 13.8 hours | Un solo extractor |
product defectsVer cita textual (Table 1, page 118)Discards rate | % | 3.13% | 2% | 0.96% | -69.33% | Defectos de proceso (desecho y reproceso) | Tasa de defectos | 0.960 % | Un solo extractor |
optimized washing process cycle timewashing equipmentVer cita textual (Section 4.3 Standardization of the Washing Process, page 108)the process time was reduced from 13.81 hours to 7.07 hours, representing a time reduction of 48.79%. | No clasificable a partir del reporte | Tiempo perdido | 7.07 hours | Un solo extractor |
optimized bottling process cycle timebottling and packaging equipmentVer cita textual (Section 4.3 Standardization of the Bottling Process, page 115)the cycle time decreased from 5.10 hours to 2.51 hours, representing a 50.78% reduction in time. | No clasificable a partir del reporte | Tiempo perdido | 2.51 hours | Un solo extractor |
Unidades de observación
- Plant (whole bottling plant) · Línea completa o equipo sin especificar · Después de la intervención
- Plant (whole bottling plant) · Línea completa o equipo sin especificar · Línea base
- Washing process · Lavado y enjuague de envases · Después de la intervención
- Washing process · Lavado y enjuague de envases · Línea base
- Bottling process · Envasado (formado, sellado, envoltura, encajado, paletizado) · Línea base
- Bottling process · Envasado (formado, sellado, envoltura, encajado, paletizado) · Después de la intervención
- Bottled water packaging line · Línea completa o equipo sin especificar · Línea base
- Bottled water packaging line · Línea completa o equipo sin especificar · Después de la intervención

