foratvise
Get Started
Included study

PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF MAINTENANCE IN A MANUFACTURING INDUSTRY

Open source

1Bibliographic record

Authors
Onyejaka, Chidi Maurice, Prof. Ike, Oluka
Year
2023
Venue
—
Country
Nigeria
Segment
Soft drinks, bottled water and juices
Process family
Filling and packaging line
Study type
Multiple case study
Extraction scope
Full text
Size
2 plants · 2 lines · 5 machines
Observation period
1,825 days
Data collection
questionnaire
Intervention
Show the setting as described by the study
This was a retrospective study of performance evaluation of maintenance of Nigerian Bottling Company Ltd (coca cola) Benin Plant and BONS INDUSTRIES Ltd, Enugu from 2017 – 2021.

2Risk of bias

Scored with the rubric of the protocol: 2 low concern, 1 some concerns, 0 high concern.
Total score 10Moderate risk
ItemScore
Is the observed line, machine or plant described well enough to classify its segment, process and equipment?Product, process and equipment are all described.2 / 2
Is the observation period long enough and reported?Period reported and at least 30 days of production (or at least 100 recorded events).2 / 2
How were loss data collected?Manual logs or maintenance records with unknown completeness.1 / 2
Are OEE, loading time and the loss categories defined explicitly?A standard definition is cited but its application is not shown.1 / 2
Does the loss breakdown account for the total loss it claims to explain?Only selected causes are reported and the total is unknown.0 / 2
Is there evidence of selective reporting of favourable results?Observational study, or intervention study that reports baseline and post-intervention data with the same method.2 / 2
Are the reported numbers internally consistent?Inconsistencies above 10 percentage points, or OEE factors above 100%.0 / 2
Could conflicts of interest or the source of the data bias the result?Academic or independent study, or conflicts declared and unrelated to the result.2 / 2

3Extracted data

Each datum with its classification and the verbatim quote that states it.
Reported causeLoss categoryMetricValueExtraction
—Filler machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Show verbatim quote (Figure 4 / text)
performance rate was least in year four (2020 (66.2%) while it was highest in year three (129%)
nonePerformance66.2 %Both extractors agreed
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 7)
Year One (2017) 93.5% 103% 99%
noneAvailability93.5 %Both extractors agreed
breakdownFiller machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Show verbatim quote (Table 2)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 123.66 107.33 146.33 153.4 108.5
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time124 hSingle extractor
breakdownFiller machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Show verbatim quote (Table 2)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 123.66 107.33 146.33 153.4 108.5
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time107 hSingle extractor
breakdownFiller machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Show verbatim quote (Table 2)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 123.66 107.33 146.33 153.4 108.5
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time146 hSingle extractor
breakdownFiller machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Show verbatim quote (Table 2)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 123.66 107.33 146.33 153.4 108.5
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time153 hSingle extractor
breakdownFiller machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Show verbatim quote (Table 2)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 123.66 107.33 146.33 153.4 108.5
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time109 hSingle extractor
—Filler machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Show verbatim quote (Figure 3)
95.0% 96.0% 96.0% 93.0% 96.9%
noneAvailability95.0 %Single extractor
—Filler machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Show verbatim quote (Figure 3)
95.0% 96.0% 96.0% 93.0% 96.9%
noneAvailability96.0 %Single extractor
—Filler machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Show verbatim quote (Figure 3)
95.0% 96.0% 96.0% 93.0% 96.9%
noneAvailability93.0 %Single extractor
—Filler machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Show verbatim quote (Figure 3 / text)
The availability rate was highest in the year five 96.9% while it was lowest in year four (93.0%)
noneAvailability96.9 %Single extractor
—Filler machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Show verbatim quote (Figure 4)
104.1% 108.3% 129.3% 66.2% 113.6%
nonePerformance104 %Single extractor
—Filler machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Show verbatim quote (Figure 4)
104.1% 108.3% 129.3% 66.2% 113.6%
nonePerformance108 %Single extractor
—Filler machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Show verbatim quote (Figure 4 / text)
performance rate was least in year four (2020 (66.2%) while it was highest in year three (129%)
nonePerformance129 %Single extractor
—Filler machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Show verbatim quote (Figure 4)
104.1% 108.3% 129.3% 66.2% 113.6%
nonePerformance114 %Single extractor
—Filler machine (Krones 1650CPH)
Show verbatim quote (Table 4)
Year one (2017) 99.9
noneQuality99.9 %Single extractor
breakdownPacker/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 5)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 154.5 117.66 158.3 264.5 128.6
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time155 hSingle extractor
breakdownPacker/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 5)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 154.5 117.66 158.3 264.5 128.6
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time118 hSingle extractor
breakdownPacker/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 5)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 154.5 117.66 158.3 264.5 128.6
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time158 hSingle extractor
breakdownPacker/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 5)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 154.5 117.66 158.3 264.5 128.6
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time265 hSingle extractor
breakdownPacker/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 5)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 154.5 117.66 158.3 264.5 128.6
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time129 hSingle extractor
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 7)
Year One (2017) 93.5% 103% 99%
nonePerformance103 %Single extractor
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 7)
Year One (2017) 93.5% 103% 99%
noneQuality99.0 %Single extractor
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 7)
Year Two (2018) 95.2% 105% 99%
noneAvailability95.2 %Single extractor
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 7)
Year Two (2018) 95.2% 105% 99%
nonePerformance105 %Single extractor
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 7)
Year Three (2019) 95.6% 108% 99%
noneAvailability95.6 %Single extractor
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 7)
Year Three (2019) 95.6% 108% 99%
nonePerformance108 %Single extractor
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 7)
Year Four (2020) 87.0% 66.2% 99%
noneAvailability87.0 %Single extractor
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 7)
Year Four (2020) 87.0% 66.2% 99%
nonePerformance66.2 %Single extractor
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 7)
Year Five (2021) 96.3% 103% 99%
noneAvailability96.3 %Single extractor
breakdownBlow Mould
Show verbatim quote (Table 8)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 125 130 227 397 132
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time125 hSingle extractor
breakdownBlow Mould
Show verbatim quote (Table 8)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 125 130 227 397 132
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time130 hSingle extractor
breakdownBlow Mould
Show verbatim quote (Table 8)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 125 130 227 397 132
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time227 hSingle extractor
breakdownBlow Mould
Show verbatim quote (Table 8)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 125 130 227 397 132
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time397 hSingle extractor
breakdownBlow Mould
Show verbatim quote (Table 8)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 125 130 227 397 132
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time132 hSingle extractor
—Blow Mould
Show verbatim quote (Table 10)
Year One (2017) 95.8% 80.5% 97.2%
noneAvailability95.8 %Single extractor
—Blow Mould
Show verbatim quote (Table 10)
Year One (2017) 95.8% 80.5% 97.2%
nonePerformance80.5 %Single extractor
—Blow Mould
Show verbatim quote (Table 10)
Year One (2017) 95.8% 80.5% 97.2%
noneQuality97.2 %Single extractor
—Blow Mould
Show verbatim quote (Table 10)
Year Two (2018) 95.0% 85.1% 96.8%
noneAvailability95.0 %Single extractor
—Blow Mould
Show verbatim quote (Table 10)
Year Two (2018) 95.0% 85.1% 96.8%
nonePerformance85.1 %Single extractor
—Blow Mould
Show verbatim quote (Table 10)
Year Two (2018) 95.0% 85.1% 96.8%
noneQuality96.8 %Single extractor
—Blow Mould
Show verbatim quote (Table 10)
Year Three (2019) 92.4% 89.2% 96.3%
noneAvailability92.4 %Single extractor
—Blow Mould
Show verbatim quote (Table 10)
Year Three (2019) 92.4% 89.2% 96.3%
nonePerformance89.2 %Single extractor
—Blow Mould
Show verbatim quote (Table 10)
Year Three (2019) 92.4% 89.2% 96.3%
noneQuality96.3 %Single extractor
—Blow Mould
Show verbatim quote (Table 10)
Year Four (2020) 86.8% 46.7% 96.1%
noneAvailability86.8 %Single extractor
—Blow Mould
Show verbatim quote (Table 10)
Year Four (2020) 86.8% 46.7% 96.1%
nonePerformance46.7 %Single extractor
—Blow Mould
Show verbatim quote (Table 10)
Year Four (2020) 86.8% 46.7% 96.1%
noneQuality96.1 %Single extractor
—Blow Mould
Show verbatim quote (Table 10)
Year Five (2021) 95.6% 82.0% 95.1%
noneAvailability95.6 %Single extractor
—Blow Mould
Show verbatim quote (Table 10)
Year Five (2021) 95.6% 82.0% 95.1%
nonePerformance82.0 %Single extractor
—Blow Mould
Show verbatim quote (Table 10)
Year Five (2021) 95.6% 82.0% 95.1%
noneQuality95.1 %Single extractor
breakdownMonobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Show verbatim quote (Table 11)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 120 130 217.5 386 114.5
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time120 hSingle extractor
breakdownMonobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Show verbatim quote (Table 11)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 120 130 217.5 386 114.5
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time130 hSingle extractor
breakdownMonobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Show verbatim quote (Table 11)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 120 130 217.5 386 114.5
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time218 hSingle extractor
breakdownMonobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Show verbatim quote (Table 11)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 120 130 217.5 386 114.5
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time386 hSingle extractor
breakdownMonobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Show verbatim quote (Table 11)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 120 130 217.5 386 114.5
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time115 hSingle extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Show verbatim quote (Figure 5)
95.8% 95.0% 92.4% 86.8% 95.6%
noneAvailability95.8 %Single extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Show verbatim quote (Figure 5)
95.8% 95.0% 92.4% 86.8% 95.6%
noneAvailability95.0 %Single extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Show verbatim quote (Figure 5)
95.8% 95.0% 92.4% 86.8% 95.6%
noneAvailability92.4 %Single extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Show verbatim quote (Figure 5)
95.8% 95.0% 92.4% 86.8% 95.6%
noneAvailability86.8 %Single extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Show verbatim quote (Figure 5)
95.8% 95.0% 92.4% 86.8% 95.6%
noneAvailability95.6 %Single extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Show verbatim quote (Figure 6)
93.9% 94.1% 88.8% 47.2% 96.1%
nonePerformance93.9 %Single extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Show verbatim quote (Figure 6)
93.9% 94.1% 88.8% 47.2% 96.1%
nonePerformance94.1 %Single extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Show verbatim quote (Figure 6)
93.9% 94.1% 88.8% 47.2% 96.1%
nonePerformance88.8 %Single extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Show verbatim quote (Figure 6)
93.9% 94.1% 88.8% 47.2% 96.1%
nonePerformance47.2 %Single extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Show verbatim quote (Figure 6)
93.9% 94.1% 88.8% 47.2% 96.1%
nonePerformance96.1 %Single extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Show verbatim quote (Table 13)
Year One (2017) 93.5%
noneQuality93.5 %Single extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Show verbatim quote (Table 13)
Year Two (2018) 93.7%
noneQuality93.7 %Single extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Show verbatim quote (Table 13)
Year Three (2019) 92.0%
noneQuality92.0 %Single extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Show verbatim quote (Table 13)
Year Four (2020) 92.4%
noneQuality92.4 %Single extractor
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser)
Show verbatim quote (Table 13)
Year Five (2021) 91.8%
noneQuality91.8 %Single extractor
breakdownPacker/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 14)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 321.5 165.8 285.5 364.3 216
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time322 hSingle extractor
breakdownPacker/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 14)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 321.5 165.8 285.5 364.3 216
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time166 hSingle extractor
breakdownPacker/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 14)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 321.5 165.8 285.5 364.3 216
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time286 hSingle extractor
breakdownPacker/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 14)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 321.5 165.8 285.5 364.3 216
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time364 hSingle extractor
breakdownPacker/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 14)
Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 321.5 165.8 285.5 364.3 216
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time216 hSingle extractor
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 16)
Year One (2017) 89.0% 83.8% 91.7%
noneAvailability89.0 %Single extractor
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 16)
Year One (2017) 89.0% 83.8% 91.7%
nonePerformance83.8 %Single extractor
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 16)
Year One (2017) 89.0% 83.8% 91.7%
noneQuality91.7 %Single extractor
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 16)
Year Two (2018) 94.5% 87.8% 90.0%
noneAvailability94.5 %Single extractor
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 16)
Year Two (2018) 94.5% 87.8% 90.0%
nonePerformance87.8 %Single extractor
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 16)
Year Two (2018) 94.5% 87.8% 90.0%
noneQuality90.0 %Single extractor
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 16)
Year Three (2019) 90.5% 80.4% 91.7%
noneAvailability90.5 %Single extractor
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 16)
Year Three (2019) 90.5% 80.4% 91.7%
nonePerformance80.4 %Single extractor
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 16)
Year Four (2020) 87.9% 46.3% 90.9%
noneAvailability87.9 %Single extractor
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 16)
Year Four (2020) 87.9% 46.3% 90.9%
nonePerformance46.3 %Single extractor
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 16)
Year Four (2020) 87.9% 46.3% 90.9%
noneQuality90.9 %Single extractor
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 16)
Year Five (2021) 92.1% 85.8% 90.0%
noneAvailability92.1 %Single extractor
—Packer/Caser
Show verbatim quote (Table 16)
Year Five (2021) 92.1% 85.8% 90.0%
nonePerformance85.8 %Single extractor

Observation units

  • NBC Filler · Filling · Baseline
  • NBC Packer/Caser · Packaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing) · Baseline
  • BONS Blow Mould · Forming, moulding and depositing · Baseline
  • BONS Monobloc · Filling · Baseline
  • BONS Packer/Caser · Packaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing) · Baseline