Included study
Analisis Efektivitas Mesin pada Divisi Pengalengan Jamur Di PT XYZ Menggunakan Metode Overall Equipment Effectiveness
1Bibliographic record
- Authors
- Haradito, Aditya, Sabarisman, Iman, Anoraga, Satria Bhirawa
- Year
- 2019
- Venue
- —
- DOI
- —
- Country
- Indonesia
- Segment
- Fruit and vegetable processing
- Process family
- Filling and packaging line
- Study type
- Single case study
- Extraction scope
- Full text
- Size
- 1 plants · 1 lines · 9 machines
- Observation period
- 60 days
- Data collection
- manual_logs
- Intervention
Show the setting as described by the study
This study measures the value of OEE in the production line of mushroom canning within two months.
2Risk of bias
Scored with the rubric of the protocol: 2 low concern, 1 some concerns, 0 high concern.
Total score 13Low risk
| Item | Score |
|---|---|
| Is the observed line, machine or plant described well enough to classify its segment, process and equipment?Product, process and equipment are all described. | 2 / 2 |
| Is the observation period long enough and reported?Period reported and at least 30 days of production (or at least 100 recorded events). | 2 / 2 |
| How were loss data collected?Manual logs or maintenance records with unknown completeness. | 1 / 2 |
| Are OEE, loading time and the loss categories defined explicitly?A standard definition is cited but its application is not shown. | 1 / 2 |
| Does the loss breakdown account for the total loss it claims to explain?Only the top causes are reported and the unexplained remainder can be computed. | 1 / 2 |
| Is there evidence of selective reporting of favourable results?Observational study, or intervention study that reports baseline and post-intervention data with the same method. | 2 / 2 |
| Are the reported numbers internally consistent?Recomputed totals, shares and OEE factors agree with the reported values within 2 percentage points. | 2 / 2 |
| Could conflicts of interest or the source of the data bias the result?Academic or independent study, or conflicts declared and unrelated to the result. | 2 / 2 |
3Extracted data
Each datum with its classification and the verbatim quote that states it.
| Reported cause | Loss category | Metric | Value | Extraction |
|---|---|---|---|---|
—retortShow verbatim quote (Section 5, Gambar 4)mesin washer tank dengan nilai 47,22%, mesin blancher dengan nilai 58,32%, mesin cooling dengan nilai 37,85%, mesin grading dengan nilai 51,28%, mesin sortasi belt dengan nilai 54,71%, mesin slicing dengan nilai 49,85%, mesin exhaust dengan nilai 84,55%, mesin seamer dengan nilai 71,80% dan mesin retort dengan nilai 72,81%. | none | OEE | 72.8 % | Both extractors agreed |
—retortShow verbatim quote (Section 3, Gambar 2)blancher bernilai 66,49%, mesin cooling bernilai 42,90%, mesin grading bernilai 58,30%, mesin sortasi belt bernilai 62,41%, mesin slicing bernilai 54,84%, mesin exhaust bernilai 87,66%, mesin seamer bernilai 77,46%, dan mesin retort bernilai 82,91%. | none | Performance | 82.9 % | Both extractors agreed |
—retortShow verbatim quote (Section 2, Gambar 1)Enam mesin yang mempunyai nilai availability rate dibawah nilai standard antara lain mesin washer tank bernilai 88,61%, mesin blancher bernilai 87,86%, mesin cooling bernilai 88,30%, mesin grading bernilai 87,98%, mesin sortasi belt bernilai 87,80%, dan mesin retort bernilai 88,43%. | none | Availability | 88.4 % | Both extractors agreed |
—seamerShow verbatim quote (Section 5, Gambar 4)mesin washer tank dengan nilai 47,22%, mesin blancher dengan nilai 58,32%, mesin cooling dengan nilai 37,85%, mesin grading dengan nilai 51,28%, mesin sortasi belt dengan nilai 54,71%, mesin slicing dengan nilai 49,85%, mesin exhaust dengan nilai 84,55%, mesin seamer dengan nilai 71,80% dan mesin retort dengan nilai 72,81%. | none | OEE | 71.8 % | Both extractors agreed |
—seamerShow verbatim quote (Section 4, Gambar 3)Perhitungan nilai quality rate mesin washer tank bernilai 99,95%, mesin blancher bernilai 99,87%, mesin cooling bernilai 99,95%, mesin grading bernilai 99,97%, mesin sortasi belt bernilai 99,84%, mesin slicing bernilai 99,12%, mesin exhaust bernilai 100,00%, mesin seamer bernilai 99,80%, dan mesin retort bernilai | none | Quality | 99.8 % | Both extractors agreed |
—seamerShow verbatim quote (Section 3, Gambar 2)blancher bernilai 66,49%, mesin cooling bernilai 42,90%, mesin grading bernilai 58,30%, mesin sortasi belt bernilai 62,41%, mesin slicing bernilai 54,84%, mesin exhaust bernilai 87,66%, mesin seamer bernilai 77,46%, dan mesin retort bernilai 82,91%. | none | Performance | 77.5 % | Both extractors agreed |
—seamerShow verbatim quote (Section 2, Gambar 1)bernilai 91,44%, mesin exhaust bernilai 96,67%, dan mesin seamer bernilai 92,88%. | none | Availability | 92.9 % | Both extractors agreed |
—exhaustShow verbatim quote (Section 5, Gambar 4)mesin washer tank dengan nilai 47,22%, mesin blancher dengan nilai 58,32%, mesin cooling dengan nilai 37,85%, mesin grading dengan nilai 51,28%, mesin sortasi belt dengan nilai 54,71%, mesin slicing dengan nilai 49,85%, mesin exhaust dengan nilai 84,55%, mesin seamer dengan nilai 71,80% dan mesin retort dengan nilai 72,81%. | none | OEE | 84.6 % | Both extractors agreed |
—exhaustShow verbatim quote (Section 4, Gambar 3)Perhitungan nilai quality rate mesin washer tank bernilai 99,95%, mesin blancher bernilai 99,87%, mesin cooling bernilai 99,95%, mesin grading bernilai 99,97%, mesin sortasi belt bernilai 99,84%, mesin slicing bernilai 99,12%, mesin exhaust bernilai 100,00%, mesin seamer bernilai 99,80%, dan mesin retort bernilai | none | Quality | 100 % | Both extractors agreed |
—exhaustShow verbatim quote (Section 3, Gambar 2)blancher bernilai 66,49%, mesin cooling bernilai 42,90%, mesin grading bernilai 58,30%, mesin sortasi belt bernilai 62,41%, mesin slicing bernilai 54,84%, mesin exhaust bernilai 87,66%, mesin seamer bernilai 77,46%, dan mesin retort bernilai 82,91%. | none | Performance | 87.7 % | Both extractors agreed |
—exhaustShow verbatim quote (Section 2, Gambar 1)bernilai 91,44%, mesin exhaust bernilai 96,67%, dan mesin seamer bernilai 92,88%. | none | Availability | 96.7 % | Both extractors agreed |
—slicingShow verbatim quote (Section 5, Gambar 4)mesin washer tank dengan nilai 47,22%, mesin blancher dengan nilai 58,32%, mesin cooling dengan nilai 37,85%, mesin grading dengan nilai 51,28%, mesin sortasi belt dengan nilai 54,71%, mesin slicing dengan nilai 49,85%, mesin exhaust dengan nilai 84,55%, mesin seamer dengan nilai 71,80% dan mesin retort dengan nilai 72,81%. | none | OEE | 49.9 % | Both extractors agreed |
—slicingShow verbatim quote (Section 4, Gambar 3)Perhitungan nilai quality rate mesin washer tank bernilai 99,95%, mesin blancher bernilai 99,87%, mesin cooling bernilai 99,95%, mesin grading bernilai 99,97%, mesin sortasi belt bernilai 99,84%, mesin slicing bernilai 99,12%, mesin exhaust bernilai 100,00%, mesin seamer bernilai 99,80%, dan mesin retort bernilai | none | Quality | 99.1 % | Both extractors agreed |
—slicingShow verbatim quote (Section 3, Gambar 2)blancher bernilai 66,49%, mesin cooling bernilai 42,90%, mesin grading bernilai 58,30%, mesin sortasi belt bernilai 62,41%, mesin slicing bernilai 54,84%, mesin exhaust bernilai 87,66%, mesin seamer bernilai 77,46%, dan mesin retort bernilai 82,91%. | none | Performance | 54.8 % | Both extractors agreed |
—sortasi beltShow verbatim quote (Section 5, Gambar 4)mesin washer tank dengan nilai 47,22%, mesin blancher dengan nilai 58,32%, mesin cooling dengan nilai 37,85%, mesin grading dengan nilai 51,28%, mesin sortasi belt dengan nilai 54,71%, mesin slicing dengan nilai 49,85%, mesin exhaust dengan nilai 84,55%, mesin seamer dengan nilai 71,80% dan mesin retort dengan nilai 72,81%. | none | OEE | 54.7 % | Both extractors agreed |
—sortasi beltShow verbatim quote (Section 4, Gambar 3)Perhitungan nilai quality rate mesin washer tank bernilai 99,95%, mesin blancher bernilai 99,87%, mesin cooling bernilai 99,95%, mesin grading bernilai 99,97%, mesin sortasi belt bernilai 99,84%, mesin slicing bernilai 99,12%, mesin exhaust bernilai 100,00%, mesin seamer bernilai 99,80%, dan mesin retort bernilai | none | Quality | 99.8 % | Both extractors agreed |
—sortasi beltShow verbatim quote (Section 3, Gambar 2)blancher bernilai 66,49%, mesin cooling bernilai 42,90%, mesin grading bernilai 58,30%, mesin sortasi belt bernilai 62,41%, mesin slicing bernilai 54,84%, mesin exhaust bernilai 87,66%, mesin seamer bernilai 77,46%, dan mesin retort bernilai 82,91%. | none | Performance | 62.4 % | Both extractors agreed |
—sortasi beltShow verbatim quote (Section 2, Gambar 1)Enam mesin yang mempunyai nilai availability rate dibawah nilai standard antara lain mesin washer tank bernilai 88,61%, mesin blancher bernilai 87,86%, mesin cooling bernilai 88,30%, mesin grading bernilai 87,98%, mesin sortasi belt bernilai 87,80%, dan mesin retort bernilai 88,43%. | none | Availability | 87.8 % | Both extractors agreed |
—gradingShow verbatim quote (Section 5, Gambar 4)mesin washer tank dengan nilai 47,22%, mesin blancher dengan nilai 58,32%, mesin cooling dengan nilai 37,85%, mesin grading dengan nilai 51,28%, mesin sortasi belt dengan nilai 54,71%, mesin slicing dengan nilai 49,85%, mesin exhaust dengan nilai 84,55%, mesin seamer dengan nilai 71,80% dan mesin retort dengan nilai 72,81%. | none | OEE | 51.3 % | Both extractors agreed |
—gradingShow verbatim quote (Section 4, Gambar 3)Perhitungan nilai quality rate mesin washer tank bernilai 99,95%, mesin blancher bernilai 99,87%, mesin cooling bernilai 99,95%, mesin grading bernilai 99,97%, mesin sortasi belt bernilai 99,84%, mesin slicing bernilai 99,12%, mesin exhaust bernilai 100,00%, mesin seamer bernilai 99,80%, dan mesin retort bernilai | none | Quality | 100.0 % | Both extractors agreed |
—gradingShow verbatim quote (Section 3, Gambar 2)blancher bernilai 66,49%, mesin cooling bernilai 42,90%, mesin grading bernilai 58,30%, mesin sortasi belt bernilai 62,41%, mesin slicing bernilai 54,84%, mesin exhaust bernilai 87,66%, mesin seamer bernilai 77,46%, dan mesin retort bernilai 82,91%. | none | Performance | 58.3 % | Both extractors agreed |
—gradingShow verbatim quote (Section 2, Gambar 1)Enam mesin yang mempunyai nilai availability rate dibawah nilai standard antara lain mesin washer tank bernilai 88,61%, mesin blancher bernilai 87,86%, mesin cooling bernilai 88,30%, mesin grading bernilai 87,98%, mesin sortasi belt bernilai 87,80%, dan mesin retort bernilai 88,43%. | none | Availability | 88.0 % | Both extractors agreed |
—coolingShow verbatim quote (Section 5, Gambar 4)mesin washer tank dengan nilai 47,22%, mesin blancher dengan nilai 58,32%, mesin cooling dengan nilai 37,85%, mesin grading dengan nilai 51,28%, mesin sortasi belt dengan nilai 54,71%, mesin slicing dengan nilai 49,85%, mesin exhaust dengan nilai 84,55%, mesin seamer dengan nilai 71,80% dan mesin retort dengan nilai 72,81%. | none | OEE | 37.9 % | Both extractors agreed |
—coolingShow verbatim quote (Section 4, Gambar 3)Perhitungan nilai quality rate mesin washer tank bernilai 99,95%, mesin blancher bernilai 99,87%, mesin cooling bernilai 99,95%, mesin grading bernilai 99,97%, mesin sortasi belt bernilai 99,84%, mesin slicing bernilai 99,12%, mesin exhaust bernilai 100,00%, mesin seamer bernilai 99,80%, dan mesin retort bernilai | none | Quality | 100.0 % | Both extractors agreed |
—coolingShow verbatim quote (Section 3, Gambar 2)blancher bernilai 66,49%, mesin cooling bernilai 42,90%, mesin grading bernilai 58,30%, mesin sortasi belt bernilai 62,41%, mesin slicing bernilai 54,84%, mesin exhaust bernilai 87,66%, mesin seamer bernilai 77,46%, dan mesin retort bernilai 82,91%. | none | Performance | 42.9 % | Both extractors agreed |
—coolingShow verbatim quote (Section 2, Gambar 1)Enam mesin yang mempunyai nilai availability rate dibawah nilai standard antara lain mesin washer tank bernilai 88,61%, mesin blancher bernilai 87,86%, mesin cooling bernilai 88,30%, mesin grading bernilai 87,98%, mesin sortasi belt bernilai 87,80%, dan mesin retort bernilai 88,43%. | none | Availability | 88.3 % | Both extractors agreed |
—blancherShow verbatim quote (Section 5, Gambar 4)mesin washer tank dengan nilai 47,22%, mesin blancher dengan nilai 58,32%, mesin cooling dengan nilai 37,85%, mesin grading dengan nilai 51,28%, mesin sortasi belt dengan nilai 54,71%, mesin slicing dengan nilai 49,85%, mesin exhaust dengan nilai 84,55%, mesin seamer dengan nilai 71,80% dan mesin retort dengan nilai 72,81%. | none | OEE | 58.3 % | Both extractors agreed |
—blancherShow verbatim quote (Section 4, Gambar 3)Perhitungan nilai quality rate mesin washer tank bernilai 99,95%, mesin blancher bernilai 99,87%, mesin cooling bernilai 99,95%, mesin grading bernilai 99,97%, mesin sortasi belt bernilai 99,84%, mesin slicing bernilai 99,12%, mesin exhaust bernilai 100,00%, mesin seamer bernilai 99,80%, dan mesin retort bernilai | none | Quality | 99.9 % | Both extractors agreed |
—blancherShow verbatim quote (Section 2, Gambar 1)Enam mesin yang mempunyai nilai availability rate dibawah nilai standard antara lain mesin washer tank bernilai 88,61%, mesin blancher bernilai 87,86%, mesin cooling bernilai 88,30%, mesin grading bernilai 87,98%, mesin sortasi belt bernilai 87,80%, dan mesin retort bernilai 88,43%. | none | Availability | 87.9 % | Both extractors agreed |
—washer tankShow verbatim quote (Section 5, Gambar 4)mesin washer tank dengan nilai 47,22%, mesin blancher dengan nilai 58,32%, mesin cooling dengan nilai 37,85%, mesin grading dengan nilai 51,28%, mesin sortasi belt dengan nilai 54,71%, mesin slicing dengan nilai 49,85%, mesin exhaust dengan nilai 84,55%, mesin seamer dengan nilai 71,80% dan mesin retort dengan nilai 72,81%. | none | OEE | 47.2 % | Both extractors agreed |
—washer tankShow verbatim quote (Section 4, Gambar 3)Perhitungan nilai quality rate mesin washer tank bernilai 99,95%, mesin blancher bernilai 99,87%, mesin cooling bernilai 99,95%, mesin grading bernilai 99,97%, mesin sortasi belt bernilai 99,84%, mesin slicing bernilai 99,12%, mesin exhaust bernilai 100,00%, mesin seamer bernilai 99,80%, dan mesin retort bernilai | none | Quality | 100.0 % | Both extractors agreed |
—washer tankShow verbatim quote (Section 3, Gambar 2)Perhitungan nilai performance rate mesin washer tank bernilai 53,24%, mesin | none | Performance | 53.2 % | Both extractors agreed |
—washer tankShow verbatim quote (Section 2, Gambar 1)Enam mesin yang mempunyai nilai availability rate dibawah nilai standard antara lain mesin washer tank bernilai 88,61%, mesin blancher bernilai 87,86%, mesin cooling bernilai 88,30%, mesin grading bernilai 87,98%, mesin sortasi belt bernilai 87,80%, dan mesin retort bernilai 88,43%. | none | Availability | 88.6 % | Both extractors agreed |
Defect LossesShow verbatim quote (Tabel 2)Rata-Rata 0,099271 9,29814 30,74813 0,00000 0,00000 0,13414 | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Share of planned time | 0.134 % | Both extractors agreed |
Rework LossesShow verbatim quote (Tabel 2)Rata-Rata 0,099271 9,29814 30,74813 0,00000 0,00000 0,13414 | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Share of planned time | 0 % | Both extractors agreed |
Reduced Speed LossesShow verbatim quote (Tabel 2)Rata-Rata 0,099271 9,29814 30,74813 0,00000 0,00000 0,13414 | Reduced speed | Share of planned time | 0 % | Both extractors agreed |
Setup & Adjustment LossesShow verbatim quote (Tabel 2)Rata-Rata 0,099271 9,29814 30,74813 0,00000 0,00000 0,13414 | Setup and adjustments | Share of planned time | 9.30 % | Both extractors agreed |
Breakdown LossesShow verbatim quote (Tabel 2)Rata-Rata 0,099271 9,29814 30,74813 0,00000 0,00000 0,13414 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Share of planned time | 0.0993 % | Both extractors agreed |
—blancherShow verbatim quote (Section 3, Gambar 2)blancher bernilai 66,49%, mesin cooling bernilai 42,90%, mesin grading bernilai 58,30%, mesin sortasi belt bernilai 62,41%, mesin slicing bernilai 54,84%, mesin exhaust bernilai 87,66%, mesin seamer bernilai 77,46%, dan mesin retort bernilai 82,91%. | none | Performance | 66.5 % | Single extractor |
—slicingShow verbatim quote (Section 2, Gambar 1)bernilai 91,44%, mesin exhaust bernilai 96,67%, dan mesin seamer bernilai 92,88%. | none | Availability | 91.4 % | Single extractor |
—retortShow verbatim quote (Section 4, Gambar 3)99,31%. Mesin yang ada di perusahaan sudah bagus dalam menghasilkan keluaran dari masukan bahan | none | Quality | 99.3 % | Single extractor |
Idle & Minor Stoppages LossesShow verbatim quote (Tabel 2)Rata-Rata 0,099271 9,29814 30,74813 0,00000 0,00000 0,13414 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of planned time | 30.7 % | Single extractor |
Idle & Minor Stoppages LossesShow verbatim quote (Section 7, Gambar 9 (Diagram Pareto))Dapat dilihat di grafik bahwa nilai losses terbesar ada pada idle & minor stoppages losses dan setup & adjustment losses yang mewakili 76,34% dan 23,08% dari total losses perusahaan, hal ini tentu saja harus diperbaiki. | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 76.3 % | Single extractor |
Setup & Adjustment LossesShow verbatim quote (Section 7, Gambar 9 (Diagram Pareto))Dapat dilihat di grafik bahwa nilai losses terbesar ada pada idle & minor stoppages losses dan setup & adjustment losses yang mewakili 76,34% dan 23,08% dari total losses perusahaan, hal ini tentu saja harus diperbaiki. | Setup and adjustments | Share of lost time | 23.1 % | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Page 78, Analisis Six Big Losses section)rata-rata losses terbesar terdapat pada idle and minor stoppages losses yang mana rata-rata dari keseluruhan alat berkisar antar 30,748% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of planned time | 30.7 % | Single extractor |
Observation units
- Mesin Retort · Sterilization (retort, UHT) · Baseline
- Mesin Seamer · Capping and seaming · Baseline
- Mesin Exhaust · Cooking and frying · Baseline
- Mesin Slicing · Cutting, slicing and deboning · Baseline
- Mesin Sortasi Belt · Separation (centrifugation, filtration, membranes) · Baseline
- Mesin Grading · Separation (centrifugation, filtration, membranes) · Baseline
- Mesin Cooling · Refrigeration and freezing · Baseline
- Mesin Blancher · Cooking and frying · Baseline
- Mesin Washer Tank · Cleaning in place (CIP) and sanitation · Baseline
- Rata-rata seluruh mesin (line average) · Whole line or unspecified equipment · Baseline
- Divisi Pengalengan Jamur (line average) · Whole line or unspecified equipment · Baseline

