Included study
Reliability Measurement of Torque Transmission System for Spice Manufacturing Plant
1Bibliographic record
- Authors
- Jivan Rao, Shamsul Sarip, Mohd Nabil Muhtazaruddin, Siti Armiza Mohd Aris, Mohamed Azlan Suhot, Mohamad Zaki Hassan, Roslina Mohammad, Mohd Yusof Md Daud, Sa’ardin Abdul Aziz, Nurul Aini Bani, Hazilah Mad Kaidi, Rasheed Mohamed Kutty, Nor Fazilah Mohd Hashim
- Year
- 2019
- Venue
- International Journal of Engineering & Technology
- Country
- Malaysia
- Segment
- Snacks, coffee, tea and other foods
- Process family
- Milling, extraction and separation
- Study type
- Multiple case study
- Extraction scope
- Full text
- Size
- 1 plants · — lines · 2 machines
- Observation period
- 427 days
- Data collection
- maintenance_records
- Intervention
Show the setting as described by the study
This study focuses on vertical roller mills used to grind the 'chili' flakes into fine powder, and its productivity for different drive systems, namely belt drive and gearbox drive.
2Risk of bias
Scored with the rubric of the protocol: 2 low concern, 1 some concerns, 0 high concern.
Total score 14Low risk
| Item | Score |
|---|---|
| Is the observed line, machine or plant described well enough to classify its segment, process and equipment?Product, process and equipment are all described. | 2 / 2 |
| Is the observation period long enough and reported?Period reported and at least 30 days of production (or at least 100 recorded events). | 2 / 2 |
| How were loss data collected?Automatic line monitoring, or systematic logs covering every stop in the period. | 2 / 2 |
| Are OEE, loading time and the loss categories defined explicitly?A standard definition is cited but its application is not shown. | 1 / 2 |
| Does the loss breakdown account for the total loss it claims to explain?Only the top causes are reported and the unexplained remainder can be computed. | 1 / 2 |
| Is there evidence of selective reporting of favourable results?Observational study, or intervention study that reports baseline and post-intervention data with the same method. | 2 / 2 |
| Are the reported numbers internally consistent?Recomputed totals, shares and OEE factors agree with the reported values within 2 percentage points. | 2 / 2 |
| Could conflicts of interest or the source of the data bias the result?Academic or independent study, or conflicts declared and unrelated to the result. | 2 / 2 |
3Extracted data
Each datum with its classification and the verbatim quote that states it.
| Reported cause | Loss category | Metric | Value | Extraction |
|---|---|---|---|---|
—Show verbatim quote (Table 4)Energy consumption/kg 2.014kWh/kg 3.295kWh/kg | none | Specific energy | 2.01 kWh/kg | Both extractors agreed |
Roller arm locker plate bolt/scrapper failureroller arm locker plate bolt / scrapperShow verbatim quote (Table 3)Roller arm locker plate bolt/scrapper failure 2807.21 0.79 699.70 2.30 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Time between events | 2,807 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
Roller arm failures/Liner replacementroller arm/linerShow verbatim quote (Table 3)Roller arm failures/Liner replacement 2805.00 3.00 2794.5 13.5 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Mean event duration | 3.00 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 4)Throughput 7.18 kg/hour 4.14 kg/hour | none | Throughput | 7.18 kg/h | Both extractors agreed |
Drive related failuresbelt drive / transmission shaftShow verbatim quote (Table 3)Drive related failures 1685.17 6.83 - - | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Time between events | 1,685 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
Mill centre shaft failure/Servicecentre shaftShow verbatim quote (Table 3)Mill centre shaft failure/Service - - 2734.38 73.63 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Time between events | 2,734 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
Variable frequency drive failureVFD/inverterShow verbatim quote (Table 3)Variable frequency drive failure - - 2806.00 2.00 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Time between events | 2,806 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
V1: Transmission shaft (TS1) bottom pulley end brokentransmission shaft pulleyShow verbatim quote (Table 1)01/16/17 017640 V1: Transmission shaft (TS1) bottom pulley end broken CMU 16 2 18 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 18.0 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
V4: Roller arm locker plate bolt brokenroller arm locker plate boltShow verbatim quote (Table 2)12/08/15 014601 V4: Roller arm locker plate bolt broken CMU 0 1 1 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 1.00 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
V1: Roller arm jammed/Roller arm changeroller armShow verbatim quote (Table 1)08/30/16 016657 V1: Roller arm jammed/Roller arm change CMU 0 3 3 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 3.00 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
V1: Roller arm (R63) locker plate bolt brokenroller arm locker plate boltShow verbatim quote (Table 1)03/08/16 015266 V1: Roller arm (R63) locker plate bolt broken CMU 0 0.58 0.58 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 0.580 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
V1: Roller arm/Liner replacementroller arm/linerShow verbatim quote (Table 1)01/06/16 014500 V1: Roller arm/Liner replacement CMP 0 3 3 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 3.00 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
V1: Center shaft - transmission shaft belt changetransmission shaft beltShow verbatim quote (Table 1)12/19/16 017414 V1: Center shaft - transmission shaft belt change CMP 0 1.25 1.25 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 1.25 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
V1: Center shaft pulley belts turned overcenter shaft pulley beltShow verbatim quote (Table 1)12/29/16 017518 V1: Center shaft pulley belts turned over CMU 0 1.5 1.5 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 1.50 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
V4: Center shaft service (Sleeve worn out)centre shaft sleeveShow verbatim quote (Table 2)12/24/15 014674 V4: Center shaft service (Sleeve worn out) CMU 112 13.25 125.25 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 125 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
V1: Belt drive cover damagedbelt drive coverShow verbatim quote (Table 1)02/22/16 015173 V1: Belt drive cover damaged CMP 0.75 0.5 1.25 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 1.25 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
V4: Roller arm locker plate bolt broken/Roller arm (R21) changeroller arm (R21)Show verbatim quote (Table 2)12/04/15 014523 V4: Roller arm locker plate bolt broken/Roller arm (R21) change CMU 4 4 8 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 8.00 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 4)Availability 96.81% 99.47% | none | Availability | 96.8 % | Both extractors agreed |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 4)Availability 96.81% 99.47% | none | Availability | 99.5 % | Both extractors agreed |
V1: Mill jammed/1 unit scrapper brokenscrapperShow verbatim quote (Table 1)12/28/16 017504 V1: Mill jammed/ 1 unit scrapper broken CMU 0 1 1 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 1.00 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
Mill centre shaft failure/Servicecentre shaftShow verbatim quote (Table 3)Mill centre shaft failure/Service - - 2734.38 73.63 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Mean event duration | 73.6 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
Overall/Mixed failure modesShow verbatim quote (Table 3)Overall/Mixed failure modes 698.30 3.70 362.49 11.91 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Time between events | 698 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
Roller arm failures/Liner replacementroller arm/linerShow verbatim quote (Table 3)Roller arm failures/Liner replacement 2805.00 3.00 2794.5 13.5 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Time between events | 2,795 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
Overall/Mixed failure modesShow verbatim quote (Table 3)Overall/Mixed failure modes 698.30 3.70 362.49 11.91 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Time between events | 362 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
Overall/Mixed failure modesShow verbatim quote (Table 3)Overall/Mixed failure modes 698.30 3.70 362.49 11.91 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Mean event duration | 11.9 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
Overall/Mixed failure modesShow verbatim quote (Table 3)Overall/Mixed failure modes 698.30 3.70 362.49 11.91 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Mean event duration | 3.70 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
Variable frequency drive failureVFD/inverterShow verbatim quote (Table 3)Variable frequency drive failure - - 2806.00 2.00 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Mean event duration | 2.00 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
Roller arm locker plate bolt/scrapper failureroller arm locker plate bolt / scrapperShow verbatim quote (Table 3)Roller arm locker plate bolt/scrapper failure 2807.21 0.79 699.70 2.30 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Mean event duration | 0.790 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
Roller arm failures/Liner replacementroller arm/linerShow verbatim quote (Table 3)Roller arm failures/Liner replacement 2805.00 3.00 2794.5 13.5 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Mean event duration | 13.5 Hr | Both extractors agreed |
Roller arm failures/Liner replacementroller arm/linerShow verbatim quote (Table 3)Roller arm failures/Liner replacement 2805.00 3.00 2794.5 13.5 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Time between events | 2,805 Hr | Single extractor |
Drive related failuresbelt drive / transmission shaftShow verbatim quote (Table 3)Drive related failures 1685.17 6.83 - - | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Mean event duration | 6.83 Hr | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 4)Energy consumption/kg 2.014kWh/kg 3.295kWh/kg | none | Specific energy | 3.30 kWh/kg | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 4)Throughput 7.18 kg/hour 4.14 kg/hour | none | Throughput | 4.14 kg/h | Single extractor |
roller arm failureroller armShow verbatim quote (Results and discussion)V1 had recorded one roller arm failure between 01/12/15 and 31/01/17, and had its grinding liner replaced 2 times in that period. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Number of events | 1.00 events | Single extractor |
grinding liner replacementlinerShow verbatim quote (Results and discussion)V1 had recorded one roller arm failure between 01/12/15 and 31/01/17, and had its grinding liner replaced 2 times in that period. | Setup and adjustments | Number of events | 2.00 events | Single extractor |
roller/scrapper failurescrapper / roller arm locker plateShow verbatim quote (Results and discussion)V1 had only recorded 2 failures from operating 351 days. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Number of events | 2.00 events | Single extractor |
roller/scrapper failurescrapper / roller arm locker plateShow verbatim quote (Results and discussion)These intermittent stoppages caused by such failure had accumulated 1.58, and 18.41 hour of stoppage time for V1 and V4 respectively. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 1.58 Hr | Single extractor |
belt failure, transmission shaft failure, minor belt cover damagebelt drive / transmission shaftShow verbatim quote (Results and discussion)The belt driven V1 has experienced belt failure, transmission shaft failure, and minor belt cover damage, resulting in a total stoppage of 20.5 hours. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 20.5 hours | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 1)Total from 12/01/16 till 01/31/17 16.75 12.83 29.58 | Not classifiable from the report | Lost time | 29.6 Hr | Single extractor |
Roller arm locker plate bolt/scrapper failureroller arm locker plate bolt / scrapperShow verbatim quote (Table 3)Roller arm locker plate bolt/scrapper failure 2807.21 0.79 699.70 2.30 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Time between events | 700 Hr | Single extractor |
Roller arm locker plate bolt/scrapper failureroller arm locker plate bolt / scrapperShow verbatim quote (Table 3)Roller arm locker plate bolt/scrapper failure 2807.21 0.79 699.70 2.30 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Mean event duration | 2.30 Hr | Single extractor |
grinding liner replacementlinerShow verbatim quote (Results and discussion)V4 had recorded two roller arm associated failures and, had its liner replaced 3 times in 61 weeks. | Setup and adjustments | Number of events | 3.00 events | Single extractor |
roller/scrapper failurescrapper / roller arm locker plateShow verbatim quote (Results and discussion)During the same period, V4 had encountered the same failure 5 times extra, totalling a 7 failure. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Number of events | 7.00 events | Single extractor |
roller/scrapper failurescrapper / roller arm locker plateShow verbatim quote (Results and discussion)These intermittent stoppages caused by such failure had accumulated 1.58, and 18.41 hour of stoppage time for V1 and V4 respectively. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 18.4 Hr | Single extractor |
locker plate bolt damageroller arm locker plate boltShow verbatim quote (Results and discussion)43.75% of failure in V4 mill is caused by locker plate bolt damage, the higher rate of such failure is due to the type of drive employed in V4 mill. | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Share of loss events | 43.8 % | Single extractor |
V4: R49 Locker plate bolt brokenroller arm (R49) locker plate boltShow verbatim quote (Table 2)02/19/16 015158 V4: R49 Locker plate bolt broken CMU 0 0.33 0.33 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 0.330 Hr | Single extractor |
V4: Roller arm (R49) locker plate bolt brokenroller arm (R49)Show verbatim quote (Table 2)03/09/16 015231 V4: Roller arm (R49) locker plate bolt broken CMU 0 0.5 0.5 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 0.500 Hr | Single extractor |
V4: Roller arm (R49) locker plate bolt brokenroller arm (R49)Show verbatim quote (Table 2)03/29/16 015448 V4: Roller arm (R49) locker plate bolt broken CMU 0 1 1 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 1.00 Hr | Single extractor |
V4: R49 locker plate holding bolts loosenroller arm (R49) locker plate boltShow verbatim quote (Table 2)04/06/16 015496 V4: R49 locker plate holding bolts loosen CMU 0 0.33 0.33 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 0.330 Hr | Single extractor |
V4: Roller arm and liner changeroller arm/linerShow verbatim quote (Table 2)05/07/16 015728 V4: Roller arm and liner change CMP 0 5 5 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 5.00 Hr | Single extractor |
V4: Inverter 75kW (S/N 000001) error OC1inverter/VFDShow verbatim quote (Table 2)06/25/16 016132 V4: Inverter 75kW (S/N 000001) error OC1 CMU 0 3 3 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 3.00 Hr | Single extractor |
V4: Roller arm locker plate bolt broken/stopper brokenroller arm locker plate bolt / stopperShow verbatim quote (Table 2)07/01/16 016185 V4: Roller arm locker plate bolt broken/stopper broken CMU 0 5 5 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 5.00 Hr | Single extractor |
V4: MGB2 Gearbox MaintenancegearboxShow verbatim quote (Table 2)08/20/16 008880 V4: MGB2 Gearbox Maintenance PM 0 2.25 2.25 | Planned downtime (scheduled maintenance, breaks, no demand) | Lost time | 2.25 Hr | Single extractor |
V4: Mill motor (M211) short circuitmill motorShow verbatim quote (Table 2)08/24/16 016602 V4: Mill motor (M211) short circuit CMU 0 5 5 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 5.00 Hr | Single extractor |
V4: Mill inverter fan blower probleminverter fan blowerShow verbatim quote (Table 2)08/29/16 016602-01 V4: Mill inverter fan blower problem CMU 0 1 1 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 1.00 Hr | Single extractor |
V4: M109 high amps/Changemotor M109Show verbatim quote (Table 2)09/17/16 016791 V4: M109 high amps/Change CMP 0 3 3 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 3.00 Hr | Single extractor |
V4: Center shaft service/Roller arm & liner changecentre shaft / roller arm / linerShow verbatim quote (Table 2)10/13/16 016972 V4: Center shaft service/Roller arm & liner change CMU 16 6 22 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 22.0 Hr | Single extractor |
V4: Inverter (DR-14) serviceinverter DR-14Show verbatim quote (Table 2)10/14/16 016694 V4: Inverter (DR-14) service PM 0 1 1 | Planned downtime (scheduled maintenance, breaks, no demand) | Lost time | 1.00 Hr | Single extractor |
V4: Roller came loose from arm/Abnormal noiseroller / roller armShow verbatim quote (Table 2)01/04/17 017546 V4: Roller came loose from arm/Abnormal noise CMU 0 2.25 2.25 | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Lost time | 2.25 Hr | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 2)Total from 12/01/15 till 01/31/17 128 53.91 181.91 | Not classifiable from the report | Lost time | 182 Hr | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 4, V4 row)Energy consumption/day | 231.36 kWh/day | none | Specific energy | 231 kWh/day | Single extractor |
Observation units
- V4 (gearbox-driven vertical roller mill) · Milling and grinding · Baseline
- V1 (belt-driven vertical roller mill) · Milling and grinding · Baseline
- V4 · Milling and grinding · Baseline

