foratvise
Get Started
Setup and adjustments

Manual cleaning of mixing equipment during changeover

Setup and adjustmentsAvailabilityMixing and blending

In short

It appears in about 1 of every 100 lines studied.

When it appears, it takes on average about 57 % of the line's lost time. Reported by 2 of the 31 studies that could observe it (limited evidence).

What happens

Between production runs, operators must manually clean residue from different levels or sections of the mixer using tools such as brooms, vacuum cleaners, compressed air lances or torches, because the design does not allow automated or CIP-only cleaning of these areas. This hands-on task extends the time between the last good unit of one run and the first good unit of the next, as it requires access, tool retrieval and physical scrubbing before the mixer can be restarted.

What is done about it

Redesign access points and internal surfaces of the mixer to allow automated or semi-automated cleaning, such as fixed spray nozzles or CIP circuits, for areas currently cleaned by hand, and standardize cleaning procedures with dedicated tool kits staged at the equipment to reduce search and setup time. Where manual cleaning cannot be eliminated, use parallel tasking or quick-release panels to shorten the critical path of the changeover.

Practical guidance written from engineering knowledge; it is not a statistical estimate.

1Probability and evidence

Pooled over all segments. A wide interval is a result: it states how much the evidence allows us to know.
Probability of presence
1.3% [0.2–3.7%]
Expected share of lost time
0.7% [0.1–2.2%]
Share of lost time when present
57% [44–67%]
Studies / units
31 / 40
Evidence grade
C

Grade C: 2 to 4 studies, or an interval wider than 0.35.

2Probability by segment

Partially pooled estimates for each industry segment.
  • Dairy products
    1.4% [0.2–5.1%]6 studies
  • Soft drinks, bottled water and juices
    1.5% [0.2–5.4%]2 studies
  • Brewing, wine and spirits
    1.6% [0.1–5.9%]0 studies
  • Bakery and pasta
    2.1% [0.2–7.2%]2 studies
  • Meat, poultry and seafood
    1.5% [0.2–5.8%]1 study
  • Fruit and vegetable processing
    1.5% [0.2–6.2%]2 studies
  • Grain and oilseed milling
    1.6% [0.1–6.0%]0 studies
  • Sugar and confectionery
    1.5% [0.1–5.8%]3 studies
  • Snacks, coffee, tea and other foods
    2.1% [0.2–7.5%]3 studies
  • Animal feed and pet food
    1.4% [0.1–5.0%]5 studies
  • Food manufacturing (unspecified or mixed)
    1.5% [0.1–5.5%]7 studies

3Mechanism, SCADA signature and countermeasure

Engineering guidance that helps recognise and address the cause; it is not part of the statistical estimate.

Mechanism

Engineering guidance

Between production runs, operators must manually clean residue from different levels or sections of the mixer using tools such as brooms, vacuum cleaners, compressed air lances or torches, because the design does not allow automated or CIP-only cleaning of these areas. This hands-on task extends the time between the last good unit of one run and the first good unit of the next, as it requires access, tool retrieval and physical scrubbing before the mixer can be restarted.

How it looks in SCADA data

Engineering guidance

The mixer state log shows an extended changeover or stopped state with no process variable movement, often preceded by a product or recipe change event; auxiliary equipment such as agitators and discharge valves remain idle for the duration. No fault or alarm is typically logged, since the stoppage is procedural rather than a failure, and the event is usually tagged manually as cleaning or changeover time in the MES if recorded at all.

Countermeasure

Engineering guidance

Redesign access points and internal surfaces of the mixer to allow automated or semi-automated cleaning, such as fixed spray nozzles or CIP circuits, for areas currently cleaned by hand, and standardize cleaning procedures with dedicated tool kits staged at the equipment to reduce search and setup time. Where manual cleaning cannot be eliminated, use parallel tasking or quick-release panels to shorten the critical path of the changeover.

4Sources

Every extracted datum with its study, value and verbatim quote.
  1. Lost time: 188 min · as reported: “Flavour mixer cleaning and setup”
    Show verbatim quote
    Flavour mixer cleaning and setup 188 minutes
  2. Lost time: 135 min · as reported: “Oil drum cleaning and setup”
    Show verbatim quote
    Oil drum cleaning and setup 135 minutes
  3. Share of lost time: 19.0 % · as reported: “mixer washing”
    Show verbatim quote
    the total single washing time was 5 hours 3 minutes on average, which accounted for about 19% of the total retooling of the production line
  4. Mean event duration: 0.220 min · as reported: “Bring torch for cleaning of 2nd level”
    Show verbatim quote
    Bring torch for cleaning of 2nd level Operator 2 DRY Operator 2 DRY External External 0.22 0.25
  5. Mean event duration: 4.50 min · as reported: “Clean 3rd level with broom and vacuum”
    Show verbatim quote
    Clean 3rd level with broom and vacuum Operator 2 DRY Operator 2 DRY Internal Internal 4.50 2.60
  6. Mean event duration: 16.0 min · as reported: “Clean mixer at 2nd level with broom and air”
    Show verbatim quote
    Clean mixer at 2nd level with broom and air Operator 1 DRY Operator 1 DRY Internal Internal 16.00 7.80
  7. Mean event duration: 0.250 min · as reported: “Bring torch for cleaning of 2nd level”
    Show verbatim quote
    Bring torch for cleaning of 2nd level Operator 2 DRY Operator 2 DRY External External 0.22 0.25
  8. Mean event duration: 2.60 min · as reported: “Clean 3rd level with broom and vacuum”
    Show verbatim quote
    Clean 3rd level with broom and vacuum Operator 2 DRY Operator 2 DRY Internal Internal 4.50 2.60
  9. Mean event duration: 7.80 min · as reported: “Clean mixer at 2nd level with broom and air”
    Show verbatim quote
    Clean mixer at 2nd level with broom and air Operator 1 DRY Operator 1 DRY Internal Internal 16.00 7.80