foratvise
Get Started
Included study

A case study of VSM and SMED in the food processing industry

Open source

1Bibliographic record

Authors
Malek Miguel Maalouf, Magdalena Zaduminska
Year
2019
Venue
Management and Production Engineering Review
Country
Denmark
Segment
Meat, poultry and seafood
Process family
Filling and packaging line
Study type
Single case study
Extraction scope
Full text
Size
1 plants · 1 lines · 1 machines
Observation period
365 days
Data collection
manual_logs
Intervention
Show the setting as described by the study
Line 1 produces a family of products called “herring salad” in jars and plastic buckets, of two ˛ avors and di´erent sizes.

2Risk of bias

Scored with the rubric of the protocol: 2 low concern, 1 some concerns, 0 high concern.
Total score 11Moderate risk
ItemScore
Is the observed line, machine or plant described well enough to classify its segment, process and equipment?Product, process and equipment are all described.2 / 2
Is the observation period long enough and reported?Period reported and at least 30 days of production (or at least 100 recorded events).2 / 2
How were loss data collected?Manual logs or maintenance records with unknown completeness.1 / 2
Are OEE, loading time and the loss categories defined explicitly?No definition; metrics are reported as bare numbers.0 / 2
Does the loss breakdown account for the total loss it claims to explain?The reported causes or categories sum to at least 90% of the stated total, or an explicit "other" class closes the balance.2 / 2
Is there evidence of selective reporting of favourable results?Intervention study in which baseline and post-intervention periods differ in length or method.1 / 2
Are the reported numbers internally consistent?Recomputed totals, shares and OEE factors agree with the reported values within 2 percentage points.2 / 2
Could conflicts of interest or the source of the data bias the result?Authors are employees of the plant or of an equipment/software vendor; no declaration.1 / 2

3Extracted data

Each datum with its classification and the verbatim quote that states it.
Reported causeLoss categoryMetricValueExtraction
retooling (two workers, parallel operations)Multi-Weight machine
Show verbatim quote (Outcomes of SMED implementation section / Fig. 9)
The time of retooling was reduced from 17.5 minutes to 11.5 minutes.
Setup and adjustmentsMean event duration11.5 minBoth extractors agreed
retooling (one worker)Multi-Weight machine
Show verbatim quote (Implementation (future state) section / Fig. 9)
The total time of retooling using one worker (Current state in Fig. 9) is 17.5 minutes involving 9 activities (A,B,C,D,E,F,G,H,I).
Setup and adjustmentsMean event duration17.5 minBoth extractors agreed
machine breakdowns
Show verbatim quote (Changeover data analysis section / Fig. 5)
Changeovers consumed 536 hours (28%), while machine breakdowns totalled 485 hours (25%).
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Share of planned time25.0 %Both extractors agreed
machine breakdowns
Show verbatim quote (Changeover data analysis section / Fig. 5)
Changeovers consumed 536 hours (28%), while machine breakdowns totalled 485 hours (25%).
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Lost time485 hBoth extractors agreed
changeovers
Show verbatim quote (Changeover data analysis section / Fig. 5)
Changeovers consumed 536 hours (28%), while machine breakdowns totalled 485 hours (25%).
Setup and adjustmentsShare of planned time28.0 %Both extractors agreed
changeovers
Show verbatim quote (Changeover data analysis section / Fig. 5)
Changeovers consumed 536 hours (28%), while machine breakdowns totalled 485 hours (25%).
Setup and adjustmentsLost time536 hBoth extractors agreed
retooling
Show verbatim quote (Changeover data analysis section / Fig. 6)
A look at Fig. 6 revelas that retooling consumed up to 23% of the overall working hours adding up to 5602 hours in 2014.
Setup and adjustmentsLost time5,602 hBoth extractors agreed
—
Show verbatim quote (Changeover data analysis section / Fig. 5)
In 2014, out of a total of 1928 hours available in the year, the real production time of line L1 was 907 hours (47%).
noneAvailability47.0 %Single extractor
retooling
Show verbatim quote (Changeover data analysis section / Fig. 6)
A look at Fig. 6 revelas that retooling consumed up to 23% of the overall working hours adding up to 5602 hours in 2014.
Setup and adjustmentsShare of planned time23.0 %Single extractor
—
Show verbatim quote (Page 6, Outcomes of SMED implementation section)
The reduction of changeover time of Line 1 (producing 84% of total production) generated increase of ca. 11% of the production capacity (kg/h) of the L1 in 2016 (Fig. 10).
noneThroughput11.0 %Single extractor

Observation units

  • Multi-Weight machine · Filling · After intervention
  • Multi-Weight machine · Filling · Baseline
  • Line L1 · Whole line or unspecified equipment · Baseline
  • Line 1 · Whole line or unspecified equipment · After intervention