Product scrap and rejection
In short
It appears in about 1 of every 100 lines studied.
When it appears, it takes on average about 49 % of the line's lost time. Reported by 4 of the 127 studies that could observe it (limited evidence).
What happens
Units produced during otherwise stable running fail to meet specification (weight, seal, shape, wrap or appearance) because of minor material misbehavior such as product sticking, folding or wrapping incorrectly around forming, cutting or packaging elements, and are removed from the line as scrap or rework.
What is done about it
Tighten in-process monitoring and quick-clear procedures at the forming, cutting or wrapping station, adjust guides, tooling and material tension to prevent sticking or misforming, and reinforce operator checks and minor-stop logging so root causes of scrap are tracked and corrected.
Practical guidance written from engineering knowledge; it is not a statistical estimate.
1Probability and evidence
- Probability of presence
- 1.3% [0.4–2.9%]
- Expected share of lost time
- 0.6% [0.2–1.4%]
- Share of lost time when present
- 49% [38–60%]
- Studies / units
- 127 / 161
- Evidence grade
- C
Grade C: 2 to 4 studies, or an interval wider than 0.35.
2Probability by segment
- Dairy products1.4% [0.2–4.4%]13 studies
- Soft drinks, bottled water and juices1.1% [0.2–3.3%]26 studies
- Brewing, wine and spirits1.4% [0.2–4.3%]11 studies
- Bakery and pasta1.6% [0.3–4.6%]24 studies
- Meat, poultry and seafood1.9% [0.3–5.9%]9 studies
- Fruit and vegetable processing1.4% [0.2–4.8%]7 studies
- Grain and oilseed milling1.4% [0.2–4.6%]6 studies
- Sugar and confectionery1.4% [0.2–4.4%]9 studies
- Snacks, coffee, tea and other foods2.0% [0.3–6.5%]5 studies
- Animal feed and pet food2.0% [0.3–6.6%]7 studies
- Food manufacturing (unspecified or mixed)1.4% [0.2–4.8%]10 studies
3Mechanism, SCADA signature and countermeasure
Mechanism
Engineering guidanceUnits produced during otherwise stable running fail to meet specification (weight, seal, shape, wrap or appearance) because of minor material misbehavior such as product sticking, folding or wrapping incorrectly around forming, cutting or packaging elements, and are removed from the line as scrap or rework.
How it looks in SCADA data
Engineering guidanceMES/quality modules show an elevated scrap or reject counter and a declining first-pass yield while the line state remains mostly in run, with short, scattered micro-stop events that do not reach the equipment-failure duration threshold and are not tied to a single sustained fault code.
Countermeasure
Engineering guidanceTighten in-process monitoring and quick-clear procedures at the forming, cutting or wrapping station, adjust guides, tooling and material tension to prevent sticking or misforming, and reinforce operator checks and minor-stop logging so root causes of scrap are tracked and corrected.
4Sources
- Investigation on a multiscale sustainable manufacturing approach to production changeover complexity reduction and its implementation through smart surfaces and process optimization (2022)Open sourceLost time: 2.00 min · as reported: “Cute Wrap Up”
Show verbatim quote
Cute Wrap Up 1 1 2
- Usulan Penurunan Tingkat Kecacatan Produk Sosis Ayam di PT Charoen Pokphand Indonesia (2015)Open sourceDefect rate: 0.340 % · as reported: “reject cooking”
Show verbatim quote
Chicken sausages have several types of defects like wrinkled (0,9%), fungus (0,04%), and reject cooking (0,34%).
- A Lean Manufacturing Case Study: Enhancing Efficiency and Reducing Waste in Latin American Food Production (2024)Open sourceDefect rate: 15.0 % · as reported: “Scrap rate”
Show verbatim quote
PokaYoke Scrap rate 15% 5% 4.00% -73.33%
- A Lean Manufacturing Case Study: Enhancing Efficiency and Reducing Waste in Latin American Food Production (2024)Open sourceShare of lost time: 55.0 % · as reported: “high rate of decline”
Show verbatim quote
At the first level, three main reasons were identified: a high rate of decline (55%), a high rate of defective products (25%), and elevated unproductive times (20%).
- A Lean Manufacturing Case Study: Enhancing Efficiency and Reducing Waste in Latin American Food Production (2024)Open sourceDefect rate: 4.00 % · as reported: “Scrap rate”
Show verbatim quote
PokaYoke Scrap rate 15% 5% 4.00% -73.33%
- Integrating Lean Manufacturing and TPM for Production Efficiency Improvement: A Peruvian Case Study in the Bottled Water Industry (2024)Open sourceDefect rate: 3.13 % · as reported: “discards”
Show verbatim quote
Discards rate % 3.13% 2% 0.96% -69.33%
- Integrating Lean Manufacturing and TPM for Production Efficiency Improvement: A Peruvian Case Study in the Bottled Water Industry (2024)Open sourceDefect rate: 0.960 % · as reported: “discards”
Show verbatim quote
Discards rate % 3.13% 2% 0.96% -69.33%
- Defect rate: 10.0 % · as reported: “reject produk”
Show verbatim quote
Tingkat reject produk mencapai 10%, yang cukup signifikan untuk diperbaiki.
- Enterprise Resource Planning System Integrated with Overall Equipment Effectiveness for Enhanced Performance Tracking Metrics: Mixed-Methods Case Study of a Nigerian Feed Mill (2026)Open sourceShare of lost time: 54.7 % · as reported: “Target achieve”
Show verbatim quote
1 Target achieve 734.34 54.72 54.72 Vital few
- Enterprise Resource Planning System Integrated with Overall Equipment Effectiveness for Enhanced Performance Tracking Metrics: Mixed-Methods Case Study of a Nigerian Feed Mill (2026)Open sourceLost time: 734 hrs · as reported: “Target achieve”
Show verbatim quote
1 Target achieve 734.34 54.72 54.72 Vital few

