Sucrose Loss to Acid Hydrolysis in Evaporation
In short
It appears in about 2 of every 100 lines studied.
When it appears, it takes on average about 49 % of the line's lost time. Reported by 5 of the 29 studies that could observe it (limited evidence).
What happens
In the evaporator station, sucrose present in the juice or syrup undergoes acid-catalyzed hydrolysis into reducing sugars when pH is below the optimal range and the material is exposed to elevated temperature for prolonged residence time in the effects. This chemical degradation consumes recoverable sucrose without interrupting equipment operation, so it is recorded as a first-pass yield or quality loss rather than a stoppage; it is often compounded by mechanical breakdowns or reduced throughput that extend the time the product spends under hydrolysis-prone conditions.
What is done about it
Control and stabilize feed and in-process pH within the target range through alkali dosing ahead of and within the evaporation stage, and minimize residence time and local overheating by maintaining correct circulation, vacuum and temperature profiles per effect. Continuously monitor pH, Brix and purity with automated dosing correction, and address underlying mechanical breakdowns or speed losses promptly so product does not linger under hydrolysis-prone conditions.
Practical guidance written from engineering knowledge; it is not a statistical estimate.
1Probability and evidence
- Probability of presence
- 2.5% [0.5–6.7%]
- Expected share of lost time
- 1.2% [0.2–3.4%]
- Share of lost time when present
- 49% [37–61%]
- Studies / units
- 29 / 34
- Evidence grade
- C
Grade C: 2 to 4 studies, or an interval wider than 0.35.
2Probability by segment
- Dairy products2.7% [0.3–9.5%]5 studies
- Soft drinks, bottled water and juices2.9% [0.3–10.8%]1 study
- Brewing, wine and spirits2.9% [0.3–11.2%]0 studies
- Bakery and pasta3.0% [0.3–11.1%]0 studies
- Meat, poultry and seafood2.9% [0.3–10.9%]0 studies
- Fruit and vegetable processing2.8% [0.3–10.1%]2 studies
- Grain and oilseed milling3.0% [0.3–10.3%]0 studies
- Sugar and confectionery5.3% [0.7–16.7%]6 studies
- Snacks, coffee, tea and other foods2.7% [0.3–10.0%]3 studies
- Animal feed and pet food2.7% [0.3–9.9%]4 studies
- Food manufacturing (unspecified or mixed)3.8% [0.5–12.7%]8 studies
3Mechanism, SCADA signature and countermeasure
Mechanism
Engineering guidanceIn the evaporator station, sucrose present in the juice or syrup undergoes acid-catalyzed hydrolysis into reducing sugars when pH is below the optimal range and the material is exposed to elevated temperature for prolonged residence time in the effects. This chemical degradation consumes recoverable sucrose without interrupting equipment operation, so it is recorded as a first-pass yield or quality loss rather than a stoppage; it is often compounded by mechanical breakdowns or reduced throughput that extend the time the product spends under hydrolysis-prone conditions.
How it looks in SCADA data
Engineering guidanceEvaporator run-state logs typically show the equipment operating normally or intermittently in breakdown/reduced-speed states, while laboratory or process-quality trends reveal falling juice pH, rising reducing-sugar content and declining sucrose purity or recovery across effects. Mass-balance and yield reports at the evaporator station show a gap between theoretical and actual sucrose output that correlates with low pH excursions, extended batch or effect residence time, and periods of equipment breakdown or slow running rather than with any single alarm.
Countermeasure
Engineering guidanceControl and stabilize feed and in-process pH within the target range through alkali dosing ahead of and within the evaporation stage, and minimize residence time and local overheating by maintaining correct circulation, vacuum and temperature profiles per effect. Continuously monitor pH, Brix and purity with automated dosing correction, and address underlying mechanical breakdowns or speed losses promptly so product does not linger under hydrolysis-prone conditions.
4Sources
- Minimization of Seasonal Sucrose Losses Across Robert's- Type Evaporators in Raw Sugar Manufacture by pH Optimization (2005)Open sourceDefect rate: 0.550 % · as reported: “sucrose loss to acid hydrolysis”
Show verbatim quote
A target FES pH of 5.9 caused a season average sucrose loss of 0.55% equivalent to 1.52 lbs sucrose lost/ton of cane and a minimum USD 390,400 loss in profits.
- Minimization of Seasonal Sucrose Losses Across Robert's- Type Evaporators in Raw Sugar Manufacture by pH Optimization (2005)Open sourceDefect rate: 0.360 % · as reported: “sucrose loss to acid hydrolysis”
Show verbatim quote
In contrast, a target FES pH of 6.5 reduced this sucrose loss to 0.36% and 1.01 lbs sucrose lost/ton of cane and saved the factory a minimum of USD 131,100.
- HOW TIME BETWEEN CLEANINGS AFFECTS PERFORMANCE AND SUCROSE LOSSES IN ROBERT'S EVAPORATORS (2007)Open sourceDefect rate: 1.42 % · as reported: “total sucrose losses to acid hydrolysis”
Show verbatim quote
A wide range of 0.21–1.42% total sucrose losses to acid hydrolysis were measured across the station, which were affected by seasonal changes in clarified juice quality.
- HOW TIME BETWEEN CLEANINGS AFFECTS PERFORMANCE AND SUCROSE LOSSES IN ROBERT'S EVAPORATORS (2007)Open sourceDefect rate: 0.210 % · as reported: “total sucrose losses to acid hydrolysis”
Show verbatim quote
A wide range of 0.21–1.42% total sucrose losses to acid hydrolysis were measured across the station, which were affected by seasonal changes in clarified juice quality.
- HOW TIME BETWEEN CLEANINGS AFFECTS PERFORMANCE AND SUCROSE LOSSES IN ROBERT'S EVAPORATORS (2007)Open sourceShare of lost time: 98.0 % · as reported: “sucrose losses to acid hydrolysis”
Show verbatim quote
Losses in the pre-evaporators were up to 98% of the total station losses in early season but decreased in midseason
- ANALISA TERJADINYA SIX BIG LOSSES PADA MESIN EVAPORATOR DENGAN METODE TPM DI SEKSI REFINERY MSG PT. XXX (2018)Open sourceNumber of events: 44.0 events · as reported: “Kerusakan mesin”
Show verbatim quote
Evaporator 44 24,3
- ANALISA TERJADINYA SIX BIG LOSSES PADA MESIN EVAPORATOR DENGAN METODE TPM DI SEKSI REFINERY MSG PT. XXX (2018)Open sourceShare of loss events: 24.3 % · as reported: “Kerusakan mesin”
Show verbatim quote
Evaporator 44 24,3
- ANALISA TERJADINYA SIX BIG LOSSES PADA MESIN EVAPORATOR DENGAN METODE TPM DI SEKSI REFINERY MSG PT. XXX (2018)Open sourceShare of lost time: 4.70 % · as reported: “breakdown losses”
Show verbatim quote
Rendahnya efektifitas mesin evaporator diakibatkan tingginya kontribusi yang diberikan oleh 2 faktor six big losses yaitu tingginya nilai breakdown losses sebesar 4,7% dan reduced speed losses sebesar 2,5%.
- ANALISA TERJADINYA SIX BIG LOSSES PADA MESIN EVAPORATOR DENGAN METODE TPM DI SEKSI REFINERY MSG PT. XXX (2018)Open sourceShare of lost time: 2.50 % · as reported: “reduced speed losses”
Show verbatim quote
Rendahnya efektifitas mesin evaporator diakibatkan tingginya kontribusi yang diberikan oleh 2 faktor six big losses yaitu tingginya nilai breakdown losses sebesar 4,7% dan reduced speed losses sebesar 2,5%.
- ANALISA TERJADINYA SIX BIG LOSSES PADA MESIN EVAPORATOR DENGAN METODE TPM DI SEKSI REFINERY MSG PT. XXX (2018)Open sourceShare of planned time: 4.70 % · as reported: “breakdown losses”
Show verbatim quote
tingginya nilai breakdown losses sebesar 4,7%
- ANALISA TERJADINYA SIX BIG LOSSES PADA MESIN EVAPORATOR DENGAN METODE TPM DI SEKSI REFINERY MSG PT. XXX (2018)Open sourceShare of planned time: 2.50 % · as reported: “reduced speed losses”
Show verbatim quote
reduced speed losses sebesar 2,5%

