foratvise
Get Started
Milling, extraction and separation

Milling and grinding

Roller milling of wheat to white flour (size reduction and endosperm separation)

Validated modelOEE bound 0.964 [0.937–0.975]20,000 Monte Carlo samples · seed 20261115 · computed November 16, 2026

In short

Milling and grinding can use at most 96 of every 100 planned hours. The rest goes to limits no plant can avoid.

  1. 96usable at most
  2. 4are a physical limit

The three limits that set it

Running time: up to 97 %

The rest are stops imposed by physics or by regulation: cleaning, changeovers, defrosting.

Speed: up to 100 %

How close to its maximum speed it can run without damaging the product or the equipment.

Good product: up to 100 %

Some product falls outside specification even with the process well under control.

See the technical detail

Technical detail

Uncertainty intervals, physical models per station and sources, for anyone who wants to check each figure.

1Scenario

Cleaned and tempered common wheat is opened by corrugated break rolls, the endosperm is scraped from the bran, purified by sieving and air classification and reduced to flour on smooth reduction rolls. The product is white flour that must meet the Codex moisture limit and pass the 212 µm sieve; bran and germ leave as mill feed. Hammer milling of whole grain for animal feed is the noted variant: there is no separation (yield 1) and the same comminution laws apply to the whole kernel.

Provenance of inputsDeclared assumption15Verified quote15

2Results

Point value from the nominal parameters and 95% interval from 20,000 Monte Carlo draws of the uncertain parameters.
  • New specific surface created from kernel to flour67.2 [50.2–133.6] m²/kg
  • TheoreticalThermodynamic minimum: surface free energy of the new surface0.00437 [0.00263–0.01094] kJ/kg
  • Best available techniqueGrinding energy to flour at the best documented roller-mill energy per unit new surface (hard wheat)73.9 [55.2–146.9] kJ/kg
  • Best documentedGrinding energy to flour at the documented first-break energy per unit new surface (hard red winter wheat)92.1 [68.6–183.6] kJ/kg
  • Rittinger's law calibrated on first break, extrapolated to flour81.2 [60.6–161.4] kJ/kg
  • Kick's law calibrated on first break, extrapolated to flour32.0 [29.4–39.6] kJ/kg
  • Bond's law calibrated on first break, extrapolated to flour47.8 [40.3–72.6] kJ/kg
  • Equivalent Bond work index of wheat from the first-break measurement12.3 [12.2–16.0] kWh/tonne
  • Thermodynamic minimum divided by the documented grinding energy4.74 × 10⁻⁵ [3.02 × 10⁻⁵–7.23 × 10⁻⁵]
  • First-break throughput per metre of roll length at the declared fill factor and roll speeds (nip capacity; a scenario value, no ceiling)3.01 [1.36–4.72] tonne/h/m
  • TheoreticalMinimum time a kernel spends in the nip (contact arc / mean roll speed)3.56 [3.14–5.89] ms
  • TheoreticalMaximum flour extraction (endosperm share of the kernel)0.830 [0.811–0.850]
  • Best documentedDocumented flour extraction of roller mills (upper value)0.740
  • TypicalDocumented flour extraction of roller mills (lower value)0.720
  • Flour moisture set point (legal limit minus the control margin)14.6 [13.9–15.0] %
  • Share of flour above the Codex moisture limit0.00135 [0.00025–0.00577]
  • TheoreticalMaximum OEE quality factor (moisture capability)0.9987 [0.9942–0.9997]
  • TheoreticalPerformance factor at the nip-capacity rate1.00
  • TheoreticalMaximum availability (sanitation, insect control and roll exchange)0.965 [0.939–0.976]
  • TheoreticalPhysics-bounded OEE0.964 [0.937–0.975]

3Ceilings per dimension

Each dimension shows the ceilings the model computes and, where units are comparable, documented benchmarks. Colour and marker shape identify the ceiling type throughout the Oracle.
  • Theoretical
  • Best available technique
  • Best documented
  • Typical
Energy per unit of productkJ/kg · lower is better
  • TheoreticalDOE bandwidth study: most food products have a zero thermodynamic minimum (no significant chemical reaction); comminution adds only the surface energy · Benchmark0 kJ/kg
  • TheoreticalThermodynamic minimum: surface free energy of the new surface0.00437 [0.00263–0.01094] kJ/kg
  • Best available techniqueGrinding energy to flour at the best documented roller-mill energy per unit new surface (hard wheat)73.9 [55.2–146.9] kJ/kg
  • Best documentedGrinding energy to flour at the documented first-break energy per unit new surface (hard red winter wheat)92.1 [68.6–183.6] kJ/kg
Cycle or residence timems · lower is better
  • TheoreticalMinimum time a kernel spends in the nip (contact arc / mean roll speed)3.56 [3.14–5.89] ms
Yieldhigher is better
  • TheoreticalMaximum flour extraction (endosperm share of the kernel)0.830 [0.811–0.850]
  • Best documentedDocumented flour extraction of roller mills (upper value)0.740
  • TypicalDocumented flour extraction of roller mills (lower value)0.720
Qualityhigher is better
  • TheoreticalMaximum OEE quality factor (moisture capability)0.9987 [0.9942–0.9997]
Performancehigher is better
  • TheoreticalPerformance factor at the nip-capacity rate1.00
Availabilityhigher is better
  • TheoreticalMaximum availability (sanitation, insect control and roll exchange)0.965 [0.939–0.976]
OEEhigher is better
  • TheoreticalPhysics-bounded OEE0.964 [0.937–0.975]

4Loss cascade

What separates each ceiling from the next one, from the physical limit to typical operation.
  1. TheoreticalBest available techniqueEnergy per unit of product
    0.00437 [0.00263–0.01094] kJ/kg → 73.9 [55.2–146.9] kJ/kg (gap 73.9 kJ/kg)

    The thermodynamic minimum is the free energy of the new surface, gamma times the new area: a few joules per kilogram. Roller grinding of hard wheat needs about 1.1 kJ per square metre of new surface, more than ten thousand times more. Almost all of that work is dissipated: elastic and plastic deformation of the whole kernel before it breaks, crack propagation that is not reversible (fracture energy is much larger than surface energy in visco-plastic starch–protein solids), friction between particles and against the corrugations, and the kinetic energy of the fragments, all ending as heat in the stock and the rolls.

  2. Best available techniqueBest documentedEnergy per unit of product
    73.9 [55.2–146.9] kJ/kg → 92.1 [68.6–183.6] kJ/kg (gap 18.2 kJ/kg)

    The documented first-break value for hard red winter wheat (1.37 kJ/m2) is higher than the best of the hard-wheat region because kernel hardness, size and mass spread widen the energy needed per unit area; repeated passes (up to five breaks and twelve reductions) re-grind particles that were already fine enough. The BAT indicative levels for whole mills (0.05–0.13 MWh/t) add the conveying, pneumatic transport, sifting, purifying and aspiration energy, which is several times the grinding energy itself.

  3. TheoreticalBest documentedYield
    0.830 [0.811–0.850] → 0.740 (gap 0.0900)

    The endosperm is 83 % of the kernel, but roller mills extract 72–74 % white flour. The gap is endosperm that stays attached to bran flakes and to the germ, and the fine bran that cannot be practically separated from the last endosperm stream: recovering it would raise the ash and colour of the flour above the specification. It is a separation-selectivity limit (adhesion of the aleurone to the endosperm), not a mass loss: it leaves as mill feed.

  4. Best documentedTypicalYield
    0.740 → 0.720 (gap 0.0200)

    Older or less purified mills, harder-to-separate wheat lots and tighter ash targets reduce the extraction to the lower documented value.

5Physics-bounded OEE

The highest OEE the operation can reach: availability, performance and quality limited only by unavoidable stops and physical capability.
Fraction of loading time that remains after each unavoidable loss. Axis starts at 0.90.
  • Loading time (ideal)
    1.000
  • Availability
    factor 0.965 [0.939–0.976]
    0.965 (−0.035)
  • Performance
    factor 1.00
    0.965 (−0.000)
  • Quality
    factor 0.9987 [0.9942–0.9997]
    0.964 (−0.001)
  • Physics-bounded OEE
    0.964 [0.937–0.975]

6Full derivation

Mass and energy balances, rate-limiting step, process capability and unavoidable stops, with every term explained.

Scope. Cleaned and tempered common wheat is opened on corrugated break rolls, the endosperm is scraped from the bran, purified by sieving and air classification and reduced to flour on smooth reduction rolls (up to five breaks and twelve reductions). The product is white flour that must meet the Codex moisture limit (15.5 % m/m) and pass the 212 µm sieve. Hammer milling of whole grain for feed is the noted variant: there is no separation, so its yield ceiling is 1 and only the comminution part of this model applies. Symbols and their values, units, uncertainty distributions and sources are listed in the parameter table generated from config/physics/milling.yaml.

1. Mass balance — maximum yield

Milling neither creates nor destroys mass; it separates the kernel into streams. On an equal-moisture basis the balance over the mill is

m˙wheat=m˙flour+m˙bran+m˙germ+m˙loss,\dot m_{wheat} = \dot m_{flour} + \dot m_{bran} + \dot m_{germ} + \dot m_{loss},

where m˙loss\dot m_{loss} (dust leaving the filters, spillage) is small and not physical in origin. White flour is, by definition, comminuted endosperm with the bran and germ removed. The wheat kernel consists of seed coat (bran), aleurone layer, endosperm and germ, and the endosperm is fendf_{end} = 83 % of its mass. A perfect separator would deliver every gram of endosperm and nothing else, so the physical ceiling of the extraction rate is

Ymax=fend.Y_{max} = f_{end}.
  • fendf_{end} — mass fraction of endosperm in the kernel. A declared spread (sd 0.01) represents varietal differences.
  • YmaxY_{max} — the largest possible ratio of white flour to wheat milled.

The basis matters: tempering adds water to the wheat and flour leaves the mill at a different moisture than the by-products; both are ignored by expressing every stream at the same moisture. Commercial roller mills extract 72–74 % flour. The 9–11 point gap is endosperm that stays attached to bran flakes and germ, and fine bran that cannot be separated from the last endosperm streams without raising the ash and colour of the flour above specification. It is a limit of separation selectivity — the aleurone adheres to the outer endosperm — and the material is not lost: it leaves as mill feed.

2. Energy balance — minimum energy per unit of product

What changes. Grinding is a mechanical operation without chemical reaction. The only state change of the material is the creation of new surface. The free energy of a solid rises by γ\gamma per unit of new surface, so the reversible work of size reduction is

wmin=γ ΔA.w_{min} = \gamma\,\Delta A .
  • γ\gamma — surface free energy of the solid (J/m²). The endosperm is starch granules in a protein matrix; the value used is the surface free energy measured on starch-based films (about 65 mJ/m²), with a declared range of 40–100 mJ/m² because the endosperm is not a film.
  • ΔA\Delta A — new surface per kilogram of wheat (m²/kg).

The US DOE bandwidth study assigns a zero thermodynamic minimum to most food products because no significant chemical reaction takes place; the surface term is the only correction, and it is tiny.

New surface. For particles of surface-equivalent (Sauter) diameter dd and particle density ρp\rho_p, the specific surface of equal-volume spheres is 6/(ρpd)6/(\rho_p d); real fragments have more surface, by a shape factor ψ≥1\psi \ge 1. From kernels of diameter dkd_k to flour of mean diameter dfd_f,

ΔA=6 ψρp(1df−1dk).\Delta A = \frac{6\,\psi}{\rho_p}\left(\frac{1}{d_f} - \frac{1}{d_k}\right).
  • dkd_k — single-kernel diameter of tempered wheat (2.3–3.0 mm).
  • dfd_f — Sauter mean diameter of the flour, a declared 40–90 µm, consistent with 98 % passing 212 µm.
  • ρp\rho_p — true density of endosperm (declared 1380–1500 kg/m³).
  • ψ\psi — shape factor; 1 (spheres) gives the smallest area and therefore the most favourable minimum.

With the point values, ΔA≈67\Delta A \approx 67 m²/kg and wmin≈0.004w_{min} \approx 0.004 kJ/kg (about 1 Wh per tonne).

The comminution laws. The classical laws describe how much work real machines need:

  • Rittinger (1867): work is proportional to the new surface, E=CR ΔAE = C_R\,\Delta A. The constant CRC_R is the energy per unit of new surface (kJ/m²), measured directly on wheat as the ratio of the energy per unit mass to the new specific surface.
  • Kick (1885): work depends only on the size-reduction ratio, E=Kln⁡(dk/d)E = K \ln(d_k/d), as if every geometrically similar reduction step cost the same.
  • Bond (1952): work is proportional to the change in the inverse square root of size, E=10 Wi (1/P−1/F)E = 10\,W_i\,(1/\sqrt{P} - 1/\sqrt{F}) with sizes in µm and the work index WiW_i in kWh/t.

None of the three has a DOI (they are a textbook, a monograph and a conference transaction); they are cited through the open first-break study used below. Wheat does not follow any single law over the whole range — it is a visco-plastic biological material — so all three are calibrated on the same measurement: first-break grinding of 100 wheat samples, energy per unit mass EM,1BE_{M,1B} = 20.6 kJ/kg and new specific surface ANSS=e5.139A_{NSS} = e^{5.139} cm²/g ≈ 17 m²/kg. The surface-equivalent size after first break is

d1B=6ψρp (ANSS+6ψ/(ρpdk)),d_{1B} = \frac{6\psi}{\rho_p\,(A_{NSS} + 6\psi/(\rho_p d_k))},

and the constants are CR=EM,1B/ANSSC_R = E_{M,1B}/A_{NSS}, K=EM,1B/ln⁡(dk/d1B)K = E_{M,1B}/\ln(d_k/d_{1B}) and Wi=EM,1B/[10 (1/d1B−1/dk)]W_i = E_{M,1B}/[10\,(1/\sqrt{d_{1B}} - 1/\sqrt{d_k})] (equivalent Bond index about 12 kWh/t). Extrapolated to flour, Kick gives about 32 kJ/kg, Bond about 48 kJ/kg and Rittinger about 81 kJ/kg: for fine grinding, where almost all the work is spent on new surface, Rittinger's law is the physically consistent one, and the other two underestimate.

Ratio to practice. The documented energy per unit of new surface for hard red winter wheat is CR,docC_{R,doc} = 1.37 kJ/m², and the best of the hard-wheat region is CR,BATC_{R,BAT} = 1.1 kJ/m². Divided by γ≈0.065\gamma \approx 0.065 J/m², grinding uses some 17 000–21 000 times the thermodynamic minimum: the surface-energy efficiency wmin/Edocw_{min}/E_{doc} is about 5×10−55\times10^{-5}. Where the rest goes: elastic and plastic deformation of the whole kernel before fracture; irreversible crack propagation, whose fracture energy in starch–protein solids is orders of magnitude above the surface energy; friction between particles and against the roll corrugations; and the kinetic energy of the fragments. All of it ends as heat in the stock and the rolls.

The energy ceilings. Theoretical: γ ΔA\gamma\,\Delta A. Best available technique: CR,BAT ΔAC_{R,BAT}\,\Delta A ≈ 74 kJ/kg (roller mills consume the least energy among grinder types). Documented: CR,doc ΔAC_{R,doc}\,\Delta A ≈ 92 kJ/kg. The BAT indicative levels for whole grain mills, 0.05–0.13 MWh per tonne of products (180–470 kJ/kg), have a wider boundary: they add pneumatic conveying, sifting, purifying, aspiration and lighting, and are shown as benchmarks.

3. Rate-limiting step — minimum time and maximum throughput

The stand that receives the whole kernel stream is the first break. Kernels larger than the gap are drawn into the nip and crushed; downstream of the nip the stream occupies at most the gap. Continuity at the gap gives the maximum mass flow per metre of roll length:

m˙maxLroll=ρb ϕ g vˉ,vˉ=vf2(1+1Dr).\frac{\dot m_{max}}{L_{roll}} = \rho_b\,\phi\,g\,\bar v, \qquad \bar v = \frac{v_f}{2}\left(1 + \frac{1}{D_r}\right).
  • ρb\rho_b — bulk density of the tempered wheat (declared 740–820 kg/m³).
  • ϕ\phi — fraction of the gap cross-section filled by the stream (declared 0.3–0.7): a single layer of kernels cannot fill the gap completely.
  • gg — roll gap (0.38–0.63 mm, from the gaps used in the first-break study).
  • vˉ\bar v — mean speed of the two roll surfaces; vfv_f is the fast-roll peripheral speed and DrD_r the speed differential.

With the point values the nip capacity is about 3 t/h per metre of roll. The minimum time a kernel spends being broken is the time to cross the contact arc, from first contact (where the roll separation equals the kernel diameter) to the gap:

tnip=R (dk−g)vˉ,t_{nip} = \frac{\sqrt{R\,(d_k - g)}}{\bar v},

with RR the roll radius — a few milliseconds. Breakage kinetics are therefore not limiting; the throughput limit is volumetric. Because the nip capacity follows from the declared fill factor (0.3–0.7) and roll speeds, it is a scenario value passed through a formula, not a physical upper bound, and it is reported without a ceiling label. A mill running at this nip capacity has an OEE performance factor of 1.

4. Process capability — quality ceiling

Granularity is guaranteed by the sieves: particles above size return to the rolls, so it is not a quality loss. The binding specification is moisture: at most wmaxw_{max} = 15.5 % m/m. Flour moisture under control is modelled as normal with standard deviation σw\sigma_w around a set point zwz_w standard deviations below the limit,

wset=wmax−zw σw,dw=Φ(−zw),Qmax=1−dw.w_{set} = w_{max} - z_w\,\sigma_w, \qquad d_w = \Phi(-z_w), \qquad Q_{max} = 1 - d_w .
  • Φ\Phi — standard normal cumulative distribution function.
  • dwd_w — share of flour above the limit (re-blended or downgraded).

The margin is an economic choice: every tenth of a point of moisture below the limit is water not sold with the flour.

5. Unavoidable stops — maximum availability

Three stops are physically unavoidable in a continuously running mill: weekly dry cleaning and sanitation tsant_{san} (flour dust in rolls, sifters and spouts is an infestation and explosion hazard), yearly insect control by gas or heat treatment tfumt_{fum}, and exchange of worn rolls trollt_{roll} (corrugations wear and must be re-fluted; smooth rolls are reground; spare rolls limit the stop to the exchange). All three durations are declared scenarios; the mill is cleaned dry, not in place, so the cleaning model does not apply:

Amax=1−tsan168 h−tfum+troll8760 h.A_{max} = 1 - \frac{t_{san}}{168\ \text{h}} - \frac{t_{fum} + t_{roll}}{8760\ \text{h}} .

6. Physics-bounded OEE

Scope of the bound. The theoretical label of OEEmaxOEE_{max} means physics-bounded under the declared scenario: the ceiling follows from the physics of the operation for the declared product, equipment and schedule, and it is a bound only conditional on those declarations. It follows the common definition of all models: AmaxA_{max} counts only stops required by regulation or forced by a physical mechanism, at their physical minimum duration, plus the start-up they force; PmaxP_{max} is the ratio of the physics-limited ideal cycle to the cycle of the capable process; QmaxQ_{max} is the share of conforming units, and mass losses of conforming product are reported only as yield.

OEEmax=Amax×Pmax×Qmax,Pmax=1.OEE_{max} = A_{max} \times P_{max} \times Q_{max}, \qquad P_{max} = 1 .

The extraction gap of Section 1 is not part of the OEE: bran and germ are by-products by design, not defective flour. The result, with the Monte Carlo interval over the declared uncertainty of every input, is reported in the output table.

7. Assumptions and validity

See the assumption and validity lists generated from the configuration file. The new surface (flour fineness, shape factor and particle density) dominates every energy output; the weekly sanitation stop dominates availability.

References

  • Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. WHEAT: Post-harvest Operations (Post-harvest Compendium), U. K. Baloch, 1999.
  • Codex Alimentarius Commission. Codex Standard for Wheat Flour, CODEX STAN 152-1985, revision 1995.
  • Pasikatan, M. C., Milliken, G. A., Steele, J. L., Haque, E., Spillman, C. K. (2001). Modeling the energy requirements of first-break grinding. Transactions of the ASAE, 44(6), 1737–1744. doi:10.13031/2013.6986
  • European Commission, Joint Research Centre. Best Available Techniques (BAT) Reference Document for the Food, Drink and Milk Industries, 2019.
  • U.S. Department of Energy. Bandwidth Study on Energy Use and Potential Energy Savings Opportunities in U.S. Food and Beverage Manufacturing, 2017.
  • Starch-based functional films enhanced with bacterial nanocellulose for smart packaging (2024). Polymers, 16(16), 2259. doi:10.3390/polym16162259
  • Classical comminution laws, as cited by Pasikatan et al. (2001), no DOI: von Rittinger (1867), Textbook of Mineral Dressing, Berlin, Ernst and Korn; Kick (1885), Das Gesetz der proportionalen Widerstände und seine Anwendungen, Leipzig, Arthur Felix; Bond, F. C. (1952), The third theory of comminution, Transactions of the AIME, 193(2), 484.

7Parameters and provenance

Every input with its value, unit, role, uncertainty distribution and provenance. Open a quote to read the passage of the source that states the value.
  • fendf_{end}0.83

    Mass fraction of the endosperm in the wheat kernel

    Property · Normal, sd 0.01

    Verified quote
    Show verbatim quote
    Endosperm: 83 percentageWHEAT: Post-harvest Operations (Post-harvest Compendium) (opens in a new tab). Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (AGSI/FAO); author U. K. Baloch, Pakistan Agricultural Research Council, 1999. p. 6. FAO INPhO Post-harvest Compendium, chapter WHEAT (last reviewed 14/10/1999)
  • YdocY_{doc}0.74

    Flour extraction rate of roller mills, upper documented value

    Benchmark · Fixed

    Verified quote
    Show verbatim quote
    The milling process yields generally 72 to 74 percentage flour.WHEAT: Post-harvest Operations (Post-harvest Compendium) (opens in a new tab). Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (AGSI/FAO); author U. K. Baloch, Pakistan Agricultural Research Council, 1999. p. 6. FAO INPhO Post-harvest Compendium, chapter WHEAT (last reviewed 14/10/1999)
  • YtypY_{typ}0.72

    Flour extraction rate of roller mills, lower documented value

    Benchmark · Fixed

    Verified quote
    Show verbatim quote
    The milling process yields generally 72 to 74 percentage flour.WHEAT: Post-harvest Operations (Post-harvest Compendium) (opens in a new tab). Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (AGSI/FAO); author U. K. Baloch, Pakistan Agricultural Research Council, 1999. p. 6. FAO INPhO Post-harvest Compendium, chapter WHEAT (last reviewed 14/10/1999)
  • wmaxw_{max}15.5 %

    Maximum moisture content of wheat flour

    Regulatory · Fixed

    Verified quote
    Show verbatim quote
    Moisture content 15.5% m/m maxCodex Standard for Wheat Flour (CODEX STAN 152-1985, revision 1995) (opens in a new tab). Codex Alimentarius Commission (FAO/WHO), 1995. p. 1. CXS 152-1985
  • σw\sigma_w0.3 %

    Standard deviation of the flour moisture content under control (percentage points)

    Scenario · Uniform 0.15 to 0.5 %

    Declared assumption

    Process-capability assumption; replace with the measured value of the mill.

  • zwz_w3

    Moisture set-point margin below the legal limit, in standard deviations

    Scenario · Uniform 2.5 to 3.5

    Declared assumption

    Operating choice: a larger margin lowers the out-of-specification share but sells less water with the flour.

  • γ\gamma65 mJ/m²

    Surface free energy of a starch-based solid, used as the surface energy of the new endosperm surfaces

    Property · Uniform 40 to 100 mJ/m²

    Verified quote
    Show verbatim quote
    for MS-based films, the value was about 65 mJ/m 2 for all samples with BNCStarch-Based Functional Films Enhanced with Bacterial Nanocellulose for Smart Packaging: Physicochemical Properties, pH Sensitivity and Colorimetric Response (Polymers 16(16): 2259) (opens in a new tab). MDPI (open access, CC BY 4.0); full text served by Europe PMC, 2024. doi:10.3390/polym16162259; PMC11358998
  • ρp\rho_p1,450 kg/m³

    Particle (true) density of wheat endosperm

    Scenario · Uniform 1,380 to 1,500 kg/m³

    Declared assumption

    Declared assumption: density of a starch–protein solid; no open source with a verbatim value was found.

  • dkd_k2.3 mm

    Single-kernel diameter of tempered wheat

    Property · Triangular 2.3, 2.3, 3 mm

    Verified quote
    Show verbatim quote
    The wheat samples covered the HSK, SSK, and MSK ranges of 19.7–97.6 hardness index, 2.3–3.0 mm, and 27.8–43.5 mg, respectively.Modeling the energy requirements of first-break grinding (Pasikatan, Milliken, Steele, Haque, Spillman; Transactions of the ASAE 44(6): 1737-1744) (opens in a new tab). American Society of Agricultural Engineers; copy published by USDA Agricultural Research Service, 2001. p. 3. doi:10.13031/2013.6986
  • dfd_f60 um

    Surface-equivalent (Sauter) mean diameter of the flour

    Scenario · Uniform 40 to 90 um

    Declared assumption

    Declared assumption, consistent with the Codex granularity requirement that 98 % of the flour pass a 212 µm sieve.

  • ψ\psi1

    Ratio of the real specific surface of the particles to that of equal-volume spheres

    Scenario · Uniform 1 to 1.5

    Declared assumption

    Spheres have the least surface for a given volume, so 1.0 gives the smallest new area (the most favourable minimum); irregular fragments have more.

  • CR,BATC_{R,BAT}1.1 kJ/m²

    Energy per unit of new surface of roller grinding, lowest value of the hard-wheat region

    Benchmark · Fixed

    Verified quote
    Show verbatim quote
    the low EA region (about 0.3– 1.1 kJ/m2) for the soft wheats, the middle EA region (about 1.1–2.0 kJ/m2) for the hard wheatsModeling the energy requirements of first-break grinding (Pasikatan, Milliken, Steele, Haque, Spillman; Transactions of the ASAE 44(6): 1737-1744) (opens in a new tab). American Society of Agricultural Engineers; copy published by USDA Agricultural Research Service, 2001. p. 5. doi:10.13031/2013.6986
  • CR,docC_{R,doc}1.3709 kJ/m²

    Energy per unit of new surface of first-break grinding of hard red winter wheat (class intercept of the regression model)

    Benchmark · Normal, sd 0.0371 kJ/m²

    Verified quote
    Show verbatim quote
    Hard Red Winter 4.9483 a (0.0216) 4.9430 a (0.0215) 19.7995 bc (0.4345) 19.7266 a (0.4652) 1.3709 b (0.0371)Modeling the energy requirements of first-break grinding (Pasikatan, Milliken, Steele, Haque, Spillman; Transactions of the ASAE 44(6): 1737-1744) (opens in a new tab). American Society of Agricultural Engineers; copy published by USDA Agricultural Research Service, 2001. p. 4. doi:10.13031/2013.6986
  • EM,1BE_{M,1B}20.617 kJ/kg

    Measured energy per unit mass of first-break grinding (mean of 100 validation samples)

    Benchmark · Fixed

    Verified quote
    Show verbatim quote
    Measured values[a] 5.139 ±0.623 20.617 ±6.365 1.349 ±0.696Modeling the energy requirements of first-break grinding (Pasikatan, Milliken, Steele, Haque, Spillman; Transactions of the ASAE 44(6): 1737-1744) (opens in a new tab). American Society of Agricultural Engineers; copy published by USDA Agricultural Research Service, 2001. p. 6. doi:10.13031/2013.6986
  • ln⁡ANSS,1B\ln A_{NSS,1B}5.139

    Natural logarithm of the measured new specific surface after first break, with the surface in cm2/g (mean of 100 validation samples)

    Benchmark · Fixed

    Verified quote
    Show verbatim quote
    Measured values[a] 5.139 ±0.623 20.617 ±6.365 1.349 ±0.696Modeling the energy requirements of first-break grinding (Pasikatan, Milliken, Steele, Haque, Spillman; Transactions of the ASAE 44(6): 1737-1744) (opens in a new tab). American Society of Agricultural Engineers; copy published by USDA Agricultural Research Service, 2001. p. 6. doi:10.13031/2013.6986
  • gg0.51 mm

    First-break roll gap

    Technology · Uniform 0.38 to 0.63 mm

    Verified quote
    Show verbatim quote
    Wheat samples were ground using five roll gaps (0.38, 0.51, 0.63, 0.75 and 0.88 mm) set using a feeler gauge.Modeling the energy requirements of first-break grinding (Pasikatan, Milliken, Steele, Haque, Spillman; Transactions of the ASAE 44(6): 1737-1744) (opens in a new tab). American Society of Agricultural Engineers; copy published by USDA Agricultural Research Service, 2001. p. 3. doi:10.13031/2013.6986
  • vfv_f6 m/s

    Peripheral speed of the fast roll

    Scenario · Uniform 4 to 7 m/s

    Declared assumption

    Declared assumption for an industrial break roll stand.

  • DrD_r2.5

    Ratio of fast to slow roll speed (roll differential)

    Scenario · Uniform 2 to 3

    Declared assumption

    Declared assumption; the roll differential is a design setting of each stand.

  • DrollD_{roll}0.25 m

    Roll diameter

    Scenario · Uniform 0.22 to 0.3 m

    Declared assumption
  • ρb\rho_b780 kg/m³

    Bulk density of tempered wheat entering the nip

    Scenario · Uniform 740 to 820 kg/m³

    Declared assumption

    Declared assumption (test weight of sound wheat).

  • ϕ\phi0.5

    Fraction of the gap cross-section occupied by the stream at the nip

    Scenario · Uniform 0.3 to 0.7

    Declared assumption

    Declared assumption; it sets how much of the geometric nip capacity a monolayer of kernels can fill.

  • tsant_{san}4 h

    Weekly stop for dry cleaning and sanitation of the mill

    Scenario · Uniform 2 to 8 h

    Declared assumption
  • tfumt_{fum}48 h

    Yearly stop for insect control (gas or heat treatment)

    Scenario · Uniform 24 to 72 h

    Declared assumption
  • trollt_{roll}48 h

    Yearly mill stop for exchanging worn rolls for re-fluted or reground ones

    Scenario · Uniform 24 to 96 h

    Declared assumption

    Declared assumption, e.g. about 16 roll pairs exchanged once a year at about 3 h each.

8Benchmarks

Documented values from open sources used to check the ceilings; no documented value may beat the theoretical limit.
BenchmarkCeilingValueProvenance
BAT indicative specific energy of grain milling, lower end (whole mill: heat and electricity per tonne of products; larger boundary than grinding alone)
Show verbatim quote
MWh/tonne of products 0.05–0.13Best Available Techniques (BAT) Reference Document for the Food, Drink and Milk Industries (opens in a new tab). European Commission, Joint Research Centre; Publications Office of the European Union, 2019. p. 725. EUR 29978 EN; JRC118627; doi:10.2760/243911
Best available technique0.05 MWh/tonneVerified quote
BAT indicative specific energy of grain milling, upper end (whole mill)
Show verbatim quote
MWh/tonne of products 0.05–0.13Best Available Techniques (BAT) Reference Document for the Food, Drink and Milk Industries (opens in a new tab). European Commission, Joint Research Centre; Publications Office of the European Union, 2019. p. 725. EUR 29978 EN; JRC118627; doi:10.2760/243911
Best documented0.13 MWh/tonneVerified quote
DOE bandwidth study: most food products have a zero thermodynamic minimum (no significant chemical reaction); comminution adds only the surface energy
Show verbatim quote
Most food and beverage products have a zero TM energy intensity because there are no significant chemical reactions involved.Bandwidth Study on Energy Use and Potential Energy Savings Opportunities in U.S. Food and Beverage Manufacturing (opens in a new tab). U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, Advanced Manufacturing Office, 2017. p. 41. DOE/EE-1571; OSTI ID 1512366
Theoretical0 Btu/lbVerified quote

9Unavoidable stops

Stops that physics or regulation impose; they set the maximum availability.
  • Insect control of silos and mill (gas or heat treatment)Verified quote

    Stored grain and mill stocks are protected against infestation by gas or heat treatment, which requires the treated sections to stop; the duration is a declared scenario.

    Show verbatim quote
    Gas or heat treatment may be applied to prevent insect infestation.Best Available Techniques (BAT) Reference Document for the Food, Drink and Milk Industries (opens in a new tab). European Commission, Joint Research Centre; Publications Office of the European Union, 2019. p. 514. EUR 29978 EN; JRC118627; doi:10.2760/243911
  • Weekly dry cleaning and sanitationDeclared assumption

    Flour dust accumulates in rolls, sifters and spouts and must be removed to prevent infestation and dust explosions; declared scenario.

  • Exchange of worn rollsDeclared assumption

    Corrugations of break rolls wear and must be re-fluted; smooth rolls must be reground. Spare rolls limit the stop to the exchange itself; declared scenario.

10Assumptions

  1. The first-break nip capacity depends on the declared fill factor and roll speeds and is reported without a ceiling label; the weekly sanitation is dry cleaning, outside the validity of the cleaning model, so its duration is declared.
  2. Yields are on equal-moisture basis: the water added at tempering and the moisture of flour and by-products are not tracked; the endosperm share is the separation ceiling.
  3. New surface area is computed for equal-volume spheres (times a shape factor) from the kernel diameter and the surface-equivalent mean diameter of the flour.
  4. Kick's and Bond's laws are calibrated on the measured first-break grinding (energy and new specific surface) and extrapolated to flour fineness; their characteristic sizes are approximated by surface-equivalent diameters.
  5. The maximum throughput is the volumetric capacity of the nip of the first break, the stand that receives the whole kernel stream; the performance factor is 1 at that rate.
  6. Flour moisture under control is normally distributed; flour above the Codex limit is out of specification (it is re-blended or downgraded). Granularity is guaranteed by the sieves and is not a loss: overs return to the rolls.

11Range of validity

  • Common wheat milled to white flour on roller mills; durum semolina milling and whole-meal flour are outside the yield model.
  • Hammer milling of whole grain for feed: set the yield ceiling to 1 and use the comminution part of the model only.

12Sensitivity

Elasticity: relative change of the output for a relative change of each parameter. Spearman rank correlation from the Monte Carlo draws is shown alongside.
  • tsant_{san}Weekly stop for dry cleaning and sanitation of the mill
    elasticity -0.025Spearman ρ -0.96
  • zwz_wMoisture set-point margin below the legal limit, in standard deviations
    elasticity +0.014Spearman ρ +0.13
  • tfumt_{fum}Yearly stop for insect control (gas or heat treatment)
    elasticity -0.006Spearman ρ -0.14
  • trollt_{roll}Yearly mill stop for exchanging worn rolls for re-fluted or reground ones
    elasticity -0.006Spearman ρ -0.21
  • Output rises with the parameter
  • Output falls with the parameter

13Validation checks

A model is published only when every check passes.
  • Dimensional analysis20 outputs converted to their declared unitsPassed
  • Every cited value verified against its source15 verified, 0 failedPassed
  • No documented value beats the theoretical limitPassed
  • Ceilings in physical orderPassed
  • Fractions within 0 and 1Passed

14Causes of loss in this operation

Probability that each cause is documented as a relevant loss of a line, pooled over all segments.

15References

  1. WHEAT: Post-harvest Operations (Post-harvest Compendium) (opens in a new tab). Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (AGSI/FAO); author U. K. Baloch, Pakistan Agricultural Research Council, 1999. p. 6. FAO INPhO Post-harvest Compendium, chapter WHEAT (last reviewed 14/10/1999)
  2. Codex Standard for Wheat Flour (CODEX STAN 152-1985, revision 1995) (opens in a new tab). Codex Alimentarius Commission (FAO/WHO), 1995. p. 1. CXS 152-1985
  3. Modeling the energy requirements of first-break grinding (Pasikatan, Milliken, Steele, Haque, Spillman; Transactions of the ASAE 44(6): 1737-1744) (opens in a new tab). American Society of Agricultural Engineers; copy published by USDA Agricultural Research Service, 2001. p. 3. doi:10.13031/2013.6986
  4. Best Available Techniques (BAT) Reference Document for the Food, Drink and Milk Industries (opens in a new tab). European Commission, Joint Research Centre; Publications Office of the European Union, 2019. p. 725. EUR 29978 EN; JRC118627; doi:10.2760/243911
  5. Bandwidth Study on Energy Use and Potential Energy Savings Opportunities in U.S. Food and Beverage Manufacturing (opens in a new tab). U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, Advanced Manufacturing Office, 2017. p. 41. DOE/EE-1571; OSTI ID 1512366
  6. Starch-Based Functional Films Enhanced with Bacterial Nanocellulose for Smart Packaging: Physicochemical Properties, pH Sensitivity and Colorimetric Response (Polymers 16(16): 2259) (opens in a new tab). MDPI (open access, CC BY 4.0); full text served by Europe PMC, 2024. doi:10.3390/polym16162259; PMC11358998
  7. doi:10.13031/2013.6986 — Energy of first-break grinding of wheat: energy per unit mass, new specific surface and energy per unit of new surface (Rittinger constant).
  8. doi:10.3390/polym16162259 — Surface free energy of starch-based films.
  9. — Classical comminution laws: von Rittinger (1867, new surface), Kick (1885, size-reduction ratio), Bond (1952, Trans. AIME 193: 484, third theory); no DOI exists for these publications; they are cited through Pasikatan et al. (2001).