foratvise
Get Started
Included study

Integrating Lean Manufacturing and TPM for Process Optimization in Bakery SMEs: A Case Study from Peru

Open source

1Bibliographic record

Authors
Roger Alberto Vásquez-García, Rubén Francisco Samanez-Coronel
Year
2024
Venue
International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Operations Management (IEOM)
Country
Peru
Segment
Bakery and pasta
Process family
Forming, baking and cooking
Study type
Before/after intervention
Extraction scope
Full text
Size
1 plants · — lines · — machines
Observation period
120 days
Data collection
maintenance_records
Intervention
Show the setting as described by the study
The validation scenario took place in a case study involving a bakery SME located in Peru, which specialized in producing various pastries and desserts, including cakes and soufflés.

2Risk of bias

Scored with the rubric of the protocol: 2 low concern, 1 some concerns, 0 high concern.
Total score 7High risk
ItemScore
Is the observed line, machine or plant described well enough to classify its segment, process and equipment?Product or sector is given but the equipment or process is only partly described.1 / 2
Is the observation period long enough and reported?Period reported and at least 30 days of production (or at least 100 recorded events).2 / 2
How were loss data collected?Interviews, estimates, or method not reported.0 / 2
Are OEE, loading time and the loss categories defined explicitly?A standard definition is cited but its application is not shown.1 / 2
Does the loss breakdown account for the total loss it claims to explain?Only selected causes are reported and the total is unknown.0 / 2
Is there evidence of selective reporting of favourable results?Intervention study in which baseline and post-intervention periods differ in length or method.1 / 2
Are the reported numbers internally consistent?Small inconsistencies (2 to 10 percentage points) or values that cannot be cross-checked.1 / 2
Could conflicts of interest or the source of the data bias the result?Authors are employees of the plant or of an equipment/software vendor; no declaration.1 / 2

3Extracted data

Each datum with its classification and the verbatim quote that states it.
Reported causeLoss categoryMetricValueExtraction
—ovens and mixing machines
Show verbatim quote (Section 4.4)
The MTBF (mean time between failures) increased from 24.33 hours to 61.33 hours, representing a 150% improvement in equipment reliability.
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Time between events61.3 hoursBoth extractors agreed
—ovens and mixing machines
Show verbatim quote (Section 4.4)
The MTTR (mean time to repair) improved from 5.10 hours in September to 3.33 hours by December, a 35% reduction.
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Mean event duration3.33 hoursBoth extractors agreed
cakes that were overbaked or underbaked due to oven temperature fluctuationsovens
Show verbatim quote (Section 4.4)
Before maintenance training, the number of defective products, particularly cakes that were overbaked or underbaked due to oven temperature fluctuations, averaged 30 units per month.
Process defects (scrap and rework)Number of events30.0 units/monthBoth extractors agreed
defective cakes due to improper procedures
Show verbatim quote (Section 4.5)
The percentage of defective cakes due to improper procedures dropped from 9.52% to 3.85%, a reduction of over 60%.
Process defects (scrap and rework)Defect rate3.85 %Both extractors agreed
defective cakes due to improper procedures
Show verbatim quote (Section 4.5)
The percentage of defective cakes due to improper procedures dropped from 9.52% to 3.85%, a reduction of over 60%.
Process defects (scrap and rework)Defect rate9.52 %Both extractors agreed
cakes that were overbaked or underbaked due to oven temperature fluctuationsovens
Show verbatim quote (Section 4.4)
This number dropped to 12 units per month after the operators were trained to monitor and maintain the ovens more effectively.
Process defects (scrap and rework)Number of events12.0 units/monthBoth extractors agreed
—ovens and mixing machines
Show verbatim quote (Section 4.4)
Prior to implementation, the bakery experienced an average of 101.15 minutes of machine downtime per week, resulting in the loss of 17 products per month.
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time101 min/weekBoth extractors agreed
—ovens and mixing machines
Show verbatim quote (Section 4.4)
The MTTR (mean time to repair) improved from 5.10 hours in September to 3.33 hours by December, a 35% reduction.
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Mean event duration5.10 hoursSingle extractor
—ovens and mixing machines
Show verbatim quote (Table 1)
MTTR hours 4.27 3.5 3.33 -22.01%
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Mean event duration4.27 hoursSingle extractor
—ovens and mixing machines
Show verbatim quote (Section 4.4)
The MTBF (mean time between failures) increased from 24.33 hours to 61.33 hours, representing a 150% improvement in equipment reliability.
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Time between events24.3 hoursSingle extractor
—
Show verbatim quote (Table 1)
Rate of reprocessed products % 23% 10% 13% -43.48%
Process defects (scrap and rework)Defect rate23.0 %Single extractor
—
Show verbatim quote (Table 1)
Rate of reprocessed products % 23% 10% 13% -43.48%
Process defects (scrap and rework)Defect rate13.0 %Single extractor
—
Show verbatim quote (Table 1, Results section, page 10-11)
the rate of order fulfillment improved significantly, rising from 77.81% to 91.23%
noneShare of planned time77.8 %Single extractor
searching for production tools and materials
Show verbatim quote (Section 4.3, page 11)
the time spent searching for tools decreased from an average of 77 minutes per shift to 29 minutes, a 62% reduction
Organizational or external stops (material or personnel shortage, utilities outage)Lost time77.0 minutesSingle extractor
oven overheating/shutdown, mixing machine blockagesovens, mixing machines
Show verbatim quote (Section 4.4, page 9)
an average of 101.15 minutes of machine downtime per week, resulting in the loss of 17 products per month
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events17.0 unitsSingle extractor
—
Show verbatim quote (Table 1, Results section, page 10-11)
the rate of order fulfillment improved significantly, rising from 77.81% to 91.23%
noneShare of planned time91.2 %Single extractor
searching for production tools and materials - after 5S implementation
Show verbatim quote (Section 4.3, page 11)
the time spent searching for tools decreased from an average of 77 minutes per shift to 29 minutes, a 62% reduction
Organizational or external stops (material or personnel shortage, utilities outage)Lost time29.0 minutesSingle extractor
oven overheating/shutdown, mixing machine blockages - after autonomous maintenance trainingovens, mixing machines
Show verbatim quote (Section 4.4, page 9)
reducing monthly product losses from 17 to 5
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events5.00 unitsSingle extractor

Observation units

  • Bakery SME - whole plant · Whole line or unspecified equipment · After intervention
  • Bakery SME - whole plant · Whole line or unspecified equipment · Baseline
  • Bakery SME (Peru) · Whole line or unspecified equipment · Baseline
  • Bakery SME (Peru) · Whole line or unspecified equipment · After intervention