1Bibliographic record
- Authors
- Ruly Sumargo, Amelia Makmur
- Year
- 2023
- Venue
- SinkrOn
- Country
- —
- Segment
- Food manufacturing (unspecified or mixed)
- Process family
- Filling and packaging line
- Study type
- Before/after intervention
- Extraction scope
- Full text
- Size
- 1 plants · 1 lines · 15 machines
- Observation period
- 365 days
- Data collection
- automatic_monitoring
- Intervention
Show the setting as described by the study
Current OEE system were assign to handled 15 packaging machines as shown by Figure 6 above.
2Risk of bias
Scored with the rubric of the protocol: 2 low concern, 1 some concerns, 0 high concern.
Total score 13Low risk
| Item | Score |
|---|---|
| Is the observed line, machine or plant described well enough to classify its segment, process and equipment?Product or sector is given but the equipment or process is only partly described. | 1 / 2 |
| Is the observation period long enough and reported?Period reported and at least 30 days of production (or at least 100 recorded events). | 2 / 2 |
| How were loss data collected?Automatic line monitoring, or systematic logs covering every stop in the period. | 2 / 2 |
| Are OEE, loading time and the loss categories defined explicitly?Formulae or definitions are given for the reported metrics, including what counts as planned time. | 2 / 2 |
| Does the loss breakdown account for the total loss it claims to explain?The reported causes or categories sum to at least 90% of the stated total, or an explicit "other" class closes the balance. | 2 / 2 |
| Is there evidence of selective reporting of favourable results?Intervention study in which baseline and post-intervention periods differ in length or method. | 1 / 2 |
| Are the reported numbers internally consistent?Recomputed totals, shares and OEE factors agree with the reported values within 2 percentage points. | 2 / 2 |
| Could conflicts of interest or the source of the data bias the result?Authors are employees of the plant or of an equipment/software vendor; no declaration. | 1 / 2 |
3Extracted data
Each datum with its classification and the verbatim quote that states it.
| Reported cause | Loss category | Metric | Value | Extraction |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Untrained operator not able to run at nominal speedShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Untrained operator not able to run at nominal speed 3.17% 4.82% 3.14% | Reduced speed | Share of lost time | 3.17 % | Both extractors agreed |
Product out of spec at process start of runShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Product out of spec at process start of run 44.24% 46.10% 44.58% | Start-up losses (reduced yield) | Share of lost time | 44.2 % | Both extractors agreed |
Damage product after maintenance activityShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Damage product after maintenance activity 6.03% 6.29% 5.97% | Start-up losses (reduced yield) | Share of lost time | 6.03 % | Both extractors agreed |
Running lower than nominal speedShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Running lower than nominal speed 8.99% 8.77% 13.44% | Reduced speed | Share of lost time | 8.99 % | Both extractors agreed |
Major component failure/Cutting Blade ChangeShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Major component failure/ Cutting Blade Change 0.79% 0.77% 0.71% | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Share of lost time | 0.790 % | Both extractors agreed |
Fallen product and CleaningShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Fallen product and Cleaning 7.94% 10.09% 31.47% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 7.94 % | Both extractors agreed |
Blockages/Process FailureShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Blockages/Process Failure 67.46% 63.60% 25.76% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 67.5 % | Both extractors agreed |
Labor shortage/Break TimeShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Labor shortage/Break Time 36.74% 36.85% 37.87% | Organizational or external stops (material or personnel shortage, utilities outage) | Share of lost time | 36.7 % | Adjudicated |
Untrained operator not able to run at nominal speedShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Untrained operator not able to run at nominal speed 3.17% 4.82% 3.14% | Reduced speed | Share of lost time | 3.14 % | Both extractors agreed |
Measurement AdjustmentShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Measurement Adjustment 2.19% 2.15% 1.49% | Setup and adjustments | Share of lost time | 2.19 % | Both extractors agreed |
Material availabilityShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Material availability 10.12% 12.16% 3.19% | Organizational or external stops (material or personnel shortage, utilities outage) | Share of lost time | 10.1 % | Adjudicated |
Product out of specShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Product out of spec 44.24% 41.90% 44.17% | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Share of lost time | 44.2 % | Both extractors agreed |
Planned maintenanceShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Planned maintenance 35.09% 34.48% 39.78% | Planned downtime (scheduled maintenance, breaks, no demand) | Share of lost time | 35.1 % | Adjudicated |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 3)Availability (%) 71.49% 56.47% 74.85% | none | Availability | 71.5 % | Both extractors agreed |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 3)Performance (%) 91.52% 90.29% 98.09% | none | Performance | 91.5 % | Both extractors agreed |
Minor StoppageShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Minor Stoppage 6.08% 3.95% 11.65% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 6.08 % | Both extractors agreed |
Major component failure/Cutting Blade ChangeShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Major component failure/ Cutting Blade Change 0.79% 0.77% 0.71% | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Share of lost time | 0.710 % | Both extractors agreed |
Product out of spec at process start of runShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Product out of spec at process start of run 44.24% 46.10% 44.58% | Start-up losses (reduced yield) | Share of lost time | 44.6 % | Both extractors agreed |
MisalignmentShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Misalignment 6.35% 8.77% 14.56% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 6.35 % | Both extractors agreed |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 3)Quality (%) 98.91% 98.95% 99.11% | none | Quality | 98.9 % | Both extractors agreed |
ChangeoverShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Changeover 14.62% 12.65% 16.58% | Setup and adjustments | Share of lost time | 14.6 % | Both extractors agreed |
BreakdownShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Breakdown 0.45% 0.94% 0.38% | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Share of lost time | 0.450 % | Both extractors agreed |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 3)OEE (%) 64.71% 50.45% 72.77% | none | OEE | 64.7 % | Both extractors agreed |
ScrapShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Scrap 5.48% 5.71% 5.28% | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Share of lost time | 5.48 % | Both extractors agreed |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 4)Accumulated time losses > 1 hour 9.02% 3.40% 4.22% | Not classifiable from the report | Share of lost time | 9.02 % | Both extractors agreed |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 4)Accumulated time losses > 1 hour 9.02% 3.40% 4.22% | Not classifiable from the report | Share of lost time | 4.22 % | Both extractors agreed |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 3)Availability (%) 71.49% 56.47% 74.85% | none | Availability | 74.9 % | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 3)Performance (%) 91.52% 90.29% 98.09% | none | Performance | 98.1 % | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 3)Quality (%) 98.91% 98.95% 99.11% | none | Quality | 99.1 % | Single extractor |
—Show verbatim quote (Table 3)OEE (%) 64.71% 50.45% 72.77% | none | OEE | 72.8 % | Single extractor |
BreakdownShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Breakdown 0.45% 0.94% 0.38% | Equipment failure (breakdowns) | Share of lost time | 0.380 % | Single extractor |
Planned maintenanceShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Planned maintenance 35.09% 34.48% 39.78% | Setup and adjustments | Share of lost time | 39.8 % | Single extractor |
Material availabilityShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Material availability 10.12% 12.16% 3.19% | Setup and adjustments | Share of lost time | 3.19 % | Single extractor |
Labor shortage/Break TimeShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Labor shortage/Break Time 36.74% 36.85% 37.87% | Setup and adjustments | Share of lost time | 37.9 % | Single extractor |
ChangeoverShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Changeover 14.62% 12.65% 16.58% | Setup and adjustments | Share of lost time | 16.6 % | Single extractor |
Measurement AdjustmentShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Measurement Adjustment 2.19% 2.15% 1.49% | Setup and adjustments | Share of lost time | 1.49 % | Single extractor |
Fallen product and CleaningShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Fallen product and Cleaning 7.94% 10.09% 31.47% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 31.5 % | Single extractor |
Blockages/Process FailureShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Blockages/Process Failure 67.46% 63.60% 25.76% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 25.8 % | Single extractor |
MisalignmentShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Misalignment 6.35% 8.77% 14.56% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 14.6 % | Single extractor |
Minor StoppageShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Minor Stoppage 6.08% 3.95% 11.65% | Idling and minor stops (micro-stops) | Share of lost time | 11.7 % | Single extractor |
Running lower than nominal speedShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Running lower than nominal speed 8.99% 8.77% 13.44% | Reduced speed | Share of lost time | 13.4 % | Single extractor |
Product out of specShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Product out of spec 44.24% 41.90% 44.17% | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Share of lost time | 44.2 % | Single extractor |
ScrapShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Scrap 5.48% 5.71% 5.28% | Process defects (scrap and rework) | Share of lost time | 5.28 % | Single extractor |
Damage product after maintenance activityShow verbatim quote (Table 4)Damage product after maintenance activity 6.03% 6.29% 5.97% | Start-up losses (reduced yield) | Share of lost time | 5.97 % | Single extractor |
Observation units
- Food packaging line (average of 15 packaging machines) · Packaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing) · Baseline
- Food packaging line (average of 15 packaging machines) · Packaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing) · After intervention

