Included study
Total productive maintenance models and tools in flow line manufacturing systems
1Bibliographic record
- Authors
- Ilenia Zennaro
- Year
- 2017
- Venue
- Padua@research (University of Padova)
- DOI
- —
- Country
- Italy
- Segment
- Soft drinks, bottled water and juices
- Process family
- Filling and packaging line
- Study type
- Single case study
- Extraction scope
- Full text
- Size
- 1 plants · 1 lines · 8 machines
- Observation period
- 60 days
- Data collection
- manual_logs
- Intervention
Show the setting as described by the study
Line D produces mineral water in 1.5L format. It produces on average 15 million bottles per month, with at an average rate of 23.000 bottles per hour.
2Risk of bias
Scored with the rubric of the protocol: 2 low concern, 1 some concerns, 0 high concern.
Total score 13Low risk
| Item | Score |
|---|---|
| Is the observed line, machine or plant described well enough to classify its segment, process and equipment?Product, process and equipment are all described. | 2 / 2 |
| Is the observation period long enough and reported?Period reported and at least 30 days of production (or at least 100 recorded events). | 2 / 2 |
| How were loss data collected?Manual logs or maintenance records with unknown completeness. | 1 / 2 |
| Are OEE, loading time and the loss categories defined explicitly?Formulae or definitions are given for the reported metrics, including what counts as planned time. | 2 / 2 |
| Does the loss breakdown account for the total loss it claims to explain?The reported causes or categories sum to at least 90% of the stated total, or an explicit "other" class closes the balance. | 2 / 2 |
| Is there evidence of selective reporting of favourable results?Observational study, or intervention study that reports baseline and post-intervention data with the same method. | 2 / 2 |
| Are the reported numbers internally consistent?Small inconsistencies (2 to 10 percentage points) or values that cannot be cross-checked. | 1 / 2 |
| Could conflicts of interest or the source of the data bias the result?Authors are employees of the plant or of an equipment/software vendor; no declaration. | 1 / 2 |
3Extracted data
Each datum with its classification and the verbatim quote that states it.
| Reported cause | Loss category | Metric | Value | Extraction |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Pallet not Alligned (Palletizer Entry)Palletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 1, p.269)E Pallet not Alligned (Palletizer Entry) 4,57% 77,92% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of loss events | 4.57 % | Both extractors agreed |
Pallets Warehouse AllarmPalletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 1, p.269)C Pallets Warehouse Allarm 10,38% 64,36% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of loss events | 10.4 % | Both extractors agreed |
Uncorrect Stratum (N°2)Palletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 1, p.269)B Uncorrect Stratum (N°2) 12,60% 53,98% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of loss events | 12.6 % | Both extractors agreed |
Uncorrect Stratum (N°1)Palletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 1, p.269)D Uncorrect Stratum (N°1) 9,00% 73,36% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of loss events | 9.00 % | Both extractors agreed |
Bundle not Alligned (Palletizer)Palletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 1, p.269)A Bundle not Alligned (Palletizer) 41,38% 41,38% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of loss events | 41.4 % | Both extractors agreed |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 3.1, p.114)OEE (Start) 71.57 % - | none | OEE | 71.6 % | Both extractors agreed |
—Show verbatim quote (Figure 2, p.264)Failures 7% Set-Up 16% Materials 3% Defects 16% | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Share of lost time | 7.00 % | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Figure 2, p.264)Failures 7% Set-Up 16% Materials 3% Defects 16% | Setup and adjustments | Share of lost time | 16.0 % | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Figure 2, p.264)Failures 7% Set-Up 16% Materials 3% Defects 16% | Organizational or external stops (material or personnel shortage, utilities outage) | Share of lost time | 3.00 % | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Figure 2, p.264)Failures 7% Set-Up 16% Materials 3% Defects 16% | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Share of lost time | 16.0 % | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Figure 2, p.264)Microdownti me 57% Others 1% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 57.0 % | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Figure 2, p.264)Microdownti me 57% Others 1% | Not classifiable from the report | Share of lost time | 1.00 % | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 3.4, p.123 (March))Original OEE 70,62% 72,68% | none | OEE | 70.6 % | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 3.4, p.123 (April))Original OEE 70,62% 72,68% | none | OEE | 72.7 % | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 3.4, p.123 (March))Production Loss [Hours] 33,88 30,71 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Lost time | 33.9 h | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 3.4, p.123 (April))Production Loss [Hours] 33,88 30,71 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Lost time | 30.7 h | Single extractor |
—Palletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Figure 5, p.265)16,43%16,09% 14,26% 12,68% 7,52% 5,14% 4,46% 3, | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 16.4 % | Single extractor |
—Shrink wrap packer (M2)Show verbatim quote (Figure 5, p.265)16,43%16,09% 14,26% 12,68% 7,52% 5,14% 4,46% 3, | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 16.1 % | Single extractor |
—Labeller (M3)Show verbatim quote (Figure 5, p.265)16,43%16,09% 14,26% 12,68% 7,52% 5,14% 4,46% 3, | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 14.3 % | Single extractor |
—Transport 1 (M4)Show verbatim quote (Figure 5, p.265)16,43%16,09% 14,26% 12,68% 7,52% 5,14% 4,46% 3, | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 12.7 % | Single extractor |
—Handler Machine (M5)Show verbatim quote (Figure 5, p.265)16,43%16,09% 14,26% 12,68% 7,52% 5,14% 4,46% 3, | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 7.52 % | Single extractor |
—Data Machine (M6)Show verbatim quote (Figure 5, p.265)16,43%16,09% 14,26% 12,68% 7,52% 5,14% 4,46% 3, | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 5.14 % | Single extractor |
—Transport 2 (M7)Show verbatim quote (Figure 5, p.265)16,43%16,09% 14,26% 12,68% 7,52% 5,14% 4,46% 3, | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 4.46 % | Single extractor |
—Filler (M9)Show verbatim quote (Figure 6, p.266)M8 M9 M10 M11 31% 2,81% 2,76% 2,44% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 2.81 % | Single extractor |
—Wrapper (M10)Show verbatim quote (Figure 6, p.266)M8 M9 M10 M11 31% 2,81% 2,76% 2,44% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 2.76 % | Single extractor |
—Positioner (M11)Show verbatim quote (Figure 6, p.266)M8 M9 M10 M11 31% 2,81% 2,76% 2,44% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 2.44 % | Single extractor |
Fallen Bundle (Palletizer)Palletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 1, p.269)F Fallen Bundle (Palletizer) 3,60% 81,52% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of loss events | 3.60 % | Single extractor |
Bundle not Alligned (Palletizer)Palletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 5.16, p.209)MTTF(s) 602,658 293143,4 780 2070 3798,75 1016,58 MTTR(s) 17,8571 34,2857 57,5 48,75 67,5 24,335 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Time between events | 603 s | Single extractor |
Uncorrect Stratum (N°2)Palletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 5.16, p.209)MTTF(s) 602,658 293143,4 780 2070 3798,75 1016,58 MTTR(s) 17,8571 34,2857 57,5 48,75 67,5 24,335 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Time between events | 293,143 s | Single extractor |
Pallets Warehouse AllarmPalletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 5.16, p.209)MTTF(s) 602,658 293143,4 780 2070 3798,75 1016,58 MTTR(s) 17,8571 34,2857 57,5 48,75 67,5 24,335 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Time between events | 780 s | Single extractor |
Uncorrect Stratum (N°1)Palletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 5.16, p.209)MTTF(s) 602,658 293143,4 780 2070 3798,75 1016,58 MTTR(s) 17,8571 34,2857 57,5 48,75 67,5 24,335 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Time between events | 2,070 s | Single extractor |
Pallet not Alligned (Palletizer Entry)Palletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 5.16, p.209)MTTF(s) 602,658 293143,4 780 2070 3798,75 1016,58 MTTR(s) 17,8571 34,2857 57,5 48,75 67,5 24,335 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Time between events | 3,799 s | Single extractor |
—Palletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 5.16, p.209)MTTF(s) 602,658 293143,4 780 2070 3798,75 1016,58 MTTR(s) 17,8571 34,2857 57,5 48,75 67,5 24,335 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Time between events | 1,017 s | Single extractor |
Bundle not Alligned (Palletizer)Palletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 5.16, p.209)MTTF(s) 602,658 293143,4 780 2070 3798,75 1016,58 MTTR(s) 17,8571 34,2857 57,5 48,75 67,5 24,335 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Mean event duration | 17.9 s | Single extractor |
Uncorrect Stratum (N°2)Palletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 5.16, p.209)MTTF(s) 602,658 293143,4 780 2070 3798,75 1016,58 MTTR(s) 17,8571 34,2857 57,5 48,75 67,5 24,335 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Mean event duration | 34.3 s | Single extractor |
Pallets Warehouse AllarmPalletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 5.16, p.209)MTTF(s) 602,658 293143,4 780 2070 3798,75 1016,58 MTTR(s) 17,8571 34,2857 57,5 48,75 67,5 24,335 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Mean event duration | 57.5 s | Single extractor |
Uncorrect Stratum (N°1)Palletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 5.16, p.209)MTTF(s) 602,658 293143,4 780 2070 3798,75 1016,58 MTTR(s) 17,8571 34,2857 57,5 48,75 67,5 24,335 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Mean event duration | 48.8 s | Single extractor |
Pallet not Alligned (Palletizer Entry)Palletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 5.16, p.209)MTTF(s) 602,658 293143,4 780 2070 3798,75 1016,58 MTTR(s) 17,8571 34,2857 57,5 48,75 67,5 24,335 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Mean event duration | 67.5 s | Single extractor |
—Palletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 5.16, p.209)MTTF(s) 602,658 293143,4 780 2070 3798,75 1016,58 MTTR(s) 17,8571 34,2857 57,5 48,75 67,5 24,335 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Mean event duration | 24.3 s | Single extractor |
Bundle not Alligned (Palletizer)Palletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 1 (TTF descriptive statistics), p.266)A 168 566.8 761.2 1.343 0 6240 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Number of events | 168 events | Single extractor |
Uncorrect Stratum (N°2)Palletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 1 (TTF descriptive statistics), p.266)B 7 2931 2925 0.9978 180 8160 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Number of events | 7.00 events | Single extractor |
Pallets Warehouse AllarmPalletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 1 (TTF descriptive statistics), p.266)C 4 780 467 0.5991 240 1200 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Number of events | 4.00 events | Single extractor |
Uncorrect Stratum (N°1)Palletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 1 (TTF descriptive statistics), p.266)D 8 2070 1546 0.7471 540 4680 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Number of events | 8.00 events | Single extractor |
Pallet not Alligned (Palletizer Entry)Palletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 1 (TTF descriptive statistics), p.266)E 16 3799 3082 0.8114 360 9420 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Number of events | 16.0 events | Single extractor |
Lack bottles in entrancePalletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 2, p.281)Lack bottles in entrance 694,38 32,46% 32,46% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Lost time | 694 min | Single extractor |
Lack bottles in entrancePalletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 2, p.281)Lack bottles in entrance 694,38 32,46% 32,46% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 32.5 % | Single extractor |
Output Transports fullPalletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 2, p.281)Output Transports full 615,10 28,75% 61,21% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Lost time | 615 min | Single extractor |
Output Transports fullPalletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 2, p.281)Output Transports full 615,10 28,75% 61,21% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 28.8 % | Single extractor |
Bottles not aligned in entrancePalletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 2, p.281)Bottles not aligned in entrance 218,67 10,22% 71,43% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Lost time | 219 min | Single extractor |
Bottles not aligned in entrancePalletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 2, p.281)Bottles not aligned in entrance 218,67 10,22% 71,43% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 10.2 % | Single extractor |
Pallet not allignedPalletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 2, p.281)Pallet not alligned 130,58 6,10% 77,53% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Lost time | 131 min | Single extractor |
Pallet not allignedPalletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 2, p.281)Pallet not alligned 130,58 6,10% 77,53% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 6.10 % | Single extractor |
Products layer uncorrectPalletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 2, p.281)Products layer uncorrect 108,00 5,05% 82,58% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Lost time | 108 min | Single extractor |
Products layer uncorrectPalletizer (M1)Show verbatim quote (Table 2, p.281)Products layer uncorrect 108,00 5,05% 82,58% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 5.05 % | Single extractor |
Micro downtimeShow verbatim quote (page 114)with an average of 57%, the principal cause is micro downtime. This means that the 57% of the line inefficiency (in terms of minutes of production lost) is caused by micro downtimes. | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 57.0 % | Single extractor |
Observation units
- Palletizer (M1) · Packaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing) · Baseline
- Line D · Whole line or unspecified equipment · Baseline

