Filling process quality defects
In short
It appears in about 1 of every 100 lines studied.
When it appears, it takes on average about 50 % of the line's lost time. Reported by 7 of the 120 studies that could observe it (good evidence).
What happens
During otherwise stable filling operation, units are produced that fail to meet fill level, weight or container integrity specifications, typically due to valve wear, nozzle drip, product viscosity or density variation, or inconsistent dosing between heads. These non-conforming units are detected at or after the filler and must be scrapped, reworked or downgraded.
What is done about it
Apply statistical process control on fill weight or volume with automatic feedback to the dosing valves, schedule preventive calibration and replacement of wear-prone filling components, and verify incoming product viscosity or density consistency before filling.
Practical guidance written from engineering knowledge; it is not a statistical estimate.
1Probability and evidence
- Probability of presence
- 1.3% [0.4–3.1%]
- Expected share of lost time
- 0.7% [0.2–1.6%]
- Share of lost time when present
- 50% [39–61%]
- Studies / units
- 120 / 162
- Evidence grade
- B
Grade B: 5 to 9 studies, or an interval width between 0.20 and 0.35.
2Probability by segment
- Dairy products1.3% [0.2–4.1%]18 studies
- Soft drinks, bottled water and juices2.7% [0.8–6.1%]44 studies
- Brewing, wine and spirits1.3% [0.2–4.1%]16 studies
- Bakery and pasta1.6% [0.2–5.9%]0 studies
- Meat, poultry and seafood1.4% [0.2–4.4%]6 studies
- Fruit and vegetable processing1.5% [0.2–4.8%]4 studies
- Grain and oilseed milling1.5% [0.2–4.7%]6 studies
- Sugar and confectionery1.6% [0.2–5.4%]3 studies
- Snacks, coffee, tea and other foods2.0% [0.4–6.3%]6 studies
- Animal feed and pet food1.5% [0.2–5.1%]4 studies
- Food manufacturing (unspecified or mixed)1.4% [0.2–4.4%]13 studies
3Mechanism, SCADA signature and countermeasure
Mechanism
Engineering guidanceDuring otherwise stable filling operation, units are produced that fail to meet fill level, weight or container integrity specifications, typically due to valve wear, nozzle drip, product viscosity or density variation, or inconsistent dosing between heads. These non-conforming units are detected at or after the filler and must be scrapped, reworked or downgraded.
How it looks in SCADA data
Engineering guidanceCheckweigher, level sensor or vision inspection downstream of the filler logs an elevated reject or downgrade counter while the filling machine state remains in normal running mode. Fill weight or volume trend data shows drift or increased variance across heads without a corresponding stop event, distinguishing it from jam-related minor stops.
Countermeasure
Engineering guidanceApply statistical process control on fill weight or volume with automatic feedback to the dosing valves, schedule preventive calibration and replacement of wear-prone filling components, and verify incoming product viscosity or density consistency before filling.
4Sources
- Proposal for OEE (Overall Equipment Effectiveness) Indicator Deployment in a Beverage Plant (2012)Open sourceDefect rate: 3.00 % · as reported: “Discarded PET bottles (waste)”
Show verbatim quote
According to the history, the waste of these bottles was around 3%.
- Proposal for OEE (Overall Equipment Effectiveness) Indicator Deployment in a Beverage Plant (2012)Open sourceDefect rate: 3.60 % · as reported: “Return/reuse of after-filling PET bottles”
Show verbatim quote
According to Table 3, an average of 3.6% of the bottles in good conditions of use was reutilized for new bottling processes.
- Application of the Concept of Total Productive Maintenance in Automatic Bottle Filling Machines (2019)Open sourceShare of lost time: 0.100 % · as reported: “Quality Defect and Yield Loses”
Show verbatim quote
Quality Defect and Yield Loses 32,50 0,10 5
- Application of the Concept of Total Productive Maintenance in Automatic Bottle Filling Machines (2019)Open sourceLost time: 32.5 min · as reported: “Quality Defect and Yield Loses”
Show verbatim quote
Quality Defect and Yield Loses 32,50 0,10 5
- Penerapan Total Productive Maintenance (TPM) Produksi Dengan Metode Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE) Pada Proses Produksi Botol (PT. XY Pandaan – Pasuruan) (2020)Open sourceDefect rate: 0.0500 % · as reported: “Reject”
Show verbatim quote
52.10% 99.95% 0,05% 0% 100% 99.37% 99.32%
- Penerapan Total Productive Maintenance (TPM) Produksi Dengan Metode Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE) Pada Proses Produksi Botol (PT. XY Pandaan – Pasuruan) (2020)Open sourceDefect rate: 0 % · as reported: “Pending”
Show verbatim quote
52.10% 99.95% 0,05% 0% 100% 99.37% 99.32%
- Penerapan Total Productive Maintenance (TPM) Produksi Dengan Metode Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE) Pada Proses Produksi Botol (PT. XY Pandaan – Pasuruan) (2020)Open sourceDefect rate: 0.180 % · as reported: “Reject”
Show verbatim quote
13.70% 99.51% 0,18% 0.31% 100% 95.67% 95.20%
- Penerapan Total Productive Maintenance (TPM) Produksi Dengan Metode Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE) Pada Proses Produksi Botol (PT. XY Pandaan – Pasuruan) (2020)Open sourceDefect rate: 0.310 % · as reported: “Pending”
Show verbatim quote
13.70% 99.51% 0,18% 0.31% 100% 95.67% 95.20%
- Penerapan Total Productive Maintenance (TPM) Produksi Dengan Metode Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE) Pada Proses Produksi Botol (PT. XY Pandaan – Pasuruan) (2020)Open sourceDefect rate: 0.390 % · as reported: “Reject”
Show verbatim quote
8.57% 99.61% 0.39% 0% 100% 97.90% 97.52%
- Penerapan Total Productive Maintenance (TPM) Produksi Dengan Metode Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE) Pada Proses Produksi Botol (PT. XY Pandaan – Pasuruan) (2020)Open sourceDefect rate: 0 % · as reported: “Pending”
Show verbatim quote
8.57% 99.61% 0.39% 0% 100% 97.90% 97.52%
- Performance Analysis of Filling Machine Using Overall Equipment Effectiveness Metric in Beverage Company (2023)Open sourceShare of lost time: 8.00 % · as reported: “Defect Process”
Show verbatim quote
Defect Process 585 8 91,4
- Performance Analysis of Filling Machine Using Overall Equipment Effectiveness Metric in Beverage Company (2023)Open sourceLost time: 585 min · as reported: “Defect Process”
Show verbatim quote
Defect Process 585 8 91,4
- Analisis Produktivitas Mesin Filling Botol Dengan Metode Overal Equipment Effectiveness Dan Failure Mode And Effect Analysis (2023)Open sourceShare of loss events: 15.6 % · as reported: “Defect Losses”
Show verbatim quote
Reduce Speed Losses with an average proportion of 3.82% and a relative frequency of 39.01%, Downtime Losses with an average of 2.27% and a relative frequency of 28.31%, Defect Losses with an average of 1.58% and a relative frequency of 15.59%, Idle and Minor Stoppage with an average of 1.55% and a relative frequency of 15.85%.
- Analisis Produktivitas Mesin Filling Botol Dengan Metode Overal Equipment Effectiveness Dan Failure Mode And Effect Analysis (2023)Open sourceShare of planned time: 1.58 % · as reported: “Defect Losses”
Show verbatim quote
Reduce Speed Losses with an average proportion of 3.82% and a relative frequency of 39.01%, Downtime Losses with an average of 2.27% and a relative frequency of 28.31%, Defect Losses with an average of 1.58% and a relative frequency of 15.59%, Idle and Minor Stoppage with an average of 1.55% and a relative frequency of 15.85%.
- A SEMINAR PAPER ON “OVERALL EQUIPMENT EFFECTIVENESS: A CASE STUDY AT A BOTTLING PLANT” (2023)Open sourceNumber of events: 2,134 bottles · as reported: “Reject Bottles”
Show verbatim quote
105334 2134 8 1.5 0.62 385
- A SEMINAR PAPER ON “OVERALL EQUIPMENT EFFECTIVENESS: A CASE STUDY AT A BOTTLING PLANT” (2023)Open sourceNumber of events: 2,483 bottles · as reported: “Reject Bottles”
Show verbatim quote
88883 2483 8 2 0.83 385
- A SEMINAR PAPER ON “OVERALL EQUIPMENT EFFECTIVENESS: A CASE STUDY AT A BOTTLING PLANT” (2023)Open sourceNumber of events: 2,359 bottles · as reported: “Reject Bottles”
Show verbatim quote
93559 2359 8 0.75 0.75 385
- Analisis Overall Equipment Effectiveness untuk Meningkatkan Efektivitas Mesin Filling Multiline pada PT-XYZ (2023)Open sourceLost time: 3.40 jam · as reported: “Defect Losses”
Show verbatim quote
Defect Losses 3,40 48,93 96,88%
- Technical Analysis and Solutions to Reduce Scrap Rate In Liquid Filler Machine: Case Study: In Moha Soft Drink Production Line (2025)Open sourceNumber of events: 49,044 cases · as reported: “Total scrap”
Show verbatim quote
Total | 20598 | 14508 | 8124 | 4518 | 1296 | 49044
- Optimizing Side Guard Angles on Multi-to-Single Conveyors to Minimize Infeed Stuck and Increase Overall Equipment Effectiveness (2026)Open sourceNumber of events: 9.00 kaleng · as reported: “Produk Cacat / Reject”
Show verbatim quote
Produk Cacat / Reject (kaleng) 65 9 -56 kaleng
- Optimizing Side Guard Angles on Multi-to-Single Conveyors to Minimize Infeed Stuck and Increase Overall Equipment Effectiveness (2026)Open sourceNumber of events: 65.0 kaleng · as reported: “Produk Cacat / Reject”
Show verbatim quote
Produk Cacat / Reject (kaleng) 65 9 -56 kaleng

