foratvise
Get Started
Included study

Six Sigma application in an Irish meat processing plant to improve process yields

Open source

1Bibliographic record

Authors
Rebecca Gilligan, Rachel Moran, Olivia McDermott
Year
2023
Venue
The TQM Journal
Country
Ireland
Segment
Meat, poultry and seafood
Process family
Slaughter, cutting and primary processing
Study type
Before/after intervention
Extraction scope
Full text
Size
1 plants · 1 lines · — machines
Observation period
—
Data collection
manual_logs
Intervention
Show the setting as described by the study
The case study organisation where this research was undertaken was within the boning hall of a red meat processing plant based in Ireland.

2Risk of bias

Scored with the rubric of the protocol: 2 low concern, 1 some concerns, 0 high concern.
Total score 7High risk
ItemScore
Is the observed line, machine or plant described well enough to classify its segment, process and equipment?Product, process and equipment are all described.2 / 2
Is the observation period long enough and reported?Period not reported.0 / 2
How were loss data collected?Manual logs or maintenance records with unknown completeness.1 / 2
Are OEE, loading time and the loss categories defined explicitly?No definition; metrics are reported as bare numbers.0 / 2
Does the loss breakdown account for the total loss it claims to explain?Only selected causes are reported and the total is unknown.0 / 2
Is there evidence of selective reporting of favourable results?Intervention study in which baseline and post-intervention periods differ in length or method.1 / 2
Are the reported numbers internally consistent?Small inconsistencies (2 to 10 percentage points) or values that cannot be cross-checked.1 / 2
Could conflicts of interest or the source of the data bias the result?Academic or independent study, or conflicts declared and unrelated to the result.2 / 2

3Extracted data

Each datum with its classification and the verbatim quote that states it.
Reported causeLoss categoryMetricValueExtraction
Customer D non-conforming at LSL
Show verbatim quote (Table 3)
D | non-conforming at the lower specification limit at 84 and 88%, respectively
Process defects (scrap and rework)Defect rate88.0 %Both extractors agreed
Customer C non-conforming at LSL
Show verbatim quote (Table 3)
C | non-conforming at the lower specification limit at 84 and 88%, respectively
Process defects (scrap and rework)Defect rate84.0 %Both extractors agreed
Customer C non-conforming below LSL
Show verbatim quote (Table 3)
C | 100% non-conforming, where the results fell largely below the lower specification limit. No over-trimming
Process defects (scrap and rework)Defect rate100 %Both extractors agreed
Customer C non-conforming, left skewed toward LSL
Show verbatim quote (Table 3)
C | 20% were non-conforming within the specifications left skewed of the target (i.e. the non-conforming longissimus dorsi were found towards the lower limit (LSL)
Process defects (scrap and rework)Defect rate20.0 %Both extractors agreed
Customer E outside specification
Show verbatim quote (Table 3)
E | 20% outside specifications
Process defects (scrap and rework)Defect rate20.0 %Both extractors agreed
Customer A non-conforming at USL
Show verbatim quote (Table 3)
Outlier observed A customer specification – however, it was the most conforming specification, with only 16% non-conforming in the USL
Process defects (scrap and rework)Defect rate16.0 %Single extractor
Customer A outliers non-conforming
Show verbatim quote (Table 3)
A | Outliers - 100% non-conforming with the specification requirements
Process defects (scrap and rework)Defect rate100 %Single extractor
Customer E non-conforming, right skewed toward USL
Show verbatim quote (Table 3)
E | 20% were non-conforming within the specifications -Right skewed of the target (i.e. that non-conforming were found towards the upper specification limit (USL))
Process defects (scrap and rework)Defect rate20.0 %Single extractor
over-trimming
Show verbatim quote (Table 6, page 20)
gluteus medius tails 7 0.35 0.79
Process defects (scrap and rework)Lost time0.350 kgSingle extractor
over-trimming
Show verbatim quote (Table 6, page 20)
longissimus dorsi tails 12 0.38 4.52
Process defects (scrap and rework)Lost time0.380 kgSingle extractor

Observation units

  • gluteus medius tails · Cutting, slicing and deboning · Baseline
  • longissimus dorsi tails · Cutting, slicing and deboning · Baseline
  • longissimus dorsi backstrap · Cutting, slicing and deboning · Baseline
  • Boning Hall · Cutting, slicing and deboning · Baseline