Eingeschlossene Studie
Revitalising the setup reduction activities in Operations Management
1Bibliografische Angaben
- Autoren
- Diego Augusto de Jesús Pacheco, Giovana Di Giorgio Heidrich
- Jahr
- 2021
- Publikationsorgan
- Production Planning & Control
- Land
- Brazil
- Segment
- Erfrischungsgetränke, abgefülltes Wasser und Säfte
- Prozessfamilie
- Abfüll- und Verpackungslinie
- Studientyp
- Vorher-nachher-Intervention
- Extraktionsumfang
- Volltext
- Umfang
- 1 Werke · 1 Linien · 4 Maschinen
- Beobachtungszeitraum
- 549 Tage
- Datenerhebung
- manual_logs
- Intervention
Umfeld laut Studie anzeigen
The beverage company where the research was conducted has been operating in Brazil since 2013 with roughly 70 employees and a plant capacity of 50.000 hectoliters/month covering three bottling production lines, according to the type of products.
2Verzerrungsrisiko
Bewertet nach dem Schema des Protokolls: 2 geringe Bedenken, 1 einige Bedenken, 0 hohe Bedenken.
Gesamtpunktzahl 12Mittleres Risiko
| Kriterium | Punkte |
|---|---|
| Is the observed line, machine or plant described well enough to classify its segment, process and equipment?Product, process and equipment are all described. | 2 / 2 |
| Is the observation period long enough and reported?Period reported and at least 30 days of production (or at least 100 recorded events). | 2 / 2 |
| How were loss data collected?Manual logs or maintenance records with unknown completeness. | 1 / 2 |
| Are OEE, loading time and the loss categories defined explicitly?A standard definition is cited but its application is not shown. | 1 / 2 |
| Does the loss breakdown account for the total loss it claims to explain?Only the top causes are reported and the unexplained remainder can be computed. | 1 / 2 |
| Is there evidence of selective reporting of favourable results?Observational study, or intervention study that reports baseline and post-intervention data with the same method. | 2 / 2 |
| Are the reported numbers internally consistent?Recomputed totals, shares and OEE factors agree with the reported values within 2 percentage points. | 2 / 2 |
| Could conflicts of interest or the source of the data bias the result?Authors are employees of the plant or of an equipment/software vendor; no declaration. | 1 / 2 |
3Extrahierte Daten
Jeder Datenpunkt mit seiner Einordnung und dem wörtlichen Zitat, das ihn belegt.
| Berichtete Ursache | Verlustkategorie | Kennzahl | Wert | Extraktion |
|---|---|---|---|---|
—Labelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.2)These values are: Availability (Jul/16: 94.68%; Aug/2016: 94.72%; Sep/2016: 94.77%), Quality (Jul/16: 99.57%; Aug/2016: 99.60%; Sep/2016: 99.65%) and Performance (Jul/16: 99.80%; Aug/2016: 99.85%; Sep/2016: 99.87%). | none | Leistung | 99,9 % | Beide Extraktionen übereinstimmend |
—Labelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.2)These values are: Availability (Jul/16: 94.68%; Aug/2016: 94.72%; Sep/2016: 94.77%), Quality (Jul/16: 99.57%; Aug/2016: 99.60%; Sep/2016: 99.65%) and Performance (Jul/16: 99.80%; Aug/2016: 99.85%; Sep/2016: 99.87%). | none | Qualität | 99,7 % | Beide Extraktionen übereinstimmend |
—Labelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.2)These values are: Availability (Jul/16: 94.68%; Aug/2016: 94.72%; Sep/2016: 94.77%), Quality (Jul/16: 99.57%; Aug/2016: 99.60%; Sep/2016: 99.65%) and Performance (Jul/16: 99.80%; Aug/2016: 99.85%; Sep/2016: 99.87%). | none | Verfügbarkeit | 94,8 % | Beide Extraktionen übereinstimmend |
—Labelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.2 / Fig. 6)Consequently, the OEE ratio of the labelling machine was improved by 33.8% (1-62.4/94.3), as displayed in Fig. 6. | none | OEE | 94,3 % | Beide Extraktionen übereinstimmend |
—Labelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.2 / Fig. 6)Consequently, the OEE ratio of the labelling machine was improved by 33.8% (1-62.4/94.3), as displayed in Fig. 6. | none | OEE | 62,4 % | Beide Extraktionen übereinstimmend |
—Labelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.2 / Fig. 5)The outcome analysis showed improvements in Availability rate of approximately 19% (1-76.8/94.8), Performance of 12.7% (1-87.2/99.9) and Quality of 6.5% (1-93.2/99.7). | none | Qualität | 93,2 % | Beide Extraktionen übereinstimmend |
—Labelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.2 / Fig. 5)The outcome analysis showed improvements in Availability rate of approximately 19% (1-76.8/94.8), Performance of 12.7% (1-87.2/99.9) and Quality of 6.5% (1-93.2/99.7). | none | Leistung | 87,2 % | Beide Extraktionen übereinstimmend |
—Labelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.2 / Fig. 5)The outcome analysis showed improvements in Availability rate of approximately 19% (1-76.8/94.8), Performance of 12.7% (1-87.2/99.9) and Quality of 6.5% (1-93.2/99.7). | none | Verfügbarkeit | 76,8 % | Beide Extraktionen übereinstimmend |
—Wörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.2 / Fig. 7)The data collection outcomes (Fig. 7) showed that the line’s OEE obtained an actual improvement of approximately 17% (1-72.3/87.5). | none | OEE | 87,5 % | Beide Extraktionen übereinstimmend |
—Wörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.2 / Fig. 7)The data collection outcomes (Fig. 7) showed that the line’s OEE obtained an actual improvement of approximately 17% (1-72.3/87.5). | none | OEE | 72,3 % | Beide Extraktionen übereinstimmend |
—Wörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Table 2)Indicator Jul. Aug. Sept. Oct. Nov. Dec. Availability 71% 68% 72% 79% 74% 72% Performance 26% 30% 26% 20% 24% 26% Quality 3% 2% 2% 1% 2% 2% | none | Verfügbarkeit | 71,0 % | Einfache Extraktion |
—Wörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Table 2)Indicator Jul. Aug. Sept. Oct. Nov. Dec. Availability 71% 68% 72% 79% 74% 72% Performance 26% 30% 26% 20% 24% 26% Quality 3% 2% 2% 1% 2% 2% | none | Verfügbarkeit | 68,0 % | Einfache Extraktion |
—Wörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Table 2)Indicator Jul. Aug. Sept. Oct. Nov. Dec. Availability 71% 68% 72% 79% 74% 72% Performance 26% 30% 26% 20% 24% 26% Quality 3% 2% 2% 1% 2% 2% | none | Verfügbarkeit | 72,0 % | Einfache Extraktion |
—Wörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Table 2)Indicator Jul. Aug. Sept. Oct. Nov. Dec. Availability 71% 68% 72% 79% 74% 72% Performance 26% 30% 26% 20% 24% 26% Quality 3% 2% 2% 1% 2% 2% | none | Verfügbarkeit | 79,0 % | Einfache Extraktion |
—Wörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Table 2)Indicator Jul. Aug. Sept. Oct. Nov. Dec. Availability 71% 68% 72% 79% 74% 72% Performance 26% 30% 26% 20% 24% 26% Quality 3% 2% 2% 1% 2% 2% | none | Verfügbarkeit | 74,0 % | Einfache Extraktion |
—Wörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Table 2)Indicator Jul. Aug. Sept. Oct. Nov. Dec. Availability 71% 68% 72% 79% 74% 72% Performance 26% 30% 26% 20% 24% 26% Quality 3% 2% 2% 1% 2% 2% | none | Leistung | 26,0 % | Einfache Extraktion |
—Wörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Table 2)Indicator Jul. Aug. Sept. Oct. Nov. Dec. Availability 71% 68% 72% 79% 74% 72% Performance 26% 30% 26% 20% 24% 26% Quality 3% 2% 2% 1% 2% 2% | none | Leistung | 30,0 % | Einfache Extraktion |
—Wörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Table 2)Indicator Jul. Aug. Sept. Oct. Nov. Dec. Availability 71% 68% 72% 79% 74% 72% Performance 26% 30% 26% 20% 24% 26% Quality 3% 2% 2% 1% 2% 2% | none | Leistung | 20,0 % | Einfache Extraktion |
—Wörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Table 2)Indicator Jul. Aug. Sept. Oct. Nov. Dec. Availability 71% 68% 72% 79% 74% 72% Performance 26% 30% 26% 20% 24% 26% Quality 3% 2% 2% 1% 2% 2% | none | Leistung | 24,0 % | Einfache Extraktion |
—Wörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Table 2)Indicator Jul. Aug. Sept. Oct. Nov. Dec. Availability 71% 68% 72% 79% 74% 72% Performance 26% 30% 26% 20% 24% 26% Quality 3% 2% 2% 1% 2% 2% | none | Qualität | 3,00 % | Einfache Extraktion |
—Wörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Table 2)Indicator Jul. Aug. Sept. Oct. Nov. Dec. Availability 71% 68% 72% 79% 74% 72% Performance 26% 30% 26% 20% 24% 26% Quality 3% 2% 2% 1% 2% 2% | none | Qualität | 2,00 % | Einfache Extraktion |
—Wörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Table 2)Indicator Jul. Aug. Sept. Oct. Nov. Dec. Availability 71% 68% 72% 79% 74% 72% Performance 26% 30% 26% 20% 24% 26% Quality 3% 2% 2% 1% 2% 2% | none | Qualität | 1,00 % | Einfache Extraktion |
setup lossesWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 3.1 / Fig. 3)Considering the same period of time analysed, the setup losses constitute 107.5 hours and the setting losses approximately 93.2 hours. | Rüsten und Einstellen | Verlustzeit | 108 h | Einfache Extraktion |
setting lossesWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 3.1 / Fig. 3)Considering the same period of time analysed, the setup losses constitute 107.5 hours and the setting losses approximately 93.2 hours. | Rüsten und Einstellen | Verlustzeit | 93,2 h | Einfache Extraktion |
setup operationWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.2)Before the intervention, the time to conclude a setup operation was approximately 156 minutes. After the intervention, it was reduced to approximately 104 minutes. | Rüsten und Einstellen | Mittlere Ereignisdauer | 156 min | Einfache Extraktion |
—Wörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.2)Considering that the production line performs an average of 8 setups operations per month and that the productive capacity of the labelling machine is, on average, 7.000 units/hour | Rüsten und Einstellen | Anzahl der Ereignisse | 8,00 events/month | Einfache Extraktion |
—Wörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.3)The size of the production lots for the manufactured products of the line (510 ml bottles and 1.500 ml bottles with/without gas) before the intervention was on average 161.450 units/month | none | Durchsatz | 161.450 units/month | Einfache Extraktion |
setup operationWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.2)Before the intervention, the time to conclude a setup operation was approximately 156 minutes. After the intervention, it was reduced to approximately 104 minutes. | Rüsten und Einstellen | Mittlere Ereignisdauer | 104 min | Einfache Extraktion |
—Wörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.3)while after the intervention and stabilisation of the new work processes implemented, the outcomes achieved a more economical production of small batch sizes, decreased to an average of 89.512 units/month | none | Durchsatz | 89.512 units/month | Einfache Extraktion |
Setup timeLabelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Table 3)Blowing machine Filling machine Labelling machine (bottleneck resource) Packaging machine 85 minutes 69 minutes 148 minutes 97 minutes 57 minutes 73 minutes 0 minutes 51 minutes | Rüsten und Einstellen | Mittlere Ereignisdauer | 148 min | Einfache Extraktion |
Idle timeLabelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Table 3)Blowing machine Filling machine Labelling machine (bottleneck resource) Packaging machine 85 minutes 69 minutes 148 minutes 97 minutes 57 minutes 73 minutes 0 minutes 51 minutes | Leerlauf und Kurzstillstände | Mittlere Ereignisdauer | 0 min | Einfache Extraktion |
equipment setupLabelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.1 / Fig. 4)In short, our results showed that before the method made its mark, the equipment setup averaged 148 minutes, and after the implementation, the setup time decreased to two digits, approximately 19 minutes (Fig. 4). | Rüsten und Einstellen | Mittlere Ereignisdauer | 148 min | Einfache Extraktion |
equipment setupLabelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.1 / Fig. 4)In short, our results showed that before the method made its mark, the equipment setup averaged 148 minutes, and after the implementation, the setup time decreased to two digits, approximately 19 minutes (Fig. 4). | Rüsten und Einstellen | Mittlere Ereignisdauer | 19,0 min | Einfache Extraktion |
—Labelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.2 / Fig. 5)The outcome analysis showed improvements in Availability rate of approximately 19% (1-76.8/94.8), Performance of 12.7% (1-87.2/99.9) and Quality of 6.5% (1-93.2/99.7). | none | Verfügbarkeit | 94,8 % | Einfache Extraktion |
—Labelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.2 / Fig. 5)The outcome analysis showed improvements in Availability rate of approximately 19% (1-76.8/94.8), Performance of 12.7% (1-87.2/99.9) and Quality of 6.5% (1-93.2/99.7). | none | Leistung | 99,9 % | Einfache Extraktion |
—Labelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.2 / Fig. 5)The outcome analysis showed improvements in Availability rate of approximately 19% (1-76.8/94.8), Performance of 12.7% (1-87.2/99.9) and Quality of 6.5% (1-93.2/99.7). | none | Qualität | 99,7 % | Einfache Extraktion |
—Labelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.2)These values are: Availability (Jul/16: 94.68%; Aug/2016: 94.72%; Sep/2016: 94.77%), Quality (Jul/16: 99.57%; Aug/2016: 99.60%; Sep/2016: 99.65%) and Performance (Jul/16: 99.80%; Aug/2016: 99.85%; Sep/2016: 99.87%). | none | Verfügbarkeit | 94,7 % | Einfache Extraktion |
—Labelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.2)These values are: Availability (Jul/16: 94.68%; Aug/2016: 94.72%; Sep/2016: 94.77%), Quality (Jul/16: 99.57%; Aug/2016: 99.60%; Sep/2016: 99.65%) and Performance (Jul/16: 99.80%; Aug/2016: 99.85%; Sep/2016: 99.87%). | none | Verfügbarkeit | 94,7 % | Einfache Extraktion |
—Labelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.2)These values are: Availability (Jul/16: 94.68%; Aug/2016: 94.72%; Sep/2016: 94.77%), Quality (Jul/16: 99.57%; Aug/2016: 99.60%; Sep/2016: 99.65%) and Performance (Jul/16: 99.80%; Aug/2016: 99.85%; Sep/2016: 99.87%). | none | Qualität | 99,6 % | Einfache Extraktion |
—Labelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.2)These values are: Availability (Jul/16: 94.68%; Aug/2016: 94.72%; Sep/2016: 94.77%), Quality (Jul/16: 99.57%; Aug/2016: 99.60%; Sep/2016: 99.65%) and Performance (Jul/16: 99.80%; Aug/2016: 99.85%; Sep/2016: 99.87%). | none | Qualität | 99,6 % | Einfache Extraktion |
—Labelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.2)These values are: Availability (Jul/16: 94.68%; Aug/2016: 94.72%; Sep/2016: 94.77%), Quality (Jul/16: 99.57%; Aug/2016: 99.60%; Sep/2016: 99.65%) and Performance (Jul/16: 99.80%; Aug/2016: 99.85%; Sep/2016: 99.87%). | none | Leistung | 99,8 % | Einfache Extraktion |
—Labelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Section 4.2)These values are: Availability (Jul/16: 94.68%; Aug/2016: 94.72%; Sep/2016: 94.77%), Quality (Jul/16: 99.57%; Aug/2016: 99.60%; Sep/2016: 99.65%) and Performance (Jul/16: 99.80%; Aug/2016: 99.85%; Sep/2016: 99.87%). | none | Leistung | 99,9 % | Einfache Extraktion |
Setup timeBlowing machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Table 3)Blowing machine Filling machine Labelling machine (bottleneck resource) Packaging machine 85 minutes 69 minutes 148 minutes 97 minutes 57 minutes 73 minutes 0 minutes 51 minutes | Rüsten und Einstellen | Mittlere Ereignisdauer | 85,0 min | Einfache Extraktion |
Idle timeBlowing machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Table 3)Blowing machine Filling machine Labelling machine (bottleneck resource) Packaging machine 85 minutes 69 minutes 148 minutes 97 minutes 57 minutes 73 minutes 0 minutes 51 minutes | Leerlauf und Kurzstillstände | Mittlere Ereignisdauer | 57,0 min | Einfache Extraktion |
Setup timeFilling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Table 3)Blowing machine Filling machine Labelling machine (bottleneck resource) Packaging machine 85 minutes 69 minutes 148 minutes 97 minutes 57 minutes 73 minutes 0 minutes 51 minutes | Rüsten und Einstellen | Mittlere Ereignisdauer | 69,0 min | Einfache Extraktion |
Idle timeFilling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Table 3)Blowing machine Filling machine Labelling machine (bottleneck resource) Packaging machine 85 minutes 69 minutes 148 minutes 97 minutes 57 minutes 73 minutes 0 minutes 51 minutes | Leerlauf und Kurzstillstände | Mittlere Ereignisdauer | 73,0 min | Einfache Extraktion |
Setup timePackaging machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Table 3)Blowing machine Filling machine Labelling machine (bottleneck resource) Packaging machine 85 minutes 69 minutes 148 minutes 97 minutes 57 minutes 73 minutes 0 minutes 51 minutes | Rüsten und Einstellen | Mittlere Ereignisdauer | 97,0 min | Einfache Extraktion |
Idle timePackaging machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Table 3)Blowing machine Filling machine Labelling machine (bottleneck resource) Packaging machine 85 minutes 69 minutes 148 minutes 97 minutes 57 minutes 73 minutes 0 minutes 51 minutes | Leerlauf und Kurzstillstände | Mittlere Ereignisdauer | 51,0 min | Einfache Extraktion |
—labelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Page 18, Table 3 and text)The observations revealed that the labelling machine is the equipment with the longest setup time in the line, totalling 156 (148 + 8) minutes. | Rüsten und Einstellen | Verlustzeit | 148 min | Einfache Extraktion |
—labelling machineWörtliches Zitat anzeigen (Page 26)our results showed that before the method made its mark, the equipment setup averaged 148 minutes, and after the implementation, the setup time decreased to two digits, approximately 19 minutes | Rüsten und Einstellen | Verlustzeit | 19,0 min | Einfache Extraktion |
Beobachtungseinheiten
- Labelling machine · Etikettieren und Kennzeichnen · Nach der Intervention
- Labelling machine · Etikettieren und Kennzeichnen · Ausgangslage
- Production line 3 · Gesamte Linie oder nicht spezifizierte Anlage · Nach der Intervention
- Production line 3 · Gesamte Linie oder nicht spezifizierte Anlage · Ausgangslage
- Blowing machine · Formen, Gießen und Dosieren · Ausgangslage
- Filling machine · Abfüllen · Ausgangslage
- Packaging machine · Verpacken (Formen, Siegeln, Einschlagen, Kartonieren, Palettieren) · Ausgangslage

