foratvise
Get Started
Milling, extraction and separation

Wheat flour milling

Cleaned and tempered wheat is ground in roller mills, sifted and packed.

In short

This is the line

Each station shows how far it can go according to physics. Select one to see its detail.

Out of every 100 hours planned for production
  1. 68produce

    Typical of the plants studied: the equivalent of 68 hours of good product at full speed (an OEE of 68 %).

  2. 28can be recovered

    The physics of this process allows up to 96 out of 100. This band is the possible improvement.

  3. 4are a physical limit

    No plant avoids them: mandatory cleaning and the minimum times needed to heat, cool or fill.

The typical value comes from 6 studies of Grain and oilseed milling, Milling, extraction and separation.

The most limiting station is Milling and grinding: it reaches 96 % at most.

Where the time is lost

  • Reduced speed28 %

    The line runs, but slower than it can.

  • Breakdowns25 %

    The machine stops because something fails and has to be repaired.

  • Minor stops21 %

    Short stops the operator clears without maintenance: jams, waiting, blocked sensors.

  • Changeovers and adjustments17 %

    Time between one product and the next: format change, cleaning, warm-up and fine tuning.

  • Defects5 %

    Product that comes out wrong and is scrapped or reworked.

  • Start-up losses4 %

    Product lost while the line settles after starting.

Split estimated from 5 studies of Grain and oilseed milling, Milling, extraction and separation.

What most often stops lines like this one

Causes reported by the studies, from the most to the least frequent.

  1. Packaging machine breakdownappears in about 4 of every 100 lines studiedPackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing) · Breakdowns · strong evidence
  2. Unspecified milling-area stoppage (mixed equipment/department code)appears in about 4 of every 100 lines studiedMilling and grinding · Breakdowns · good evidence
  3. Minor stoppage of milling equipmentappears in about 2 of every 100 lines studiedMilling and grinding · Minor stops · limited evidence
  4. Unspecified packaging defectappears in about 2 of every 100 lines studiedPackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing) · Defects · good evidence
  5. Bearing failureappears in about 2 of every 100 lines studiedSeparation (centrifugation, filtration, membranes) · Breakdowns · limited evidence

See the technical detail

Technical detail

Uncertainty intervals, physical models per station and sources, for anyone who wants to check each figure.

1Why it stops: the six big losses

The most probable situations inside each loss, according to 429 published studies. The percentage estimates the probability that a food and beverage line shows that cause; the number of studies reporting it is given below.
Availability

Equipment failure (breakdowns)

25 %of the lost time · 95% interval: 11–42 %
In the operations of this process
  1. Packaging machine breakdownPackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)4.4 %A1.9–8.4 %· 12 of 112 studies report it
  2. Unspecified milling-area stoppage (mixed equipment/department code)Milling and grinding4.0 %B1.2–9.2 %· 6 of 43 studies report it
  3. Bearing failureSeparation (centrifugation, filtration, membranes)1.6 %C0.3–4.4 %· 2 of 37 studies report it
  4. Basic Condition and Operating Standard Non-CompliancePackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)1.1 %C0.3–2.7 %· 3 of 112 studies report it
In any line
  1. Unplanned equipment breakdownWhole line or unspecified equipment11 %A6.1–18 %· 30 of 127 studies report it
  2. Mechanical, electrical or pneumatic component failureWhole line or unspecified equipment1.4 %B0.5–3.2 %· 5 of 127 studies report it

Setup and adjustments

17 %of the lost time · 95% interval: 6–32 %
In the operations of this process
  1. Changeover and setup adjustment on grinding millMilling and grinding1.3 %C0.2–3.7 %· 2 of 43 studies report it
  2. Packaging Equipment Setup and AdjustmentPackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)1.0 %C0.3–2.5 %· 3 of 112 studies report it
  3. Packaging line changeoverPackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)1.0 %C0.3–2.3 %· 3 of 112 studies report it
  4. Changeover setup time (internal and external activities)Separation (centrifugation, filtration, membranes)0.8 %D0.1–2.6 %· 1 of 37 studies reports it
In any line
  1. Changeover / setup timeWhole line or unspecified equipment11 %A5.6–17 %· 28 of 127 studies report it
  2. Cleaning and sanitation downtimeWhole line or unspecified equipment1.0 %C0.3–2.3 %· 3 of 127 studies report it
Performance

Idling and minor stops (micro-stops)

21 %of the lost time · 95% interval: 8–39 %
In the operations of this process
  1. Minor stoppage of milling equipmentMilling and grinding1.8 %C0.4–4.8 %· 3 of 43 studies report it
  2. Packaging/filling seal and handling mechanism faultPackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)0.8 %C0.2–2.0 %· 2 of 112 studies report it
  3. Palletizer minor stoppage (misalignment, jam or blockage)Packaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)0.7 %C0.2–1.8 %· 2 of 112 studies report it
  4. Strapping machine malfunction / minor stoppagePackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)0.5 %D0.1–1.5 %· 1 of 112 studies reports it
In any line
  1. Idling and minor stoppagesWhole line or unspecified equipment1.9 %B0.6–4.1 %· 6 of 127 studies report it
  2. Workplace disorder / poor housekeepingWhole line or unspecified equipment1.0 %C0.3–2.4 %· 3 of 127 studies report it

Reduced speed

28 %of the lost time · 95% interval: 12–48 %
In the operations of this process
  1. Unspecified reduced-speed operation on packaging linePackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)1.6 %C0.5–3.6 %· 4 of 112 studies report it
  2. Separator running below rated throughputSeparation (centrifugation, filtration, membranes)1.2 %D0.2–3.9 %· 1 of 37 studies reports it
  3. Reduced hammer mill throughputMilling and grinding1.2 %D0.2–3.5 %· 1 of 43 studies reports it
  4. Grinding mill component wear causing reduced throughput and scrapMilling and grinding1.1 %D0.2–3.6 %· 1 of 43 studies reports it
In any line
  1. Reduced speed loss (cause not specified)Whole line or unspecified equipment1.2 %C0.3–2.8 %· 3 of 127 studies report it
  2. Station cycle time constraintWhole line or unspecified equipment0.7 %D0.1–1.8 %· 1 of 127 studies reports it
Quality

Process defects (scrap and rework)

5.4 %of the lost time · 95% interval: 2–12 %
In the operations of this process
  1. Unspecified packaging defectPackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)1.6 %B0.5–3.7 %· 5 of 112 studies report it
  2. Flexible package seal/forming defectPackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)1.3 %C0.4–3.0 %· 4 of 112 studies report it
  3. Organ rupture/damage during mechanical eviscerationSeparation (centrifugation, filtration, membranes)1.0 %D0.2–3.2 %· 1 of 37 studies reports it
  4. Impurity/dirt carryover from first-press separationSeparation (centrifugation, filtration, membranes)1.0 %D0.2–3.0 %· 1 of 37 studies reports it
In any line
  1. Unspecified process defectsWhole line or unspecified equipment1.7 %B0.6–3.7 %· 6 of 127 studies report it
  2. Rework of off-specification productWhole line or unspecified equipment1.5 %B0.5–3.4 %· 5 of 127 studies report it

Start-up losses (reduced yield)

4.4 %of the lost time · 95% interval: 1–13 %
In the operations of this process
  1. Product damage during restart after maintenancePackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)0.5 %D0.1–1.4 %· 1 of 112 studies reports it
In any line
  1. Product Loss in Transfer LinesWhole line or unspecified equipment0.9 %C0.2–2.1 %· 3 of 127 studies report it
  2. Product loss at start-up/shut-down due to line designWhole line or unspecified equipment0.5 %D0.1–1.3 %· 1 of 127 studies reports it

Other reported causes

Outside the six big losses: planned stops, organisational or external causes and losses the studies do not classify.
  1. Miscellaneous and unclassified lossesWhole line or unspecified equipment · Not classifiable from the report10 %A5.3–17 %· 29 of 127 studies report it
  2. Raw material shortage or nonconformanceWhole line or unspecified equipment · Organizational or external stops (material or personnel shortage, utilities outage)3.1 %A1.3–5.9 %· 10 of 127 studies report it
  3. Maintenance Program Downtime (Planned and Reactive)Whole line or unspecified equipment · Planned downtime (scheduled maintenance, breaks, no demand)1.6 %B0.5–3.6 %· 5 of 127 studies report it
  4. Waiting for Raw Material or Ingredient SupplyWhole line or unspecified equipment · Organizational or external stops (material or personnel shortage, utilities outage)1.5 %B0.5–3.5 %· 5 of 127 studies report it
  5. Screw press downtime of mixed/unrecorded causeSeparation (centrifugation, filtration, membranes) · Not classifiable from the report1.5 %C0.3–4.2 %· 2 of 37 studies report it
  6. Unspecified hammer mill stoppageMilling and grinding · Not classifiable from the report1.4 %C0.3–4.1 %· 2 of 43 studies report it

The dot is the estimated probability and the band its 95% credible interval. All bars share one scale, from 0 to 20 %. The letter is the evidence grade: A is the strongest and D means the cause rests on one study or none.

Split of the lost time estimated from 5 studies of Grain and oilseed milling, Milling, extraction and separation.

2Chain of unit operations

2 of 3 operations have a published physical model. Select an operation for its full derivation.
  1. Milling and grindingPhysical model
    Energy per unit of product
    Theoretical0.00437 kJ/kgBest available technique73.9 kJ/kgBest documented92.1 kJ/kg
    Cycle or residence time
    Theoretical3.56 ms
    Yield
    Theoretical0.830Best documented0.740Typical0.720
    Quality
    Theoretical0.9987
    Performance
    Theoretical1.00
    Availability
    Theoretical0.965
    OEE
    Theoretical0.964
  2. Cycle or residence time
    Theoretical0.00911 sTypical0.300 s
    Throughput
    Theoretical158 1/minTypical89.6 1/min
    Energy per unit of product
    Theoretical0 JTypical147 J
    Quality
    Theoretical1.00000
    Yield
    Theoretical0.9982
    Availability
    Theoretical1.00
    Performance
    Theoretical0.986
    OEE
    Theoretical0.986

3Line-level physics-bounded OEE

Bracket for the whole line from the modelled operations.
  • Upper value (ideal buffers)
    0.956 [0.937–0.974]
  • Lower value (no buffers)
    0.939 [0.910–0.964]

Based on 2 of 3 operations.

Upper value: ideal buffers and synchronised unavoidable stops (the line is bounded by its most constrained modelled operation). Lower value: no buffers and independent unavoidable stops (downtime ratios add, quality factors multiply, the slowest operation sets the rate). Operations without a physical model are not yet included, so both values are upper bounds for the whole line.

4Composition of lost time

Share of lost time among the six big losses for Grain and oilseed milling, Milling, extraction and separation.
Evidence gradeC5 studies, 5 units
  • Equipment failure (breakdowns)
  • Setup and adjustments
  • Idling and minor stops (micro-stops)
  • Reduced speed
  • Process defects (scrap and rework)
  • Start-up losses (reduced yield)
  • Equipment failure (breakdowns)Availability
    25% [11–42%]prediction 0–66%
  • Setup and adjustmentsAvailability
    17% [6–32%]prediction 0–81%
  • Idling and minor stops (micro-stops)Performance
    21% [8–39%]prediction 0–82%
  • Reduced speedPerformance
    28% [12–48%]prediction 0–89%
  • Process defects (scrap and rework)Quality
    5.4% [1.6–11.6%]prediction 0.0–23.8%
  • Start-up losses (reduced yield)Quality
    4.4% [0.9–12.7%]prediction 0.0–62.6%

Dots are posterior means; thick whiskers are 95% credible intervals; thin whiskers are 95% prediction intervals for a new line.

5Most probable causes

Probability of presence of each cause in food and beverage lines (all segments), highest first. The estimate by segment is on the page of each cause.

6Documented OEE

Pooled OEE and factors reported by the included studies of this group, and the best documented value.
MetricPooled estimate [95% CrI]Studies / unitsBest documented
OEE0.681 [0.606–0.763]6 / 60.875 · View study
Show verbatim quote
Dari hasil penelitian didapatkan nilai OEE sebesar 87.52% dibawah standar yang di tetapkan PT. Pioneer Flour Mill Industries yaitu 90%
Availability0.861 [0.811–0.915]5 / 50.973 · View study
Show verbatim quote
Rata-rata 97,28 78,20 89,51 68,26
Performance0.810 [0.733–0.876]4 / 40.871 · View study
Show verbatim quote
rasio kinerja atau performance ratio 87,12%
Quality0.942 [0.904–0.967]4 / 41.00 · View study
Show verbatim quote
nilai rata-rata dari availability ratio, performance ratio, quality ratio, dan nilai OEE adalah masing-masing 70,08%, 69,57%, 100%, dan 48,75%

OEE documented in other processes of Grain and oilseed milling

Process familyOEEStudies / unitsEvidence grade
Filling and packaging line0.655 [0.583–0.708]7 / 7B
Thermal processing0.627 [0.520–0.700]7 / 7B
Concentration and drying0.653 [0.557–0.740]1 / 1D
Slaughter, cutting and primary processing0.649 [0.580–0.708]16 / 57A