Included study
Integration of Energy Saving with Lean Production in a Food Processing Company
1Bibliographic record
- Authors
- Sameh A. Salah, Ahmad Mustafa
- Year
- 2021
- Venue
- Journal of Machine Engineering
- Country
- Egypt
- Segment
- Dairy products
- Process family
- Filling and packaging line
- Study type
- Before/after intervention
- Extraction scope
- Full text
- Size
- 1 plants · 1 lines · — machines
- Observation period
- —
- Data collection
- not_reported
- Intervention
Show the setting as described by the study
The production line 22 produces cheese in one kg with many recipes.
2Risk of bias
Scored with the rubric of the protocol: 2 low concern, 1 some concerns, 0 high concern.
Total score 11Moderate risk
| Item | Score |
|---|---|
| Is the observed line, machine or plant described well enough to classify its segment, process and equipment?Product, process and equipment are all described. | 2 / 2 |
| Is the observation period long enough and reported?Period reported but shorter than 30 days, or only the number of shifts is given. | 1 / 2 |
| How were loss data collected?Interviews, estimates, or method not reported. | 0 / 2 |
| Are OEE, loading time and the loss categories defined explicitly?A standard definition is cited but its application is not shown. | 1 / 2 |
| Does the loss breakdown account for the total loss it claims to explain?The reported causes or categories sum to at least 90% of the stated total, or an explicit "other" class closes the balance. | 2 / 2 |
| Is there evidence of selective reporting of favourable results?Observational study, or intervention study that reports baseline and post-intervention data with the same method. | 2 / 2 |
| Are the reported numbers internally consistent?Recomputed totals, shares and OEE factors agree with the reported values within 2 percentage points. | 2 / 2 |
| Could conflicts of interest or the source of the data bias the result?Authors are employees of the plant or of an equipment/software vendor; no declaration. | 1 / 2 |
3Extracted data
Each datum with its classification and the verbatim quote that states it.
| Reported cause | Loss category | Metric | Value | Extraction |
|---|---|---|---|---|
LaborShow verbatim quote (Table 7)Average wasted time Per Shift (Sec/shift) 0 - 152 116 | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Lost time | 0 Sec/shift | Both extractors agreed |
Changeover for new batchTetra Pak unitShow verbatim quote (Section 4)The changeover time reduced from 94 second to 45 second per changeover. | Setup and adjustments | Mean event duration | 45.0 s | Both extractors agreed |
LaborShow verbatim quote (Table 6)Average wasted time Per Shift (Sec/shift) 1712 | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Lost time | 1,712 Sec/shift | Both extractors agreed |
Changeover for new batchShow verbatim quote (Section 3.4, Data Analysis for waste)Number of changeover per month = 15 changeover/Month. | Setup and adjustments | Number of events | 15.0 changeover/Month | Both extractors agreed |
Changeover for new batchTetra Pak unitShow verbatim quote (Section 3.4, Data Analysis for waste)Changeover time is calculated with 94 min. | Setup and adjustments | Mean event duration | 94.0 min | Both extractors agreed |
Strapping machineStrapping machineShow verbatim quote (Table 6)Average wasted time Per Shift (Sec/shift) 1712 - 286 192 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Lost time | 192 Sec/shift | Adjudicated |
Strapping machineStrapping machineShow verbatim quote (Table 7)Average wasted time Per Shift (Sec/shift) 0 - 152 116 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Lost time | 116 Sec/shift | Adjudicated |
Final folderFinal folderShow verbatim quote (Table 7)Average wasted time Per Shift (Sec/shift) 0 - 152 116 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Lost time | 152 Sec/shift | Adjudicated |
Final folderFinal folderShow verbatim quote (Table 6)Average wasted time Per Shift (Sec/shift) 1712 - 286 192 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Lost time | 286 Sec/shift | Adjudicated |
—Show verbatim quote (Fig. 3 / Table 4)Line 19 Line 20 Line 21 Line 22 SEC(KWh/Ton) 177,7 196,7 96,3 221,2 | none | Specific energy | 221 KWh/Ton | Both extractors agreed |
Changeover for new batchShow verbatim quote (Table 5)Changeover for new batch 1410 Waiting | Setup and adjustments | Lost time | 1,410 Minutes | Adjudicated |
Final folderFinal folderShow verbatim quote (Table 5)Final folder 286 Waiting / Rework | Not classifiable from the report | Lost time | 286 Minutes | Adjudicated |
Strapping machineStrapping machineShow verbatim quote (Table 5)Strapping machine 192 Waiting, Defects | Not classifiable from the report | Lost time | 192 Minutes | Adjudicated |
—Tetra Pak unitShow verbatim quote (Section 3.4, Data Analysis for waste)Production rate = 60 Pack cheese 1kg/minute. | none | Throughput | 60.0 Pack cheese 1kg/minute | Single extractor |
Raw materialsShow verbatim quote (Table 5)Raw materials 48 Unnecessary motion | Not classifiable from the report | Lost time | 48.0 Minutes | Single extractor |
Tetra Pak unitTetra Pak unitShow verbatim quote (Table 5)Tetra Pak unit 83 Defects, rework, over processing | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Lost time | 83.0 Minutes | Single extractor |
ConveyorConveyorShow verbatim quote (Table 5)Conveyor 46 Defects, inventory | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Lost time | 46.0 Minutes | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 8)SEC (KWh/ton) 221.2 187.9 33.3 15.1 | none | Specific energy | 188 KWh/ton | Single extractor |
Defects - labor manual process over/under weight packsShow verbatim quote (Table 7, Labor row)Average waste Per Month (Ton/Month) 0 | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Lost time | 0 ton | Single extractor |
Changeover for new batchShow verbatim quote (Table 7, Changeover row)Average waste Per Month (Ton/Month) 45 | Setup and adjustments | Lost time | 45.0 ton | Single extractor |
Final folderfinal folderShow verbatim quote (Table 7, Final folder row)Average waste Per Month (Ton/Month) 9.120 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Lost time | 9.12 ton | Single extractor |
Strapping machinestrapping machineShow verbatim quote (Table 7, Strapping machine row)Average waste Per Month (Ton/Month) 6.96 | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Lost time | 6.96 ton | Single extractor |
Observation units
- Line 22 · Whole line or unspecified equipment · After intervention
- Line 22 · Whole line or unspecified equipment · Baseline

