Unspecified process defects
In short
It appears in about 2 of every 100 lines studied.
When it appears, it takes on average about 47 % of the line's lost time. Reported by 6 of the 127 studies that could observe it (good evidence).
What happens
Units produced during otherwise stable running fail to meet specification at first pass because of some combination of equipment drift, material variability or process parameter deviation that the primary report does not attribute to a specific machine or mechanism. The defective output is identified only in aggregate as scrap, rework or downgrade without a named root cause.
What is done about it
Improve defect tagging at the point of rejection so each loss event is linked to a specific machine, station and probable cause code, then use Pareto analysis of the resulting data to prioritize targeted root-cause investigations. In the meantime, tighten incoming material and in-process checks and reinforce operator training to reduce the undifferentiated defect rate.
Practical guidance written from engineering knowledge; it is not a statistical estimate.
1Probability and evidence
- Probability of presence
- 1.7% [0.6–3.7%]
- Expected share of lost time
- 0.8% [0.3–1.7%]
- Share of lost time when present
- 47% [37–57%]
- Studies / units
- 127 / 161
- Evidence grade
- B
Grade B: 5 to 9 studies, or an interval width between 0.20 and 0.35.
2Probability by segment
- Dairy products1.8% [0.3–5.5%]13 studies
- Soft drinks, bottled water and juices1.9% [0.4–5.0%]26 studies
- Brewing, wine and spirits1.8% [0.3–5.3%]11 studies
- Bakery and pasta3.5% [0.8–9.1%]24 studies
- Meat, poultry and seafood2.6% [0.5–7.5%]9 studies
- Fruit and vegetable processing1.8% [0.3–5.5%]7 studies
- Grain and oilseed milling1.9% [0.3–6.0%]6 studies
- Sugar and confectionery2.5% [0.5–7.5%]9 studies
- Snacks, coffee, tea and other foods1.8% [0.3–5.6%]5 studies
- Animal feed and pet food1.8% [0.3–5.5%]7 studies
- Food manufacturing (unspecified or mixed)1.8% [0.3–5.5%]10 studies
3Mechanism, SCADA signature and countermeasure
Mechanism
Engineering guidanceUnits produced during otherwise stable running fail to meet specification at first pass because of some combination of equipment drift, material variability or process parameter deviation that the primary report does not attribute to a specific machine or mechanism. The defective output is identified only in aggregate as scrap, rework or downgrade without a named root cause.
How it looks in SCADA data
Engineering guidanceMES/SCADA records show an aggregate defect, scrap or rework quantity or rate tied to a production order or shift, without a corresponding machine fault code, stop event or named parameter excursion. Quality or vision-inspection counters increment while machine states remain in normal run, so the loss is visible only in yield or reject tallies.
Countermeasure
Engineering guidanceImprove defect tagging at the point of rejection so each loss event is linked to a specific machine, station and probable cause code, then use Pareto analysis of the resulting data to prioritize targeted root-cause investigations. In the meantime, tighten incoming material and in-process checks and reinforce operator training to reduce the undifferentiated defect rate.
4Sources
- Analisis Efektivitas Mesin pada Divisi Pengalengan Jamur Di PT XYZ Menggunakan Metode Overall Equipment Effectiveness (2019)Open sourceShare of planned time: 0.134 % · as reported: “Defect Losses”
Show verbatim quote
Rata-Rata 0,099271 9,29814 30,74813 0,00000 0,00000 0,13414
- Number of events: 19.0 cases · as reported: “nonconforming product”
Show verbatim quote
This is reflected in the production of nonconforming product decrease from 19 cases (2010) to 3 (2013).
- Number of events: 3.00 cases · as reported: “nonconforming product”
Show verbatim quote
This is reflected in the production of nonconforming product decrease from 19 cases (2010) to 3 (2013).
- Enhancing operational efficiency in craft beer production: implementation of lean manufacturing and TPM methodologies in SMES (2025)Open sourceDefect rate: 2.97 % · as reported: “Rate of defective products”
Show verbatim quote
The rate of defective products was reduced from 2.97% to 1.30%, which is equivalent to a 56% decrease.
- Enhancing operational efficiency in craft beer production: implementation of lean manufacturing and TPM methodologies in SMES (2025)Open sourceDefect rate: 1.30 % · as reported: “Rate of defective products”
Show verbatim quote
The rate of defective products was reduced from 2.97% to 1.30%, which is equivalent to a 56% decrease.
- Share of lost time: 19.9 % · as reported: “defects”
Show verbatim quote
Analysis showed the distribution of the losses with set-up and failures being the predominant with 66.4% of total lost time, followed by defects participating with 19.9% and reduced speed and minor stoppage contributing with 13.7%.
- Analisis Efektivitas Mesin pada Divisi Pengalengan Jamur Di PT. Suryajaya Abadiperkasa Menggunakan Metode Overall Equipment Effectiveness (2020)Open sourceShare of lost time: 0.134 % · as reported: “Defect Losses”
Show verbatim quote
Rata-Rata 0,099271 9,29814 30,74813 0,00000 0,00000 0,13414
- Increased equipment performance in agro-industrial companies through a maintenance model based on the TPM approach (2022)Open sourceDefect rate: 11.8 % · as reported: “productos no conformes (PNC)”
Show verbatim quote
se cuenta con una línea de producción donde se obtuvo 98746 latas como productos no conformes teniendo en un índice de 11.75% de la producción planeada comparado con el margen establecido mundial
- Peningkatan Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE) dengan Pendekatan Total Productive Maintenance (TPM) di Line X PT Kraft Ultrajaya Indonesia (2023)Open sourceShare of lost time: 4.00 % · as reported: “Defect Amount”
Show verbatim quote
the loss factors that affect the OEE line X value are Idling and Minor Stoppage with a percentage of 8%, Setup and Adjustment with a percentage of 5%, Defect Amount with a percentage of 4%.
- Production Model Based on Lean Manufacturing, MRP, MPS and TPM to Reduce Losses in a MSE in the Bakery Sector (2023)Open sourceDefect rate: 10.0 % · as reported: “Defective products rate”
Show verbatim quote
Defective product index: This indicator managed to drop from 10% to 5%, with this the company achieved better profitability and had fewer economic losses.
- Production Model Based on Lean Manufacturing, MRP, MPS and TPM to Reduce Losses in a MSE in the Bakery Sector (2023)Open sourceDefect rate: 5.00 % · as reported: “Defective products rate”
Show verbatim quote
Defective product index: This indicator managed to drop from 10% to 5%, with this the company achieved better profitability and had fewer economic losses.
- Share of planned time: 2.20 % · as reported: “Defect in process”
Show verbatim quote
𝐷𝑒𝑓𝑒𝑐𝑡 𝑖𝑛 𝑝𝑟𝑜𝑐𝑒𝑠𝑠= 2,202 %
- Enhancing Operational Efficiency in Craft Beer Production: Implementation of Lean Manufacturing and TPM Methodologies in SMEs (2024)Open sourceDefect rate: 2.97 % · as reported: “rate of defective products”
Show verbatim quote
The rate of defective products was reduced from 2.97% to 1.30%, which is equivalent to a 56% decrease.
- Enhancing Operational Efficiency in Craft Beer Production: Implementation of Lean Manufacturing and TPM Methodologies in SMEs (2024)Open sourceDefect rate: 1.30 % · as reported: “rate of defective products”
Show verbatim quote
The rate of defective products was reduced from 2.97% to 1.30%, which is equivalent to a 56% decrease.
- The implementation of an integrated Lean Management-HACCP model: application in the food industry in Casablanca,Morocco (2025)Open sourceDefect rate: 5.00 % · as reported: “non-compliant products”
Show verbatim quote
Only 5% of non- compliant products per month
- The implementation of an integrated Lean Management-HACCP model: application in the food industry in Casablanca,Morocco (2025)Open sourceLost time: 5.00 min · as reported: “non-conformity”
Show verbatim quote
the non- conformity time to 5 minutes
- The implementation of an integrated Lean Management-HACCP model: application in the food industry in Casablanca,Morocco (2025)Open sourceLost time: 10.0 min · as reported: “Non-quality/ Non-conformity”
Show verbatim quote
Non-quality/ Non-conformity 10 min
- The implementation of an integrated Lean Management-HACCP model: application in the food industry in Casablanca,Morocco (2025)Open sourceDefect rate: 20.0 % · as reported: “products with defects”
Show verbatim quote
20% ofproductswithdefects /month
- A Lean Manufacturing Case Study: Enhancing Efficiency and Reducing Waste in Latin American Food Production (2024)Open sourceShare of lost time: 25.0 % · as reported: “high rate of defective products”
Show verbatim quote
At the first level, three main reasons were identified: a high rate of decline (55%), a high rate of defective products (25%), and elevated unproductive times (20%).
- Integrating Lean Manufacturing and TPM for Production Efficiency Improvement: A Peruvian Case Study in the Bottled Water Industry (2024)Open sourceDefect rate: 3.13 % · as reported: “product defects”
Show verbatim quote
Discards rate | % | 3.13% | 2% | 0.96% | -69.33%
- Integrating Lean Manufacturing and TPM for Production Efficiency Improvement: A Peruvian Case Study in the Bottled Water Industry (2024)Open sourceDefect rate: 0.960 % · as reported: “product defects”
Show verbatim quote
Discards rate | % | 3.13% | 2% | 0.96% | -69.33%
- Reliability-Centered Maintenance Model to Improve OEE in a Mass-Consumption Food Company: A Case Study from Peru (2025)Open sourceShare of lost time: 4.30 % · as reported: “defective products”
Show verbatim quote
The analysis revealed three main reasons contributing to this issue: production line stoppages accounted for 49.2% of the problem, followed by low operational performance with a contribution of 46.5%, and a smaller share of 4.3% attributed to defective products.
- Productivity Improvement Through the Application of Lean Six Sigma Tools in a Non-Alcoholic Beverage Company (2025)Open sourceDefect rate: 9.62 % · as reported: “non-conformance”
Show verbatim quote
Defect rate (%) 9.62% 5.80 – 6.00 % – 40 %
- Lost time: 70.0 min · as reported: “Produto não conforme”
Show verbatim quote
Produto não conforme 12 845 1 087,07 € 70
- Number of events: 12.0 events · as reported: “Produto não conforme”
Show verbatim quote
Produto não conforme 12 845 1 087,07 € 70

