foratvise
Comenzar
Estudio incluido

PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF MAINTENANCE IN A MANUFACTURING INDUSTRY

Abrir fuente

1Ficha bibliográfica

Autores
Onyejaka, Chidi Maurice, Prof. Ike, Oluka
Año
2023
Publicación
—
País
Nigeria
Segmento
Refrescos, agua embotellada y jugos
Familia de procesos
Línea de llenado y envasado
Tipo de estudio
Estudio de casos múltiples
Alcance de la extracción
Texto completo
Tamaño
2 plantas · 2 líneas · 5 máquinas
Periodo de observación
1,825 días
Recolección de datos
questionnaire
Intervención
Ver el contexto tal como lo describe el estudio
This was a retrospective study of performance evaluation of maintenance of Nigerian Bottling Company Ltd (coca cola) Benin Plant and BONS INDUSTRIES Ltd, Enugu from 2017 – 2021.

2Riesgo de sesgo

Puntuado con la rúbrica del protocolo: 2 preocupación baja, 1 algunas preocupaciones, 0 preocupación alta.
Puntuación total 10Riesgo moderado
ÍtemPuntuación
Is the observed line, machine or plant described well enough to classify its segment, process and equipment?Product, process and equipment are all described.2 / 2
Is the observation period long enough and reported?Period reported and at least 30 days of production (or at least 100 recorded events).2 / 2
How were loss data collected?Manual logs or maintenance records with unknown completeness.1 / 2
Are OEE, loading time and the loss categories defined explicitly?A standard definition is cited but its application is not shown.1 / 2
Does the loss breakdown account for the total loss it claims to explain?Only selected causes are reported and the total is unknown.0 / 2
Is there evidence of selective reporting of favourable results?Observational study, or intervention study that reports baseline and post-intervention data with the same method.2 / 2
Are the reported numbers internally consistent?Inconsistencies above 10 percentage points, or OEE factors above 100%.0 / 2
Could conflicts of interest or the source of the data bias the result?Academic or independent study, or conflicts declared and unrelated to the result.2 / 2

3Datos extraídos

Cada dato con su clasificación y la cita textual que lo establece.
Causa reportadaCategoría de pérdidaMétricaValorExtracción
—Filler machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Ver cita textual (Figure 4 / text)
performance rate was least in year four (2020 (66.2%) while it was highest in year three (129%)
noneRendimiento66.2 %Ambos extractores coincidieron
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 7)
Year One (2017) 93.5% 103% 99%
noneDisponibilidad93.5 %Ambos extractores coincidieron
breakdownFiller machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Ver cita textual (Table 2)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 123.66 107.33 146.33 153.4 108.5
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido124 hUn solo extractor
breakdownFiller machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Ver cita textual (Table 2)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 123.66 107.33 146.33 153.4 108.5
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido107 hUn solo extractor
breakdownFiller machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Ver cita textual (Table 2)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 123.66 107.33 146.33 153.4 108.5
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido146 hUn solo extractor
breakdownFiller machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Ver cita textual (Table 2)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 123.66 107.33 146.33 153.4 108.5
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido153 hUn solo extractor
breakdownFiller machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Ver cita textual (Table 2)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 123.66 107.33 146.33 153.4 108.5
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido109 hUn solo extractor
—Filler machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Ver cita textual (Figure 3)
95.0% 96.0% 96.0% 93.0% 96.9%
noneDisponibilidad95.0 %Un solo extractor
—Filler machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Ver cita textual (Figure 3)
95.0% 96.0% 96.0% 93.0% 96.9%
noneDisponibilidad96.0 %Un solo extractor
—Filler machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Ver cita textual (Figure 3)
95.0% 96.0% 96.0% 93.0% 96.9%
noneDisponibilidad93.0 %Un solo extractor
—Filler machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Ver cita textual (Figure 3 / text)
The availability rate was highest in the year five 96.9% while it was lowest in year four (93.0%)
noneDisponibilidad96.9 %Un solo extractor
—Filler machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Ver cita textual (Figure 4)
104.1% 108.3% 129.3% 66.2% 113.6%
noneRendimiento104 %Un solo extractor
—Filler machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Ver cita textual (Figure 4)
104.1% 108.3% 129.3% 66.2% 113.6%
noneRendimiento108 %Un solo extractor
—Filler machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Ver cita textual (Figure 4 / text)
performance rate was least in year four (2020 (66.2%) while it was highest in year three (129%)
noneRendimiento129 %Un solo extractor
—Filler machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Ver cita textual (Figure 4)
104.1% 108.3% 129.3% 66.2% 113.6%
noneRendimiento114 %Un solo extractor
—Filler machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Ver cita textual (Table 4)
Year one (2017) 99.9
noneCalidad99.9 %Un solo extractor
breakdownPacker/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 5)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 154.5 117.66 158.3 264.5 128.6
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido155 hUn solo extractor
breakdownPacker/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 5)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 154.5 117.66 158.3 264.5 128.6
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido118 hUn solo extractor
breakdownPacker/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 5)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 154.5 117.66 158.3 264.5 128.6
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido158 hUn solo extractor
breakdownPacker/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 5)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 154.5 117.66 158.3 264.5 128.6
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido265 hUn solo extractor
breakdownPacker/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 5)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 154.5 117.66 158.3 264.5 128.6
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido129 hUn solo extractor
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 7)
Year One (2017) 93.5% 103% 99%
noneRendimiento103 %Un solo extractor
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 7)
Year One (2017) 93.5% 103% 99%
noneCalidad99.0 %Un solo extractor
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 7)
Year Two (2018) 95.2% 105% 99%
noneDisponibilidad95.2 %Un solo extractor
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 7)
Year Two (2018) 95.2% 105% 99%
noneRendimiento105 %Un solo extractor
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 7)
Year Three (2019) 95.6% 108% 99%
noneDisponibilidad95.6 %Un solo extractor
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 7)
Year Three (2019) 95.6% 108% 99%
noneRendimiento108 %Un solo extractor
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 7)
Year Four (2020) 87.0% 66.2% 99%
noneDisponibilidad87.0 %Un solo extractor
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 7)
Year Four (2020) 87.0% 66.2% 99%
noneRendimiento66.2 %Un solo extractor
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 7)
Year Five (2021) 96.3% 103% 99%
noneDisponibilidad96.3 %Un solo extractor
breakdownBlow Mould
Ver cita textual (Table 8)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 125 130 227 397 132
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido125 hUn solo extractor
breakdownBlow Mould
Ver cita textual (Table 8)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 125 130 227 397 132
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido130 hUn solo extractor
breakdownBlow Mould
Ver cita textual (Table 8)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 125 130 227 397 132
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido227 hUn solo extractor
breakdownBlow Mould
Ver cita textual (Table 8)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 125 130 227 397 132
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido397 hUn solo extractor
breakdownBlow Mould
Ver cita textual (Table 8)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 125 130 227 397 132
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido132 hUn solo extractor
—Blow Mould
Ver cita textual (Table 10)
Year One (2017) 95.8% 80.5% 97.2%
noneDisponibilidad95.8 %Un solo extractor
—Blow Mould
Ver cita textual (Table 10)
Year One (2017) 95.8% 80.5% 97.2%
noneRendimiento80.5 %Un solo extractor
—Blow Mould
Ver cita textual (Table 10)
Year One (2017) 95.8% 80.5% 97.2%
noneCalidad97.2 %Un solo extractor
—Blow Mould
Ver cita textual (Table 10)
Year Two (2018) 95.0% 85.1% 96.8%
noneDisponibilidad95.0 %Un solo extractor
—Blow Mould
Ver cita textual (Table 10)
Year Two (2018) 95.0% 85.1% 96.8%
noneRendimiento85.1 %Un solo extractor
—Blow Mould
Ver cita textual (Table 10)
Year Two (2018) 95.0% 85.1% 96.8%
noneCalidad96.8 %Un solo extractor
—Blow Mould
Ver cita textual (Table 10)
Year Three (2019) 92.4% 89.2% 96.3%
noneDisponibilidad92.4 %Un solo extractor
—Blow Mould
Ver cita textual (Table 10)
Year Three (2019) 92.4% 89.2% 96.3%
noneRendimiento89.2 %Un solo extractor
—Blow Mould
Ver cita textual (Table 10)
Year Three (2019) 92.4% 89.2% 96.3%
noneCalidad96.3 %Un solo extractor
—Blow Mould
Ver cita textual (Table 10)
Year Four (2020) 86.8% 46.7% 96.1%
noneDisponibilidad86.8 %Un solo extractor
—Blow Mould
Ver cita textual (Table 10)
Year Four (2020) 86.8% 46.7% 96.1%
noneRendimiento46.7 %Un solo extractor
—Blow Mould
Ver cita textual (Table 10)
Year Four (2020) 86.8% 46.7% 96.1%
noneCalidad96.1 %Un solo extractor
—Blow Mould
Ver cita textual (Table 10)
Year Five (2021) 95.6% 82.0% 95.1%
noneDisponibilidad95.6 %Un solo extractor
—Blow Mould
Ver cita textual (Table 10)
Year Five (2021) 95.6% 82.0% 95.1%
noneRendimiento82.0 %Un solo extractor
—Blow Mould
Ver cita textual (Table 10)
Year Five (2021) 95.6% 82.0% 95.1%
noneCalidad95.1 %Un solo extractor
breakdownMonobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Ver cita textual (Table 11)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 120 130 217.5 386 114.5
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido120 hUn solo extractor
breakdownMonobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Ver cita textual (Table 11)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 120 130 217.5 386 114.5
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido130 hUn solo extractor
breakdownMonobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Ver cita textual (Table 11)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 120 130 217.5 386 114.5
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido218 hUn solo extractor
breakdownMonobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Ver cita textual (Table 11)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 120 130 217.5 386 114.5
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido386 hUn solo extractor
breakdownMonobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Ver cita textual (Table 11)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 120 130 217.5 386 114.5
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido115 hUn solo extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Ver cita textual (Figure 5)
95.8% 95.0% 92.4% 86.8% 95.6%
noneDisponibilidad95.8 %Un solo extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Ver cita textual (Figure 5)
95.8% 95.0% 92.4% 86.8% 95.6%
noneDisponibilidad95.0 %Un solo extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Ver cita textual (Figure 5)
95.8% 95.0% 92.4% 86.8% 95.6%
noneDisponibilidad92.4 %Un solo extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Ver cita textual (Figure 5)
95.8% 95.0% 92.4% 86.8% 95.6%
noneDisponibilidad86.8 %Un solo extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Ver cita textual (Figure 5)
95.8% 95.0% 92.4% 86.8% 95.6%
noneDisponibilidad95.6 %Un solo extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Ver cita textual (Figure 6)
93.9% 94.1% 88.8% 47.2% 96.1%
noneRendimiento93.9 %Un solo extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Ver cita textual (Figure 6)
93.9% 94.1% 88.8% 47.2% 96.1%
noneRendimiento94.1 %Un solo extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Ver cita textual (Figure 6)
93.9% 94.1% 88.8% 47.2% 96.1%
noneRendimiento88.8 %Un solo extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Ver cita textual (Figure 6)
93.9% 94.1% 88.8% 47.2% 96.1%
noneRendimiento47.2 %Un solo extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Ver cita textual (Figure 6)
93.9% 94.1% 88.8% 47.2% 96.1%
noneRendimiento96.1 %Un solo extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Ver cita textual (Table 13)
Year One (2017) 93.5%
noneCalidad93.5 %Un solo extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Ver cita textual (Table 13)
Year Two (2018) 93.7%
noneCalidad93.7 %Un solo extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Ver cita textual (Table 13)
Year Three (2019) 92.0%
noneCalidad92.0 %Un solo extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Ver cita textual (Table 13)
Year Four (2020) 92.4%
noneCalidad92.4 %Un solo extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Ver cita textual (Table 13)
Year Five (2021) 91.8%
noneCalidad91.8 %Un solo extractor
breakdownPacker/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 14)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 321.5 165.8 285.5 364.3 216
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido322 hUn solo extractor
breakdownPacker/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 14)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 321.5 165.8 285.5 364.3 216
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido166 hUn solo extractor
breakdownPacker/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 14)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 321.5 165.8 285.5 364.3 216
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido286 hUn solo extractor
breakdownPacker/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 14)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 321.5 165.8 285.5 364.3 216
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido364 hUn solo extractor
breakdownPacker/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 14)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 321.5 165.8 285.5 364.3 216
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo perdido216 hUn solo extractor
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 16)
Year One (2017) 89.0% 83.8% 91.7%
noneDisponibilidad89.0 %Un solo extractor
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 16)
Year One (2017) 89.0% 83.8% 91.7%
noneRendimiento83.8 %Un solo extractor
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 16)
Year One (2017) 89.0% 83.8% 91.7%
noneCalidad91.7 %Un solo extractor
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 16)
Year Two (2018) 94.5% 87.8% 90.0%
noneDisponibilidad94.5 %Un solo extractor
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 16)
Year Two (2018) 94.5% 87.8% 90.0%
noneRendimiento87.8 %Un solo extractor
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 16)
Year Two (2018) 94.5% 87.8% 90.0%
noneCalidad90.0 %Un solo extractor
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 16)
Year Three (2019) 90.5% 80.4% 91.7%
noneDisponibilidad90.5 %Un solo extractor
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 16)
Year Three (2019) 90.5% 80.4% 91.7%
noneRendimiento80.4 %Un solo extractor
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 16)
Year Four (2020) 87.9% 46.3% 90.9%
noneDisponibilidad87.9 %Un solo extractor
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 16)
Year Four (2020) 87.9% 46.3% 90.9%
noneRendimiento46.3 %Un solo extractor
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 16)
Year Four (2020) 87.9% 46.3% 90.9%
noneCalidad90.9 %Un solo extractor
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 16)
Year Five (2021) 92.1% 85.8% 90.0%
noneDisponibilidad92.1 %Un solo extractor
—Packer/Caser
Ver cita textual (Table 16)
Year Five (2021) 92.1% 85.8% 90.0%
noneRendimiento85.8 %Un solo extractor

Unidades de observación

  • NBC Filler · Llenado · Línea base
  • NBC Packer/Caser · Envasado (formado, sellado, envoltura, encajado, paletizado) · Línea base
  • BONS Blow Mould · Formado, moldeado y dosificado · Línea base
  • BONS Monobloc · Llenado · Línea base
  • BONS Packer/Caser · Envasado (formado, sellado, envoltura, encajado, paletizado) · Línea base