foratvise
Get Started
Included study

Meyve Suyu Dolum Hatlarında Güvenilirlik Analizi

Open source

1Bibliographic record

Authors
Aydın Koçak, Funda İşçioğlu
Year
2018
Venue
Journal of Yaşar University
Country
Turkey
Segment
Soft drinks, bottled water and juices
Process family
Filling and packaging line
Study type
Reliability analysis
Extraction scope
Full text
Size
1 plants · 2 lines · 10 machines
Observation period
163 days
Data collection
maintenance_records
Intervention
Show the setting as described by the study
Bu çalışma birbirinin aynısı olan sadece 1lt.'lik meyve suyu dolumu yapılan iki hatta gerçekleştirilmiştir. Her bir hatta dolum, yazıcı, Helix, kapaklama ve kolileme olmak üzere beş makine bulunmaktadır.

2Risk of bias

Scored with the rubric of the protocol: 2 low concern, 1 some concerns, 0 high concern.
Total score 13Low risk
ItemScore
Is the observed line, machine or plant described well enough to classify its segment, process and equipment?Product, process and equipment are all described.2 / 2
Is the observation period long enough and reported?Period reported and at least 30 days of production (or at least 100 recorded events).2 / 2
How were loss data collected?Manual logs or maintenance records with unknown completeness.1 / 2
Are OEE, loading time and the loss categories defined explicitly?A standard definition is cited but its application is not shown.1 / 2
Does the loss breakdown account for the total loss it claims to explain?Only the top causes are reported and the unexplained remainder can be computed.1 / 2
Is there evidence of selective reporting of favourable results?Observational study, or intervention study that reports baseline and post-intervention data with the same method.2 / 2
Are the reported numbers internally consistent?Recomputed totals, shares and OEE factors agree with the reported values within 2 percentage points.2 / 2
Could conflicts of interest or the source of the data bias the result?Academic or independent study, or conflicts declared and unrelated to the result.2 / 2

3Extracted data

Each datum with its classification and the verbatim quote that states it.
Reported causeLoss categoryMetricValueExtraction
—Helix
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 3, Arızalanma Süresi)
Helix 72 1 30450 2321.26 4868.575 2.0974 4.0016 18.8364
Not classifiable from the reportTime between events2,321 dakikaAdjudicated
—Yazıcı
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 3, Arızalanma Süresi)
Yazıcı 9 2109 56536 18596.22 15436.90 0.8301 2.1074 5.6479
Not classifiable from the reportTime between events18,596 dakikaAdjudicated
—Hat 2
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 3, Tamir Süresi (Kullanılabilirlik))
Hat 2 688 2 138 13.5262 14.2842 1.0560 4.22337 24.3742 0.946243
noneAvailability0.946 ratioBoth extractors agreed
—Helix
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 2, Arızalanma Süresi)
Helix 72 13 30031 2405.21 5417.98 2.2526 3.6489 14.2213
Not classifiable from the reportTime between events2,405 dakikaAdjudicated
—Hat 1
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 2, Arızalanma Süresi)
Hat 1 1019 1 3139 166.110 309.468 1.8630 4.90725 33.1882
Not classifiable from the reportTime between events166 dakikaAdjudicated
—Dolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 3, Tamir Süresi (Kullanılabilirlik))
Dolum 244 2 138 12.2418 15.4385 1.2611 5.0297 33.2724 0.982720
noneAvailability0.983 ratioBoth extractors agreed
—Dolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 2, Tamir Süresi (Kullanılabilirlik))
Dolum 304 2 180 11.7993 19.0759 1.6167 6.6501 48.9160 0.978841
noneAvailability0.979 ratioBoth extractors agreed
—Kapaklama
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 3, Tamir Süresi (Kullanılabilirlik))
Kapaklama 119 5 115 16.0084 16.2431 1.0147 3.6445 15.9880 0.988952
noneAvailability0.989 ratioBoth extractors agreed
—Hat 1
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 2, Tamir Süresi (Kullanılabilirlik))
Hat 1 1019 2 355 14.0206 17.9804 1.2824 9.55894 145.011 0.922164
noneAvailability0.922 ratioBoth extractors agreed
—Hat 1
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 2, Tamir Süresi)
Hat 1 1019 2 355 14.0206 17.9804 1.2824 9.55894 145.011 0.922164
Not classifiable from the reportMean event duration14.0 dakikaAdjudicated
—Dolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 3, Arızalanma Süresi)
Dolum 244 1 6371 696.180 1080.430 1.5519 2.6116 7.9111
Not classifiable from the reportTime between events696 dakikaAdjudicated
—Hat 2
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 3, Arızalanma Süresi)
Hat 2 688 1 3176 238.089 365.774 1.5363 3.19315 13.5611
Not classifiable from the reportTime between events238 dakikaAdjudicated
—Helix
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 2, Tamir Süresi (Kullanılabilirlik))
Helix 72 3 60 10.8194 8.8673 0.8196 3.2795 14.2826 0.995522
noneAvailability0.996 ratioBoth extractors agreed
—Helix
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 3, Tamir Süresi (Kullanılabilirlik))
Helix 72 2 106 12.0833 14.0349 1.1615 4.9964 29.9161 0.994821
noneAvailability0.995 ratioBoth extractors agreed
—Kolileme
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 2, Tamir Süresi (Kullanılabilirlik))
Kolileme 384 4 106 13.9974 11.1382 0.7957 3.7587 20.5376 0.970838
noneAvailability0.971 ratioBoth extractors agreed
—Dolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 2, Arızalanma Süresi)
Dolum 304 1 5180 545.849 925.601 1.6957 2.7305 7.9514
Not classifiable from the reportTime between events546 dakikaAdjudicated
—Kapaklama
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 2, Tamir Süresi (Kullanılabilirlik))
Kapaklama 249 3 355 17.4217 25.1661 1.4445 10.0712 131.254 0.976080
noneAvailability0.976 ratioBoth extractors agreed
—Yazıcı
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 2, Tamir Süresi (Kullanılabilirlik))
Yazıcı 10 5 56 20.80 18.5999 0.8942 1.1334 -0.3453 0.998813
noneAvailability0.999 ratioBoth extractors agreed
—Yazıcı
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 2, Arızalanma Süresi)
Yazıcı 10 1027 48720 17495.10 16093.30 0.9199 1.1570 0.4514
Not classifiable from the reportTime between events17,495 dakikaAdjudicated
—Kapaklama
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 2, Arızalanma Süresi)
Kapaklama 249 2 6493 710.912 1049.41 1.4761 2.3647 6.3286
Not classifiable from the reportTime between events711 dakikaAdjudicated
—Kolileme
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 3, Tamir Süresi (Kullanılabilirlik))
Kolileme 244 3 75 13.8525 11.9792 0.8648 2.9237 9.5971 0.980222
noneAvailability0.980 ratioBoth extractors agreed
—Kolileme
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 3, Arızalanma Süresi)
Kolileme 244 5 6391 686.537 1037.435 1.5111 2.6266 7.9999
Not classifiable from the reportTime between events687 dakikaAdjudicated
—Kolileme
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 2, Arızalanma Süresi)
Kolileme 384 1 5578 465.987 737.681 1.5831 3.1545 13.1447
Not classifiable from the reportTime between events466 dakikaAdjudicated
—Hat 2
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 3, Tamir Süresi)
Hat 2 688 2 138 13.5262 14.2842 1.0560 4.22337 24.3742 0.946243
Not classifiable from the reportMean event duration13.5 dakikaAdjudicated
—Kapaklama
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 2, Tamir Süresi)
Kapaklama 249 3 355 17.4217 25.1661 1.4445 10.0712 131.254 0.976080
Not classifiable from the reportMean event duration17.4 dakikaAdjudicated
—Dolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 3, Tamir Süresi)
Dolum 244 2 138 12.2418 15.4385 1.2611 5.0297 33.2724 0.982720
Not classifiable from the reportMean event duration12.2 dakikaAdjudicated
—Dolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 2, Tamir Süresi)
Dolum 304 2 180 11.7993 19.0759 1.6167 6.6501 48.9160 0.978841
Not classifiable from the reportMean event duration11.8 dakikaAdjudicated
—Kapaklama
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 3, Tamir Süresi)
Kapaklama 119 5 115 16.0084 16.2431 1.0147 3.6445 15.9880 0.988952
Not classifiable from the reportMean event duration16.0 dakikaAdjudicated
—Kapaklama
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 3, Arızalanma Süresi)
Kapaklama 119 6 11654 1433 1952.39 1.3624 2.6982 9.4365
Not classifiable from the reportTime between events1,433 dakikaAdjudicated
—Helix
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 3, Tamir Süresi)
Helix 72 2 106 12.0833 14.0349 1.1615 4.9964 29.9161 0.994821
Not classifiable from the reportMean event duration12.1 dakikaAdjudicated
—Kolileme
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 2, Tamir Süresi)
Kolileme 384 4 106 13.9974 11.1382 0.7957 3.7587 20.5376 0.970838
Not classifiable from the reportMean event duration14.0 dakikaAdjudicated
—Kolileme
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 3, Tamir Süresi)
Kolileme 244 3 75 13.8525 11.9792 0.8648 2.9237 9.5971 0.980222
Not classifiable from the reportMean event duration13.9 dakikaAdjudicated
—Helix
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 2, Tamir Süresi)
Helix 72 3 60 10.8194 8.8673 0.8196 3.2795 14.2826 0.995522
Not classifiable from the reportMean event duration10.8 dakikaAdjudicated
—Yazıcı
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 2, Tamir Süresi)
Yazıcı 10 5 56 20.80 18.5999 0.8942 1.1334 -0.3453 0.998813
Not classifiable from the reportMean event duration20.8 dakikaAdjudicated
kolileme ve dolum makineleriKolileme, Dolum
Show verbatim quote (Sonuç ve Değerlendirme)
en çok iki arıza yaşanan ve toplam arızaların %67’sine sahip kolileme ve dolum makinelerine odaklanılmalıdır.
Not classifiable from the reportShare of loss events67.0 %Single extractor
dolum ve kolileme makineleriDolum, Kolileme
Show verbatim quote (Sonuç ve Değerlendirme)
Hat 2’de ise benzer bir şekilde toplam arızaların %70’ine sahip dolum ve kolileme makineleri bakım ve iyileştirme faaliyetleri açısında öncelikli makinelerdir.
Not classifiable from the reportShare of loss events70.0 %Single extractor
Son katlayıcıDolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 1)
DOLUM Son katlayıcı 97 DOLUM Son katlayıcı 97
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events97.0 eventsSingle extractor
KağıtDolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 1, Hat 1)
Kağıt 67 Kağıt 68
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events67.0 eventsSingle extractor
HidrolikDolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 1, Hat 1)
Hidrolik 65 Hidrolik 15
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events65.0 eventsSingle extractor
FotoselDolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 1, Hat 1)
Fotosel 41 Fotosel 34
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events41.0 eventsSingle extractor
StripDolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 1, Hat 1)
Strip 13 Strip 2
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events13.0 eventsSingle extractor
Servis ünitesiDolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 1, Hat 1)
Servis ünitesi 8 Servis ünitesi 13
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events8.00 eventsSingle extractor
ElektrikselDolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 1, Hat 1)
Elektriksel 7 Elektriksel 0
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events7.00 eventsSingle extractor
AzotDolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 1, Hat 1)
Azot 4 Azot 4
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events4.00 eventsSingle extractor
PeroksitDolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 1, Hat 1)
Peroksit 2 Peroksit 11
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events2.00 eventsSingle extractor
son katlayıcı, kağıt ve hidrolik arızalarıDolum
Show verbatim quote (Şekil 2 bölümü metni)
Hat 1’deki dolum makinesinde en çok son katlayıcı arızası yaşanmakta olup duruşların %75’i son katlayıcı, kağıt ve hidrolik arızalarından kaynaklandığı görülmektedir.
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Share of loss events75.0 %Single extractor
Son katlayıcıDolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 1, Hat 2)
DOLUM Son katlayıcı 97 DOLUM Son katlayıcı 97
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events97.0 eventsSingle extractor
KağıtDolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 1, Hat 2)
Kağıt 67 Kağıt 68
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events68.0 eventsSingle extractor
HidrolikDolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 1, Hat 2)
Hidrolik 65 Hidrolik 15
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events15.0 eventsSingle extractor
FotoselDolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 1, Hat 2)
Fotosel 41 Fotosel 34
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events34.0 eventsSingle extractor
StripDolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 1, Hat 2)
Strip 13 Strip 2
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events2.00 eventsSingle extractor
Servis ünitesiDolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 1, Hat 2)
Servis ünitesi 8 Servis ünitesi 13
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events13.0 eventsSingle extractor
ElektrikselDolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 1, Hat 2)
Elektriksel 7 Elektriksel 0
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events0 eventsSingle extractor
AzotDolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 1, Hat 2)
Azot 4 Azot 4
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events4.00 eventsSingle extractor
PeroksitDolum
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 1, Hat 2)
Peroksit 2 Peroksit 11
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events11.0 eventsSingle extractor
son katlayıcı, kağıt ve fotosel arızalarıDolum
Show verbatim quote (Şekil 2 bölümü metni)
Hat 2 dolum makinesinde ise en çok son katlayıcı arızası yaşanmakta olup duruşların % 82’si son katlayıcı, kağıt ve fotosel arızalarından kaynaklanmaktadır.
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Share of loss events82.0 %Single extractor
—Yazıcı
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 3, Tamir Süresi)
Yazıcı 9 4 31 18.2222 9.7183 0.5333 -0,1068 -1.6405 0.999021
Not classifiable from the reportMean event duration18.2 dakikaSingle extractor
—Yazıcı
Show verbatim quote (Tablo 3, Tamir Süresi (Kullanılabilirlik))
Yazıcı 9 4 31 18.2222 9.7183 0.5333 -0,1068 -1.6405 0.999021
noneAvailability0.999 ratioSingle extractor
—
Show verbatim quote (Section 6. Arıza Türleri ve Analizi)
Arıza verileri incelendiğinde Hat 1'de toplam 1019, Hat 2'de ise 688 arıza yaşandığı görülmüştür.
noneNumber of events1,019 eventsSingle extractor
YazıcıYazıcı
Show verbatim quote (Table 1. Makine ve Hat Bazında Arıza Sayıları, HAT 1 section)
YAZICI | Yazıcı | 10
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events10.0 eventsSingle extractor
HelixHelix
Show verbatim quote (Table 1. Makine ve Hat Bazında Arıza Sayıları, HAT 1 section)
HELİX | Helix | 72
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events72.0 eventsSingle extractor
KapaklamaKapaklama
Show verbatim quote (Table 1. Makine ve Hat Bazında Arıza Sayıları, HAT 1 section)
KAPAKLAMA | Kapaklama | 249
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events249 eventsSingle extractor
KolilemeKolileme
Show verbatim quote (Table 1. Makine ve Hat Bazında Arıza Sayıları, HAT 1 section)
KOLİLEME | Kolileme | 384
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events384 eventsSingle extractor
—
Show verbatim quote (Section 6. Arıza Türleri ve Analizi)
Arıza verileri incelendiğinde Hat 1'de toplam 1019, Hat 2'de ise 688 arıza yaşandığı görülmüştür.
noneNumber of events688 eventsSingle extractor
YazıcıYazıcı
Show verbatim quote (Table 1. Makine ve Hat Bazında Arıza Sayıları, HAT 2 section)
YAZICI | Yazıcı | 9
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events9.00 eventsSingle extractor
HelixHelix
Show verbatim quote (Table 1. Makine ve Hat Bazında Arıza Sayıları, HAT 2 section)
HELİX | Helix | 72
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events72.0 eventsSingle extractor
KapaklamaKapaklama
Show verbatim quote (Table 1. Makine ve Hat Bazında Arıza Sayıları, HAT 2 section)
KAPAKLAMA | Kapaklama | 119
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events119 eventsSingle extractor
KolilemeKolileme
Show verbatim quote (Table 1. Makine ve Hat Bazında Arıza Sayıları, HAT 2 section)
KOLİLEME | Kolileme | 244
Equipment failure (breakdowns)Number of events244 eventsSingle extractor

Observation units

  • Helix - Hat 2 · Conveying and accumulation · Baseline
  • Yazıcı (Printer) - Hat 2 · Labeling and coding · Baseline
  • Hat 2 (Line 2) · Whole line or unspecified equipment · Baseline
  • Helix - Hat 1 · Conveying and accumulation · Baseline
  • Hat 1 (Line 1) · Whole line or unspecified equipment · Baseline
  • Dolum (Filling machine) - Hat 2 · Filling · Baseline
  • Dolum (Filling machine) - Hat 1 · Filling · Baseline
  • Kapaklama (Capping) - Hat 2 · Capping and seaming · Baseline
  • Kolileme (Case packer) - Hat 1 · Packaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing) · Baseline
  • Kapaklama (Capping) - Hat 1 · Capping and seaming · Baseline
  • Yazıcı (Printer) - Hat 1 · Labeling and coding · Baseline
  • Kolileme (Case packer) - Hat 2 · Packaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing) · Baseline
  • Hat 1 - Yazıcı (Printer) · Labeling and coding · Baseline
  • Hat 1 - Helix · Conveying and accumulation · Baseline
  • Hat 1 - Kapaklama (Capping) · Capping and seaming · Baseline
  • Hat 1 - Kolileme (Collating/Packaging) · Packaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing) · Baseline
  • Hat 2 - Yazıcı (Printer) · Labeling and coding · Baseline
  • Hat 2 - Helix · Conveying and accumulation · Baseline
  • Hat 2 - Kapaklama (Capping) · Capping and seaming · Baseline
  • Hat 2 - Kolileme (Collating/Packaging) · Packaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing) · Baseline