Product loss at start-up/shut-down due to line design
In short
It appears in fewer than 1 of every 100 lines studied.
When it appears, it takes on average about 47 % of the line's lost time. Reported by 1 of the 127 studies that could observe it (sparse evidence).
What happens
The physical layout of the line (pipe lengths, dead legs, tank-to-filler distances, absence of product recovery or pigging systems) forces operators to purge or flush the product/water interface at every start-up and shut-down, discarding syrup or product that cannot be routed back to the process. The same design limitations also generate off-specification product during these transitions because mixing, dosing or temperature conditions are not yet stable, which shows up as non-conformity losses.
What is done about it
Redesign the line to minimize dead volume and transfer distances, and install product recovery, pigging or push-back systems that return usable syrup/product to the process instead of draining it. Add inline interface detection (density, conductivity or optical sensors) with automated diverter valves so only the true interface segment is rejected, and standardize start-up/shut-down sequences to shorten the unstable transition window.
Practical guidance written from engineering knowledge; it is not a statistical estimate.
1Probability and evidence
- Probability of presence
- 0.5% [0.1–1.3%]
- Expected share of lost time
- 0.2% [0.0–0.7%]
- Share of lost time when present
- 47% [29–67%]
- Studies / units
- 127 / 161
- Evidence grade
- D
Grade D: 0 or 1 study; the estimate is driven by partial pooling and priors, and the wide interval is the result.
2Probability by segment
- Dairy products0.5% [0.1–1.9%]13 studies
- Soft drinks, bottled water and juices0.7% [0.1–2.2%]26 studies
- Brewing, wine and spirits0.5% [0.1–2.0%]11 studies
- Bakery and pasta0.5% [0.0–1.8%]24 studies
- Meat, poultry and seafood0.5% [0.0–1.9%]9 studies
- Fruit and vegetable processing0.5% [0.1–2.0%]7 studies
- Grain and oilseed milling0.5% [0.0–2.2%]6 studies
- Sugar and confectionery0.5% [0.0–2.0%]9 studies
- Snacks, coffee, tea and other foods0.5% [0.0–2.0%]5 studies
- Animal feed and pet food0.5% [0.1–1.8%]7 studies
- Food manufacturing (unspecified or mixed)0.5% [0.1–2.0%]10 studies
3Mechanism, SCADA signature and countermeasure
Mechanism
Engineering guidanceThe physical layout of the line (pipe lengths, dead legs, tank-to-filler distances, absence of product recovery or pigging systems) forces operators to purge or flush the product/water interface at every start-up and shut-down, discarding syrup or product that cannot be routed back to the process. The same design limitations also generate off-specification product during these transitions because mixing, dosing or temperature conditions are not yet stable, which shows up as non-conformity losses.
How it looks in SCADA data
Engineering guidanceRepeated start-up and shut-down state entries on the line timeline, often coinciding with drain/flush valve open commands or diverter-valve activations; interface or density/conductivity sensor trends show extended purge windows at run boundaries. Production counters show a gap between raw material (syrup/mix) consumption and first/last good units, and quality or MES event logs register non-conformity flags clustered around run-start and run-end timestamps.
Countermeasure
Engineering guidanceRedesign the line to minimize dead volume and transfer distances, and install product recovery, pigging or push-back systems that return usable syrup/product to the process instead of draining it. Add inline interface detection (density, conductivity or optical sensors) with automated diverter valves so only the true interface segment is rejected, and standardize start-up/shut-down sequences to shorten the unstable transition window.
4Sources
- An Example Application On Comparison Of Six Sigma And Kaizen From Total Quality Managment Techniquies (2018)Open sourceLost time: 24,000 litre · as reported: “Uygunsuzluk kayıpları”
Show verbatim quote
Bu kayıpların temelinde yatan iki nedenden uygunsuzluk kayıplarının 24.000 litre ile mevcut şurup kaybının %42.1’ini hat dizaynı ile ilgili kayıpların ise 33.000 litre ile şurup kayıplarında %58 ini oluşturduğu anlaşılmıştır.
- An Example Application On Comparison Of Six Sigma And Kaizen From Total Quality Managment Techniquies (2018)Open sourceLost time: 33,000 litre · as reported: “Hat dizaynı ile ilgili kayıplar”
Show verbatim quote
...hat dizaynı ile ilgili kayıpların ise 33.000 litre ile şurup kayıplarında %58 ini oluşturduğu anlaşılmıştır.
- An Example Application On Comparison Of Six Sigma And Kaizen From Total Quality Managment Techniquies (2018)Open sourceShare of lost time: 58.0 % · as reported: “Hat dizaynı ile ilgili kayıplar”
Show verbatim quote
...hat dizaynı ile ilgili kayıpların ise 33.000 litre ile şurup kayıplarında %58 ini oluşturduğu anlaşılmıştır.
- An Example Application On Comparison Of Six Sigma And Kaizen From Total Quality Managment Techniquies (2018)Open sourceLost time: 87.5 litre · as reported: “Üretim başlangıç ve bitişlerindeki şurup kaybı (hat dizaynı)”
Show verbatim quote
Hat dizaynındaki kayıplarla ilgili yapılan ölçümlemelerin sonucunda ürün 1 ve ürün 2 kayıpların her üretim başlangıç ve bitiminde ortama 55’er litre, ürün 3 ve ürün 4 içinse ortalama 120 litre olmak üzere ortalamada 87.5 litre şurup kaybı olduğu belirlenmiştir.

