foratvise
Comenzar
Estudio incluido

Enhancing Machinery Availability in a Food Company: An Integrated Approach Using TPM, SMED, and RCM Methodologies

Abrir fuente

1Ficha bibliográfica

Autores
Sair Castañeda, Sharon Rodriguez, Orkun Yildiz, Duilio Aranda, José C. Alvarez
Año
2024
Publicación
Social Science Research Network
País
Peru
Segmento
Azúcar y confitería
Familia de procesos
Formado, horneado y cocción
Tipo de estudio
Intervención antes/después
Alcance de la extracción
Texto completo
Tamaño
1 plantas · 1 líneas · 2 máquinas
Periodo de observación
60 días
Recolección de datos
manual_logs
Intervención
Ver el contexto tal como lo describe el estudio
The company under study belongs to the food industry in Lima, Peru. It has five production lines: Chocolate Line, Confectionery, Instant Products, Cereals and Milling.

2Riesgo de sesgo

Puntuado con la rúbrica del protocolo: 2 preocupación baja, 1 algunas preocupaciones, 0 preocupación alta.
Puntuación total 10Riesgo moderado
ÍtemPuntuación
Is the observed line, machine or plant described well enough to classify its segment, process and equipment?Product, process and equipment are all described.2 / 2
Is the observation period long enough and reported?Period reported and at least 30 days of production (or at least 100 recorded events).2 / 2
How were loss data collected?Manual logs or maintenance records with unknown completeness.1 / 2
Are OEE, loading time and the loss categories defined explicitly?Formulae or definitions are given for the reported metrics, including what counts as planned time.2 / 2
Does the loss breakdown account for the total loss it claims to explain?Only selected causes are reported and the total is unknown.0 / 2
Is there evidence of selective reporting of favourable results?Intervention study in which baseline and post-intervention periods differ in length or method.1 / 2
Are the reported numbers internally consistent?Inconsistencies above 10 percentage points, or OEE factors above 100%.0 / 2
Could conflicts of interest or the source of the data bias the result?Academic or independent study, or conflicts declared and unrelated to the result.2 / 2

3Datos extraídos

Cada dato con su clasificación y la cita textual que lo establece.
Causa reportadaCategoría de pérdidaMétricaValorExtracción
—
Ver cita textual (Conclusion)
resulting in the optimization of the values of the MTBF MTTR indicators from 29.23 to 34.94 and from 7.72 to 8.72, respectively, with the application of the first pillar of TPM (Autonomous Maintenance)
Fallas de equipo (averías)Duración media del evento8.72 hAmbos extractores coincidieron
—
Ver cita textual (Conclusion)
resulting in the optimization of the values of the MTBF MTTR indicators from 29.23 to 34.94 and from 7.72 to 8.72, respectively, with the application of the first pillar of TPM (Autonomous Maintenance)
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo entre eventos34.9 hAmbos extractores coincidieron
—
Ver cita textual (Discussion (Section 5))
availability increases by 12.10%; initially, this parameter presented a percentage of 79.06%, and after the implementation, a value equal to 89.37% was obtained.
noneDisponibilidad89.4 %Ambos extractores coincidieron
—
Ver cita textual (Conclusion)
resulting in the optimization of the values of the MTBF MTTR indicators from 29.23 to 34.94 and from 7.72 to 8.72, respectively, with the application of the first pillar of TPM (Autonomous Maintenance)
Fallas de equipo (averías)Duración media del evento7.72 hAmbos extractores coincidieron
—
Ver cita textual (Conclusion)
resulting in the optimization of the values of the MTBF MTTR indicators from 29.23 to 34.94 and from 7.72 to 8.72, respectively, with the application of the first pillar of TPM (Autonomous Maintenance)
Fallas de equipo (averías)Tiempo entre eventos29.2 hAmbos extractores coincidieron
—
Ver cita textual (Section 4.1)
a gap in machinery availability has been identified, with the company under study reporting a value of 79.06%; however, the industry reflects that the value is acceptable greater than 90%.
noneDisponibilidad79.1 %Ambos extractores coincidieron
—
Ver cita textual (Section 3.3.3)
Currently, there is 70.48% and its parameters of availability (78.05%), performance (94.86%) and quality (95.19%); and it is intended to reach an equal value of 85.02%
noneCalidad95.2 %Ambos extractores coincidieron
—
Ver cita textual (Section 3.3.3)
Currently, there is 70.48% and its parameters of availability (78.05%), performance (94.86%) and quality (95.19%); and it is intended to reach an equal value of 85.02%
noneRendimiento94.9 %Ambos extractores coincidieron
—
Ver cita textual (Table 1)
OEE 78.05% 90.00% 11.95 pp
noneOEE78.1 %Ambos extractores coincidieron
Internal activities time (final)
Ver cita textual (Section 4.3.2 Phase 4)
At the end of the activities, a final process time of 105.69 minutes was obtained, with eight internal and 25 external activities, each with a time of 25.62 and 80.07 minutes, respectively.
Setups y ajustesTiempo perdido25.6 minAmbos extractores coincidieron
Hours of preventive maintenance (scheduled), Month 2
Ver cita textual (Table 7)
Month 2 12.00 20.00 8.00
Paro planificado (mantenimiento programado, descansos, sin demanda)Tiempo perdido12.0 hAmbos extractores coincidieron
Hours of preventive maintenance (scheduled), Month 1
Ver cita textual (Table 7)
Month 1 14.00 25.00 11.00
Paro planificado (mantenimiento programado, descansos, sin demanda)Tiempo perdido14.0 hAmbos extractores coincidieron
Hours of factual preventive maintenance, Month 2
Ver cita textual (Table 7)
Month 2 12.00 20.00 8.00
Paro planificado (mantenimiento programado, descansos, sin demanda)Tiempo perdido20.0 hAmbos extractores coincidieron
Hours of factual preventive maintenance, Month 1
Ver cita textual (Table 7)
Month 1 14.00 25.00 11.00
Paro planificado (mantenimiento programado, descansos, sin demanda)Tiempo perdido25.0 hAmbos extractores coincidieron
—
Ver cita textual (Section 3.3.3)
Currently, there is 70.48% and its parameters of availability (78.05%), performance (94.86%) and quality (95.19%); and it is intended to reach an equal value of 85.02%
noneOEE70.5 %Un solo extractor
—
Ver cita textual (Section 3.3.3)
Currently, there is 70.48% and its parameters of availability (78.05%), performance (94.86%) and quality (95.19%); and it is intended to reach an equal value of 85.02%
noneDisponibilidad78.1 %Un solo extractor
Average Monthly installation time (2021)
Ver cita textual (Table 8)
Month 1 31.17 22 18.5 41%
Setups y ajustesTiempo perdido31.2 not reportedUn solo extractor
Total production time of changeover activities
Ver cita textual (Table 4)
147.54 15 23 63.22 84.32
Setups y ajustesTiempo perdido148 minUn solo extractor
Internal activities
Ver cita textual (Table 4)
147.54 15 23 63.22 84.32
Setups y ajustesNúmero de eventos15.0 eventsUn solo extractor
External activities
Ver cita textual (Table 4)
147.54 15 23 63.22 84.32
Setups y ajustesNúmero de eventos23.0 eventsUn solo extractor
Internal activities time
Ver cita textual (Table 4)
147.54 15 23 63.22 84.32
Setups y ajustesTiempo perdido63.2 minUn solo extractor
External activities time
Ver cita textual (Table 4)
147.54 15 23 63.22 84.32
Setups y ajustesTiempo perdido84.3 minUn solo extractor
Pilot test average monthly installation time
Ver cita textual (Table 8)
Month 1 31.17 22 18.5 41%
Setups y ajustesTiempo perdido18.5 not reportedUn solo extractor
Final process time after SMED implementation
Ver cita textual (Section 4.3.2 Phase 4)
At the end of the activities, a final process time of 105.69 minutes was obtained, with eight internal and 25 external activities, each with a time of 25.62 and 80.07 minutes, respectively.
Setups y ajustesTiempo perdido106 minUn solo extractor
External activities (final)
Ver cita textual (Section 4.3.2 Phase 4)
At the end of the activities, a final process time of 105.69 minutes was obtained, with eight internal and 25 external activities, each with a time of 25.62 and 80.07 minutes, respectively.
Setups y ajustesNúmero de eventos25.0 eventsUn solo extractor
External activities time (final)
Ver cita textual (Section 4.3.2 Phase 4)
At the end of the activities, a final process time of 105.69 minutes was obtained, with eight internal and 25 external activities, each with a time of 25.62 and 80.07 minutes, respectively.
Setups y ajustesTiempo perdido80.1 minUn solo extractor
Extra hours, Month 1
Ver cita textual (Table 7)
Month 1 14.00 25.00 11.00
Paro planificado (mantenimiento programado, descansos, sin demanda)Tiempo perdido11.0 hUn solo extractor
Extra hours, Month 2
Ver cita textual (Table 7)
Month 2 12.00 20.00 8.00
Paro planificado (mantenimiento programado, descansos, sin demanda)Tiempo perdido8.00 hUn solo extractor
Breakdowns in the Machinery
Ver cita textual (Table 9)
Breakdowns in the Machinery | 12.20% | 39.25%
Fallas de equipo (averías)Proporción de eventos de pérdida12.2 %Un solo extractor
Breakdowns due to human errors in calibration or operation
Ver cita textual (Table 9)
Breakdowns due to human errors in calibration or operation | 8.47% | 38.38%
Microparos y esperasProporción de eventos de pérdida8.47 %Un solo extractor

Unidades de observación

  • Confectionery line · Línea completa o equipo sin especificar · Después de la intervención
  • Confectionery line · Línea completa o equipo sin especificar · Línea base