Included study
EFFECT OF EQUIPMENT MAINTENANCE ON THE PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF FOOD AND BEVERAGE MANUFACTURING INDUSTRIES IN NIGERIA.
1Bibliographic record
- Authors
- Chidi Maurice, Onyejaka, Oluka, Prof. Ike
- Year
- 2023
- Venue
- —
- Country
- Nigeria
- Segment
- Soft drinks, bottled water and juices
- Process family
- Filling and packaging line
- Study type
- Multiple case study
- Extraction scope
- Full text
- Size
- 2 plants · — lines · 5 machines
- Observation period
- 1,825 days
- Data collection
- questionnaire
- Intervention
Show the setting as described by the study
Records on maintenance of filler machine, Packer/Caser, Blow Mould machine, Monobloc (filler/Capper/Rinser) machines were collected for a period of five years from 2017-2021 using a questionnaire.
2Risk of bias
Scored with the rubric of the protocol: 2 low concern, 1 some concerns, 0 high concern.
Total score 11Moderate risk
| Item | Score |
|---|---|
| Is the observed line, machine or plant described well enough to classify its segment, process and equipment?Product, process and equipment are all described. | 2 / 2 |
| Is the observation period long enough and reported?Period reported and at least 30 days of production (or at least 100 recorded events). | 2 / 2 |
| How were loss data collected?Manual logs or maintenance records with unknown completeness. | 1 / 2 |
| Are OEE, loading time and the loss categories defined explicitly?Formulae or definitions are given for the reported metrics, including what counts as planned time. | 2 / 2 |
| Does the loss breakdown account for the total loss it claims to explain?Only selected causes are reported and the total is unknown. | 0 / 2 |
| Is there evidence of selective reporting of favourable results?Observational study, or intervention study that reports baseline and post-intervention data with the same method. | 2 / 2 |
| Are the reported numbers internally consistent?Inconsistencies above 10 percentage points, or OEE factors above 100%. | 0 / 2 |
| Could conflicts of interest or the source of the data bias the result?Academic or independent study, or conflicts declared and unrelated to the result. | 2 / 2 |
3Extracted data
Each datum with its classification and the verbatim quote that states it.
| Reported cause | Loss category | Metric | Value | Extraction |
|---|---|---|---|---|
—Filler (Krones 1650CPH)Show verbatim quote (Figure 4 / text)Figure 4 shows that performance rate was least in year four (2020 (66.2%) while it was highest in year three (129%) | none | Performance | 66.2 % | Both extractors agreed |
—Filler (Krones 1650CPH)Show verbatim quote (Figure 3 / text)The availability rate was highest in the year five 96.9% while it was lowest in year four (93.0%) | none | Availability | 96.9 % | Both extractors agreed |
—Filler (Krones 1650CPH)Show verbatim quote (Figure 3 / text)The availability rate was highest in the year five 96.9% while it was lowest in year four (93.0%) | none | Availability | 93.0 % | Both extractors agreed |
—Filler (Krones 1650CPH)Show verbatim quote (Figure 4)104.1% 108.3% 129.3% 66.2% 113.6% 0.0% 20.0% 40.0% 60.0% 80.0% 100.0% 120.0% 140.0% Year one Year two Year three Year four Year five Performance rate Year of study | none | Performance | 129 % | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownPacker/Caser (600BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 14)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 321.5 165.8 285.5 364.3 216 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 216 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownMonobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser) 600BPHShow verbatim quote (Table 11)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 120 130 217.5 386 114.5 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 386 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownMonobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser) 600BPHShow verbatim quote (Table 11)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 120 130 217.5 386 114.5 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 130 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownMonobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser) 600BPHShow verbatim quote (Table 11)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 120 130 217.5 386 114.5 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 120 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownBlow Mould (550BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 8)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 125 130 227 397 132 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 132 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownBlow Mould (550BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 8)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 125 130 227 397 132 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 397 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownBlow Mould (550BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 8)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 125 130 227 397 132 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 227 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownBlow Mould (550BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 8)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 125 130 227 397 132 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 130 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownBlow Mould (550BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 8)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 125 130 227 397 132 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 125 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownFiller (Krones 1650CPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 2)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 123.66 107.33 146.33 153.4 108.5 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 124 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownPacker/Caser (600BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 14)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 321.5 165.8 285.5 364.3 216 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 322 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownPacker/CaserShow verbatim quote (Table 5)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 154.5 117.66 158.3 264.5 128.6 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 158 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownPacker/CaserShow verbatim quote (Table 5)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 154.5 117.66 158.3 264.5 128.6 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 155 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownPacker/Caser (600BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 14)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 321.5 165.8 285.5 364.3 216 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 364 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownMonobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser) 600BPHShow verbatim quote (Table 11)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 120 130 217.5 386 114.5 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 115 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownMonobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser) 600BPHShow verbatim quote (Table 11)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 120 130 217.5 386 114.5 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 218 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownPacker/CaserShow verbatim quote (Table 5)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 154.5 117.66 158.3 264.5 128.6 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 129 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownFiller (Krones 1650CPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 2)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 123.66 107.33 146.33 153.4 108.5 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 109 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownFiller (Krones 1650CPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 2)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 123.66 107.33 146.33 153.4 108.5 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 153 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownPacker/Caser (600BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 14)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 321.5 165.8 285.5 364.3 216 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 286 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownPacker/Caser (600BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 14)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 321.5 165.8 285.5 364.3 216 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 166 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownPacker/CaserShow verbatim quote (Table 5)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 154.5 117.66 158.3 264.5 128.6 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 265 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownFiller (Krones 1650CPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 2)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 123.66 107.33 146.33 153.4 108.5 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 146 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownFiller (Krones 1650CPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 2)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 123.66 107.33 146.33 153.4 108.5 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 107 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownPacker/CaserShow verbatim quote (Table 5)Total number hours of breakdown per year(hours) 154.5 117.66 158.3 264.5 128.6 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 118 h | Both extractors agreed |
—Filler (Krones 1650CPH)Show verbatim quote (Figure 3)95.0% 96.0% 96.0% 93.0% 96.9% 91% 92% 93% 94% 95% 96% 97% 98% Year one Year two Year three Year four Year five Availability rate Year of study | none | Availability | 95.0 % | Single extractor |
—Filler (Krones 1650CPH)Show verbatim quote (Figure 3)95.0% 96.0% 96.0% 93.0% 96.9% 91% 92% 93% 94% 95% 96% 97% 98% Year one Year two Year three Year four Year five Availability rate Year of study | none | Availability | 96.0 % | Single extractor |
—Filler (Krones 1650CPH)Show verbatim quote (Figure 4)104.1% 108.3% 129.3% 66.2% 113.6% 0.0% 20.0% 40.0% 60.0% 80.0% 100.0% 120.0% 140.0% Year one Year two Year three Year four Year five Performance rate Year of study | none | Performance | 104 % | Single extractor |
—Filler (Krones 1650CPH)Show verbatim quote (Figure 4)104.1% 108.3% 129.3% 66.2% 113.6% 0.0% 20.0% 40.0% 60.0% 80.0% 100.0% 120.0% 140.0% Year one Year two Year three Year four Year five Performance rate Year of study | none | Performance | 108 % | Single extractor |
—Filler (Krones 1650CPH)Show verbatim quote (Figure 4)104.1% 108.3% 129.3% 66.2% 113.6% 0.0% 20.0% 40.0% 60.0% 80.0% 100.0% 120.0% 140.0% Year one Year two Year three Year four Year five Performance rate Year of study | none | Performance | 114 % | Single extractor |
—Filler (Krones 1650CPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 4)Year one (2017) 99.9 | none | Quality | 99.9 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/CaserShow verbatim quote (Table 7)Year One (2017) 93.5% 103% 99% | none | Availability | 93.5 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/CaserShow verbatim quote (Table 7)Year One (2017) 93.5% 103% 99% | none | Performance | 103 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/CaserShow verbatim quote (Table 7)Year One (2017) 93.5% 103% 99% | none | Quality | 99.0 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/CaserShow verbatim quote (Table 7)Year Two (2018) 95.2% 105% 99% | none | Availability | 95.2 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/CaserShow verbatim quote (Table 7)Year Two (2018) 95.2% 105% 99% | none | Performance | 105 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/CaserShow verbatim quote (Table 7)Year Three (2019) 95.6% 108% 99% | none | Availability | 95.6 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/CaserShow verbatim quote (Table 7)Year Three (2019) 95.6% 108% 99% | none | Performance | 108 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/CaserShow verbatim quote (Table 7)Year Four (2020) 87.0% 66.2% 99% | none | Availability | 87.0 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/CaserShow verbatim quote (Table 7)Year Four (2020) 87.0% 66.2% 99% | none | Performance | 66.2 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/CaserShow verbatim quote (Table 7)Year Five (2021) 96.3% 103% 99% | none | Availability | 96.3 % | Single extractor |
—Blow Mould (550BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 10)Year One (2017) 95.8% 80.5% 97.2% | none | Availability | 95.8 % | Single extractor |
—Blow Mould (550BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 10)Year One (2017) 95.8% 80.5% 97.2% | none | Performance | 80.5 % | Single extractor |
—Blow Mould (550BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 10)Year One (2017) 95.8% 80.5% 97.2% | none | Quality | 97.2 % | Single extractor |
—Blow Mould (550BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 10)Year Two (2018) 95.0% 85.1% 96.8% | none | Availability | 95.0 % | Single extractor |
—Blow Mould (550BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 10)Year Two (2018) 95.0% 85.1% 96.8% | none | Performance | 85.1 % | Single extractor |
—Blow Mould (550BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 10)Year Two (2018) 95.0% 85.1% 96.8% | none | Quality | 96.8 % | Single extractor |
—Blow Mould (550BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 10)Year Three (2019) 92.4% 89.2% 96.3% | none | Availability | 92.4 % | Single extractor |
—Blow Mould (550BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 10)Year Three (2019) 92.4% 89.2% 96.3% | none | Performance | 89.2 % | Single extractor |
—Blow Mould (550BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 10)Year Three (2019) 92.4% 89.2% 96.3% | none | Quality | 96.3 % | Single extractor |
—Blow Mould (550BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 10)Year Four (2020) 86.8% 46.7% 96.1% | none | Availability | 86.8 % | Single extractor |
—Blow Mould (550BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 10)Year Four (2020) 86.8% 46.7% 96.1% | none | Performance | 46.7 % | Single extractor |
—Blow Mould (550BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 10)Year Four (2020) 86.8% 46.7% 96.1% | none | Quality | 96.1 % | Single extractor |
—Blow Mould (550BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 10)Year Five (2021) 95.6% 82.0% 95.1% | none | Availability | 95.6 % | Single extractor |
—Blow Mould (550BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 10)Year Five (2021) 95.6% 82.0% 95.1% | none | Performance | 82.0 % | Single extractor |
—Blow Mould (550BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 10)Year Five (2021) 95.6% 82.0% 95.1% | none | Quality | 95.1 % | Single extractor |
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser) 600BPHShow verbatim quote (Figure 5)95.8% 95.0% 92.4% 86.8% 95.6% 82.0% 84.0% 86.0% 88.0% 90.0% 92.0% 94.0% 96.0% 98.0% Year One Year Two Year Three Year Four Year Five Percentage Year of study | none | Availability | 95.8 % | Single extractor |
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser) 600BPHShow verbatim quote (Figure 5)95.8% 95.0% 92.4% 86.8% 95.6% 82.0% 84.0% 86.0% 88.0% 90.0% 92.0% 94.0% 96.0% 98.0% Year One Year Two Year Three Year Four Year Five Percentage Year of study | none | Availability | 95.0 % | Single extractor |
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser) 600BPHShow verbatim quote (Figure 5)95.8% 95.0% 92.4% 86.8% 95.6% 82.0% 84.0% 86.0% 88.0% 90.0% 92.0% 94.0% 96.0% 98.0% Year One Year Two Year Three Year Four Year Five Percentage Year of study | none | Availability | 92.4 % | Single extractor |
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser) 600BPHShow verbatim quote (Figure 5)95.8% 95.0% 92.4% 86.8% 95.6% 82.0% 84.0% 86.0% 88.0% 90.0% 92.0% 94.0% 96.0% 98.0% Year One Year Two Year Three Year Four Year Five Percentage Year of study | none | Availability | 95.6 % | Single extractor |
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser) 600BPHShow verbatim quote (Figure 6)93.9% 94.1% 88.8% 47.2% 96.1% 0.0% 20.0% 40.0% 60.0% 80.0% 100.0% 120.0% Year One Year Two Year Three Year Four Year Five Performance Rate (%) | none | Performance | 93.9 % | Single extractor |
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser) 600BPHShow verbatim quote (Figure 6)93.9% 94.1% 88.8% 47.2% 96.1% 0.0% 20.0% 40.0% 60.0% 80.0% 100.0% 120.0% Year One Year Two Year Three Year Four Year Five Performance Rate (%) | none | Performance | 94.1 % | Single extractor |
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser) 600BPHShow verbatim quote (Figure 6)93.9% 94.1% 88.8% 47.2% 96.1% 0.0% 20.0% 40.0% 60.0% 80.0% 100.0% 120.0% Year One Year Two Year Three Year Four Year Five Performance Rate (%) | none | Performance | 88.8 % | Single extractor |
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser) 600BPHShow verbatim quote (Figure 6)93.9% 94.1% 88.8% 47.2% 96.1% 0.0% 20.0% 40.0% 60.0% 80.0% 100.0% 120.0% Year One Year Two Year Three Year Four Year Five Performance Rate (%) | none | Performance | 47.2 % | Single extractor |
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser) 600BPHShow verbatim quote (Figure 6)93.9% 94.1% 88.8% 47.2% 96.1% 0.0% 20.0% 40.0% 60.0% 80.0% 100.0% 120.0% Year One Year Two Year Three Year Four Year Five Performance Rate (%) | none | Performance | 96.1 % | Single extractor |
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser) 600BPHShow verbatim quote (Table 13)Year One (2017) 93.5% | none | Quality | 93.5 % | Single extractor |
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser) 600BPHShow verbatim quote (Table 13)Year Two (2018) 93.7% | none | Quality | 93.7 % | Single extractor |
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser) 600BPHShow verbatim quote (Table 13)Year Three (2019) 92.0% | none | Quality | 92.0 % | Single extractor |
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser) 600BPHShow verbatim quote (Table 13)Year Four (2020) 92.4% | none | Quality | 92.4 % | Single extractor |
—Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser) 600BPHShow verbatim quote (Table 13)Year Five (2021) 91.8% | none | Quality | 91.8 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/Caser (600BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 16)Year One (2017) 89.0% 83.8% 91.7% | none | Availability | 89.0 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/Caser (600BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 16)Year One (2017) 89.0% 83.8% 91.7% | none | Performance | 83.8 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/Caser (600BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 16)Year One (2017) 89.0% 83.8% 91.7% | none | Quality | 91.7 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/Caser (600BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 16)Year Two (2018) 94.5% 87.8% 90.0% | none | Availability | 94.5 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/Caser (600BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 16)Year Two (2018) 94.5% 87.8% 90.0% | none | Performance | 87.8 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/Caser (600BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 16)Year Two (2018) 94.5% 87.8% 90.0% | none | Quality | 90.0 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/Caser (600BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 16)Year Three (2019) 90.5% 80.4% 91.7% | none | Availability | 90.5 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/Caser (600BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 16)Year Three (2019) 90.5% 80.4% 91.7% | none | Performance | 80.4 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/Caser (600BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 16)Year Four (2020) 87.9% 46.3% 90.9% | none | Availability | 87.9 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/Caser (600BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 16)Year Four (2020) 87.9% 46.3% 90.9% | none | Performance | 46.3 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/Caser (600BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 16)Year Four (2020) 87.9% 46.3% 90.9% | none | Quality | 90.9 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/Caser (600BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 16)Year Five (2021) 92.1% 85.8% 90.0% | none | Availability | 92.1 % | Single extractor |
—Packer/Caser (600BPH)Show verbatim quote (Table 16)Year Five (2021) 92.1% 85.8% 90.0% | none | Performance | 85.8 % | Single extractor |
Observation units
- Filler (XNBC) · Filling · Baseline
- Packer/Caser (Company Y) · Packaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing) · Baseline
- Monobloc (Filler/Capper/Rinser) (Company Y) · Filling · Baseline
- Blow Mould (Company Y) · Forming, moulding and depositing · Baseline
- Packer/Caser (XNBC) · Packaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing) · Baseline

