Included study
Waste Management and Operational Efficiency Improvement in Cake and Pastry Factory Through Adapting DMAIC Methodology
1Bibliographic record
- Authors
- Kaouther Ghacham, Shoug Ghanem Alshawi, Raghad Muhammed Aljaloud, Malath Abdulkarim Alrawdhan, Munerah Saleh Alrudhyan, Lial Hamad Almari
- Year
- 2026
- Venue
- International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Operations Management (IEOM)
- Country
- Saudi Arabia
- Segment
- Bakery and pasta
- Process family
- Forming, baking and cooking
- Study type
- Before/after intervention
- Extraction scope
- Full text
- Size
- 1 plants · 3 lines · 9 machines
- Observation period
- 300 days
- Data collection
- manual_logs
- Intervention
Show the setting as described by the study
This study focuses on reducing waste and enhancing operations in a bun production line within a leading bakery manufacturer that has over 40 years of experience in the fast-food and baking industry and is ranked among the top 50 most valuable brands in Saudi Arabia.
2Risk of bias
Scored with the rubric of the protocol: 2 low concern, 1 some concerns, 0 high concern.
Total score 12Moderate risk
| Item | Score |
|---|---|
| Is the observed line, machine or plant described well enough to classify its segment, process and equipment?Product, process and equipment are all described. | 2 / 2 |
| Is the observation period long enough and reported?Period reported and at least 30 days of production (or at least 100 recorded events). | 2 / 2 |
| How were loss data collected?Manual logs or maintenance records with unknown completeness. | 1 / 2 |
| Are OEE, loading time and the loss categories defined explicitly?No definition; metrics are reported as bare numbers. | 0 / 2 |
| Does the loss breakdown account for the total loss it claims to explain?The reported causes or categories sum to at least 90% of the stated total, or an explicit "other" class closes the balance. | 2 / 2 |
| Is there evidence of selective reporting of favourable results?Intervention study in which baseline and post-intervention periods differ in length or method. | 1 / 2 |
| Are the reported numbers internally consistent?Recomputed totals, shares and OEE factors agree with the reported values within 2 percentage points. | 2 / 2 |
| Could conflicts of interest or the source of the data bias the result?Academic or independent study, or conflicts declared and unrelated to the result. | 2 / 2 |
3Extracted data
Each datum with its classification and the verbatim quote that states it.
| Reported cause | Loss category | Metric | Value | Extraction |
|---|---|---|---|---|
time wasteShow verbatim quote (Section 5.2.3 Solutions Execution)Implementation led to a 13% reduction in food waste, from 1.13% to 0.983%, 5% increase in OEE, from 52.6% to 55.4%, and a 31.6% reduction in time waste, dropping from 12.8% to 8.76%, successfully meeting the project objectives. | Not classifiable from the report | Share of planned time | 8.76 % | Both extractors agreed |
—Show verbatim quote (Section 5.2.3 Solutions Execution)Implementation led to a 13% reduction in food waste, from 1.13% to 0.983%, 5% increase in OEE, from 52.6% to 55.4%, and a 31.6% reduction in time waste, dropping from 12.8% to 8.76%, successfully meeting the project objectives. | none | OEE | 55.4 % | Both extractors agreed |
DividerDividerShow verbatim quote (Section 5.1.2 Time Waste / Figure 4)Divider exhibits the highest probability of failure in the upcoming month, indicated by the most significant number of recorded breakdowns (30 incidents). The high failure frequency combined with moderate repair time (MTTR = 42.1 minutes). | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Mean event duration | 42.1 min | Both extractors agreed |
DividerDividerShow verbatim quote (Section 5.1.2 Time Waste / Figure 4)Divider exhibits the highest probability of failure in the upcoming month, indicated by the most significant number of recorded breakdowns (30 incidents). The high failure frequency combined with moderate repair time (MTTR = 42.1 minutes). | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Number of events | 30.0 events | Both extractors agreed |
ProoferProoferShow verbatim quote (Section 5.1.2 Time Waste / Figure 4)Proofer, with a recorded 27 failures, has the longest average MTTR (121.22) and reliability at only 4.25%, underscoring its substantial impact on unplanned downtime. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Mean event duration | 121 min | Both extractors agreed |
prooferProoferShow verbatim quote (Figure 2 / Section 4.2)Analysis of breakdown sources in Figure 2 showed that the proofer was the most critical contributor with 55 hours lost across 28 incidents, followed by power interruption during the Eid al-Fitr season. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Number of events | 28.0 events | Both extractors agreed |
prooferProoferShow verbatim quote (Figure 2 / Section 4.2)Analysis of breakdown sources in Figure 2 showed that the proofer was the most critical contributor with 55 hours lost across 28 incidents, followed by power interruption during the Eid al-Fitr season. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 55.0 h | Both extractors agreed |
Power InterruptionShow verbatim quote (Section 5.1.2 Time Waste)The Power Interruption category only happened twice; it had a high MTTR of 913.5 minutes, which brought the reliability down to 79.22%. | Organizational or external stops (material or personnel shortage, utilities outage) | Mean event duration | 914 min | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownsShow verbatim quote (Section 4.2 Measure Phase)Over the course of ten months in 2024, 187 breakdowns resulted in 204.75 hours of downtime (3.032% of production time), an acceptable rate that requires ongoing monitoring, particularly for trends that persist. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Share of planned time | 3.03 % | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownsShow verbatim quote (Section 4.2 Measure Phase)Over the course of ten months in 2024, 187 breakdowns resulted in 204.75 hours of downtime (3.032% of production time), an acceptable rate that requires ongoing monitoring, particularly for trends that persist. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 205 h | Both extractors agreed |
breakdownsShow verbatim quote (Section 4.2 Measure Phase)Over the course of ten months in 2024, 187 breakdowns resulted in 204.75 hours of downtime (3.032% of production time), an acceptable rate that requires ongoing monitoring, particularly for trends that persist. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Number of events | 187 events | Both extractors agreed |
—Show verbatim quote (Section 4.2 Measure Phase)The 2024 performance yielded a 98.55% yield with an 82% automation level, but moderate technology utilization was observed, indicating untapped potential and weak process control that require further investigation. | none | Yield | 98.6 % | Both extractors agreed |
—Show verbatim quote (Section 5.1.4)Results showed an Availability of 82.41%, a Performance of 87%, and a Quality rate of 68.18%, leading to an overall OEE of 48.64% and indicating potential for improvement, as world-class OEE values typically exceed 85%. | none | OEE | 48.6 % | Both extractors agreed |
—Show verbatim quote (Section 5.1.4)Results showed an Availability of 82.41%, a Performance of 87%, and a Quality rate of 68.18%, leading to an overall OEE of 48.64% and indicating potential for improvement, as world-class OEE values typically exceed 85%. | none | Quality | 68.2 % | Both extractors agreed |
—Show verbatim quote (Section 5.1.4)Results showed an Availability of 82.41%, a Performance of 87%, and a Quality rate of 68.18%, leading to an overall OEE of 48.64% and indicating potential for improvement, as world-class OEE values typically exceed 85%. | none | Performance | 87.0 % | Both extractors agreed |
—Show verbatim quote (Section 5.1.4)Results showed an Availability of 82.41%, a Performance of 87%, and a Quality rate of 68.18%, leading to an overall OEE of 48.64% and indicating potential for improvement, as world-class OEE values typically exceed 85%. | none | Availability | 82.4 % | Both extractors agreed |
breakdown time and changeover timeShow verbatim quote (Section 4.2 Measure Phase)The waste of breakdown time and changeover time together accounted for 12.8% of production time. | Not classifiable from the report | Share of planned time | 12.8 % | Both extractors agreed |
changeover timeShow verbatim quote (Section 4.2 Measure Phase)Changeover activities during January 2025 consumed 66.63 hours, which accounted for 9.77% of total production time, a relatively high percentage attributed to the product variety. | Setup and adjustments | Share of planned time | 9.77 % | Both extractors agreed |
changeover timeShow verbatim quote (Section 4.2 Measure Phase)Changeover activities during January 2025 consumed 66.63 hours, which accounted for 9.77% of total production time, a relatively high percentage attributed to the product variety. | Setup and adjustments | Lost time | 66.6 h | Both extractors agreed |
—Show verbatim quote (Section 4.1 Define Phase)improving Overall Equipment Effectiveness from its current level of 48% to more than 55% is crucial for enhancing productivity and achieving sustainability | none | OEE | 48.0 % | Single extractor |
total food wasteShow verbatim quote (Section 4.2 Measure Phase)total waste increased from 85,252 kg (0.42%) in 2022 to 286,723.99 kg (1.48%) in 2024, representing a 236% increase, while downtime increased from 106.26 hours to 244.17 hours, despite production levels remaining relatively stable at around 20 million units. | Not classifiable from the report | Defect rate | 0.420 % | Single extractor |
total food wasteShow verbatim quote (Section 4.2 Measure Phase)total waste increased from 85,252 kg (0.42%) in 2022 to 286,723.99 kg (1.48%) in 2024, representing a 236% increase, while downtime increased from 106.26 hours to 244.17 hours, despite production levels remaining relatively stable at around 20 million units. | Not classifiable from the report | Defect rate | 1.48 % | Single extractor |
total food wasteShow verbatim quote (Section 4.2 Measure Phase)total waste increased from 85,252 kg (0.42%) in 2022 to 286,723.99 kg (1.48%) in 2024, representing a 236% increase, while downtime increased from 106.26 hours to 244.17 hours, despite production levels remaining relatively stable at around 20 million units. | Not classifiable from the report | Defect rate | 85,252 kg | Single extractor |
total food wasteShow verbatim quote (Section 4.2 Measure Phase)Total food waste in the bun production line was 286,723.99 kg in 2024, representing approximately 1.5% of total production. | Not classifiable from the report | Defect rate | 286,724 kg | Single extractor |
total food wasteShow verbatim quote (Section 4.2 Measure Phase)Total food waste in the bun production line was 286,723.99 kg in 2024, representing approximately 1.5% of total production. | Not classifiable from the report | Defect rate | 1.50 % | Single extractor |
downtimeShow verbatim quote (Section 4.2 Measure Phase)total waste increased from 85,252 kg (0.42%) in 2022 to 286,723.99 kg (1.48%) in 2024, representing a 236% increase, while downtime increased from 106.26 hours to 244.17 hours, despite production levels remaining relatively stable at around 20 million units. | Not classifiable from the report | Lost time | 106 h | Single extractor |
downtimeShow verbatim quote (Section 4.2 Measure Phase)total waste increased from 85,252 kg (0.42%) in 2022 to 286,723.99 kg (1.48%) in 2024, representing a 236% increase, while downtime increased from 106.26 hours to 244.17 hours, despite production levels remaining relatively stable at around 20 million units. | Not classifiable from the report | Lost time | 244 h | Single extractor |
total food wasteShow verbatim quote (Section 4.2 Measure Phase)Over the course of ten months in 2024, the total food waste amounted to 182,539 kg. | Not classifiable from the report | Defect rate | 182,539 kg | Single extractor |
production wasteShow verbatim quote (Section 4.2 Measure Phase)It is categorized into three primary sources: production waste at 37.7%, breakdown waste at 61.7%, and R&D waste at 0.6%. | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Defect rate | 37.7 % | Single extractor |
breakdown wasteShow verbatim quote (Section 4.2 Measure Phase)It is categorized into three primary sources: production waste at 37.7%, breakdown waste at 61.7%, and R&D waste at 0.6%. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Defect rate | 61.7 % | Single extractor |
R&D wasteShow verbatim quote (Section 4.2 Measure Phase)It is categorized into three primary sources: production waste at 37.7%, breakdown waste at 61.7%, and R&D waste at 0.6%. | Not classifiable from the report | Defect rate | 0.600 % | Single extractor |
R&D wasteShow verbatim quote (Section 4.2 Measure Phase)R&D waste, though minor at 1,158.98 kg in January 2024, represented 6.55% of experimental activity waste in the month. | Not classifiable from the report | Defect rate | 1,159 kg | Single extractor |
R&D wasteShow verbatim quote (Section 4.2 Measure Phase)R&D waste, though minor at 1,158.98 kg in January 2024, represented 6.55% of experimental activity waste in the month. | Not classifiable from the report | Share of lost time | 6.55 % | Single extractor |
non-productive activitiesShow verbatim quote (Section 4.2 Measure Phase)Based on January 2025 performance, 86.5% of planned production time was used effectively, while 13.5% was lost to non-productive activities, including setup, changeover, machine downtime, and maintenance. | Not classifiable from the report | Share of planned time | 13.5 % | Single extractor |
breakdown eventsShow verbatim quote (Figure 5 / Section 5.1.2)Analysis of 200 breakdown events by shift (Day: 6 AM - 6 PM, Night: 6 PM - 6 AM), Figure 5 showed a higher concentration of incidents during the night shift, particularly in the late evening and early morning hours. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Number of events | 200 events | Single extractor |
depanning failuresdepannerShow verbatim quote (Section 5.1.1 Food Waste)The depanning failures, representing approximately 46.5% of production waste, were identified as the most significant contribution. | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Defect rate | 46.5 % | Single extractor |
proofing and baking deviationsShow verbatim quote (Section 5.1.1 Food Waste)Proofing and baking deviations, together accounting for 27% of production waste, were primarily linked to equipment malfunctions in the proofer and oven discussed earlier. | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Defect rate | 27.0 % | Single extractor |
ingredient mixing errorsShow verbatim quote (Section 5.1.1 Food Waste)Ingredient mixing errors (12.5%) were another source of loss, due to manual weighing and human variability. | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Defect rate | 12.5 % | Single extractor |
topping and panning failuresShow verbatim quote (Section 5.1.1 Food Waste)Similarly, topping and panning failures (13.9% combined) occurred when dough balls were misaligned in pans or when glazing and sesame seeds were applied unsuccessfully. | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Defect rate | 13.9 % | Single extractor |
DepannerdepannerShow verbatim quote (Section 5.2 Improve Phase)Analysis showed that the Imprinter caused 53% of breakdown-related waste (32.7% of total), followed by the Depanner at 17.4% and Ingredient Mixing at 12.9%. | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Defect rate | 17.4 % | Single extractor |
Ingredient MixingShow verbatim quote (Section 5.2 Improve Phase)Analysis showed that the Imprinter caused 53% of breakdown-related waste (32.7% of total), followed by the Depanner at 17.4% and Ingredient Mixing at 12.9%. | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Defect rate | 12.9 % | Single extractor |
ImprinterImprinterShow verbatim quote (Figure 1 / Section 4.2)Pareto analysis (Figure 1) identified the imprinter machine as having the most significant contribution at 59,692 kg and requiring the highest level of priority for corrective action. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Defect rate | 59,692 kg | Single extractor |
ImprinterImprinterShow verbatim quote (Section 5.1.1 Food Waste)The earlier Pareto chart shown in Figure 1 identified the imprinter machine as the most critical source, contributing 53% of breakdown waste and 32.7% of total food waste. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Defect rate | 53.0 % | Single extractor |
ImprinterImprinterShow verbatim quote (Section 5.1.1 Food Waste)The earlier Pareto chart shown in Figure 1 identified the imprinter machine as the most critical source, contributing 53% of breakdown waste and 32.7% of total food waste. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Defect rate | 32.7 % | Single extractor |
ProoferProoferShow verbatim quote (Section 5.1.1 Food Waste)The proof was identified as the second-largest contributor to breakdown waste, generating 14,820 kg of waste due to repeated failures in its endless drive system. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Defect rate | 14,820 kg | Single extractor |
ProoferProoferShow verbatim quote (Section 5.1.2 Time Waste / Figure 4)Proofer, with a recorded 27 failures, has the longest average MTTR (121.22) and reliability at only 4.25%, underscoring its substantial impact on unplanned downtime. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Number of events | 27.0 events | Single extractor |
ovenOvenShow verbatim quote (Section 5.1.1 Food Waste)Next, the oven, with 7,392 kg of waste, experienced frequent jamming and gas supply fluctuations, resulting in uneven baking and temperature deviations. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Defect rate | 7,392 kg | Single extractor |
food wasteShow verbatim quote (Section 5.2.3 Solutions Execution)Implementation resulted in a reduction of 24.8% in food waste, from 1.5% to 1.13%, and a 7.11% increase in OEE, from 48% to 52.6%. | Not classifiable from the report | Defect rate | 1.13 % | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Section 5.2.3 Solutions Execution)Implementation resulted in a reduction of 24.8% in food waste, from 1.5% to 1.13%, and a 7.11% increase in OEE, from 48% to 52.6%. | none | OEE | 52.6 % | Single extractor |
food wasteShow verbatim quote (Section 5.2.3 Solutions Execution)Implementation led to a 13% reduction in food waste, from 1.13% to 0.983%, 5% increase in OEE, from 52.6% to 55.4%, and a 31.6% reduction in time waste, dropping from 12.8% to 8.76%, successfully meeting the project objectives. | Not classifiable from the report | Defect rate | 0.983 % | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Section 4.2)Total food waste in the bun production line was 286,723.99 kg in 2024, representing approximately 1.5% of total production. | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Share of planned time | 1.50 % | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Section 4.2)It is categorized into three primary sources: production waste at 37.7%, breakdown waste at 61.7%, and R&D waste at 0.6%. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Share of lost time | 61.7 % | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Section 4.2)It is categorized into three primary sources: production waste at 37.7%, breakdown waste at 61.7%, and R&D waste at 0.6%. | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Share of lost time | 37.7 % | Single extractor |
imprinter machineimprinterShow verbatim quote (Section 4.2)Pareto analysis (Figure 1) identified the imprinter machine as having the most significant contribution at 59,692 kg and requiring the highest level of priority for corrective action. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 59,692 kg | Single extractor |
proofer endless drive system failuresprooferShow verbatim quote (Section 5.1.1)The proof was identified as the second-largest contributor to breakdown waste, generating 14,820 kg of waste due to repeated failures in its endless drive system. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 14,820 kg | Single extractor |
oven jamming and gas supply fluctuationsovenShow verbatim quote (Section 5.1.1)Next, the oven, with 7,392 kg of waste, experienced frequent jamming and gas supply fluctuations, resulting in uneven baking and temperature deviations. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 7,392 kg | Single extractor |
depanning failuresdepannerShow verbatim quote (Section 5.1.1)The depanning failures, representing approximately 46.5% of production waste, were identified as the most significant contribution. | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Share of lost time | 46.5 % | Single extractor |
proofing and baking deviationsproofer, ovenShow verbatim quote (Section 5.1.1)Proofing and baking deviations, together accounting for 27% of production waste, were primarily linked to equipment malfunctions in the proofer and oven | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Share of lost time | 27.0 % | Single extractor |
ingredient mixing errorsShow verbatim quote (Section 5.1.1)Ingredient mixing errors (12.5%) were another source of loss, due to manual weighing and human variability. | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Share of lost time | 12.5 % | Single extractor |
panning and topping failurespannerShow verbatim quote (Section 5.1.1)Similarly, topping and panning failures (13.9% combined) occurred when dough balls were misaligned in pans or when glazing and sesame seeds were applied unsuccessfully. | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Share of lost time | 13.9 % | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Section 5.2.3)In Phase 2, from April to May 2025, similar product scheduling was implemented, along with preventive maintenance and the standardization of color-coded measuring tools. Implementation led to a 13% reduction in food waste, from 1.13% to 0.983% | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Share of planned time | 0.983 % | Single extractor |
Observation units
- Bun production line (Phase 2) · Whole line or unspecified equipment · After intervention
- Divider · Forming, moulding and depositing · Baseline
- Proofer · Fermentation · Baseline
- Bun production line · Whole line or unspecified equipment · Baseline
- Imprinter · Forming, moulding and depositing · Baseline
- Oven · Baking · Baseline
- Bun production line (Phase 1) · Whole line or unspecified equipment · After intervention
- Bun Production Line · Whole line or unspecified equipment · After intervention

