Included study
Six Sigma application in an Irish meat processing plant to improve process yields
1Bibliographic record
- Authors
- Rebecca Gilligan, Rachel Moran, Olivia McDermott
- Year
- 2023
- Venue
- The TQM Journal
- Country
- Ireland
- Segment
- Meat, poultry and seafood
- Process family
- Slaughter, cutting and primary processing
- Study type
- Before/after intervention
- Extraction scope
- Full text
- Size
- 1 plants · 1 lines · — machines
- Observation period
- —
- Data collection
- manual_logs
- Intervention
Show the setting as described by the study
The case study organisation where this research was undertaken was within the boning hall of a red meat processing plant based in Ireland.
2Risk of bias
Scored with the rubric of the protocol: 2 low concern, 1 some concerns, 0 high concern.
Total score 7High risk
| Item | Score |
|---|---|
| Is the observed line, machine or plant described well enough to classify its segment, process and equipment?Product, process and equipment are all described. | 2 / 2 |
| Is the observation period long enough and reported?Period not reported. | 0 / 2 |
| How were loss data collected?Manual logs or maintenance records with unknown completeness. | 1 / 2 |
| Are OEE, loading time and the loss categories defined explicitly?No definition; metrics are reported as bare numbers. | 0 / 2 |
| Does the loss breakdown account for the total loss it claims to explain?Only selected causes are reported and the total is unknown. | 0 / 2 |
| Is there evidence of selective reporting of favourable results?Intervention study in which baseline and post-intervention periods differ in length or method. | 1 / 2 |
| Are the reported numbers internally consistent?Small inconsistencies (2 to 10 percentage points) or values that cannot be cross-checked. | 1 / 2 |
| Could conflicts of interest or the source of the data bias the result?Academic or independent study, or conflicts declared and unrelated to the result. | 2 / 2 |
3Extracted data
Each datum with its classification and the verbatim quote that states it.
| Reported cause | Loss category | Metric | Value | Extraction |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Customer D non-conforming at LSLShow verbatim quote (Table 3)D | non-conforming at the lower specification limit at 84 and 88%, respectively | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Defect rate | 88.0 % | Both extractors agreed |
Customer C non-conforming at LSLShow verbatim quote (Table 3)C | non-conforming at the lower specification limit at 84 and 88%, respectively | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Defect rate | 84.0 % | Both extractors agreed |
Customer C non-conforming below LSLShow verbatim quote (Table 3)C | 100% non-conforming, where the results fell largely below the lower specification limit. No over-trimming | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Defect rate | 100 % | Both extractors agreed |
Customer C non-conforming, left skewed toward LSLShow verbatim quote (Table 3)C | 20% were non-conforming within the specifications left skewed of the target (i.e. the non-conforming longissimus dorsi were found towards the lower limit (LSL) | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Defect rate | 20.0 % | Both extractors agreed |
Customer E outside specificationShow verbatim quote (Table 3)E | 20% outside specifications | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Defect rate | 20.0 % | Both extractors agreed |
Customer A non-conforming at USLShow verbatim quote (Table 3)Outlier observed A customer specification – however, it was the most conforming specification, with only 16% non-conforming in the USL | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Defect rate | 16.0 % | Single extractor |
Customer A outliers non-conformingShow verbatim quote (Table 3)A | Outliers - 100% non-conforming with the specification requirements | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Defect rate | 100 % | Single extractor |
Customer E non-conforming, right skewed toward USLShow verbatim quote (Table 3)E | 20% were non-conforming within the specifications -Right skewed of the target (i.e. that non-conforming were found towards the upper specification limit (USL)) | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Defect rate | 20.0 % | Single extractor |
over-trimmingShow verbatim quote (Table 6, page 20)gluteus medius tails 7 0.35 0.79 | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Lost time | 0.350 kg | Single extractor |
over-trimmingShow verbatim quote (Table 6, page 20)longissimus dorsi tails 12 0.38 4.52 | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Lost time | 0.380 kg | Single extractor |
Observation units
- gluteus medius tails · Cutting, slicing and deboning · Baseline
- longissimus dorsi tails · Cutting, slicing and deboning · Baseline
- longissimus dorsi backstrap · Cutting, slicing and deboning · Baseline
- Boning Hall · Cutting, slicing and deboning · Baseline

