Extruded snacks and breakfast cereals
Cereal flours are blended, cooked and shaped in an extruder, dried and packed.
In short
This is the line
Each station shows how far it can go according to physics. Select one to see its detail.
Drag to rotate the view
- 65produce
Typical of the plants studied: the equivalent of 65 hours of good product at full speed (an OEE of 65 %).
- 28can be recovered
The physics of this process allows up to 93 out of 100. This band is the possible improvement.
- 7are a physical limit
No plant avoids them: mandatory cleaning and the minimum times needed to heat, cool or fill.
The typical value comes from 4 studies of Snacks, coffee, tea and other foods, Forming, baking and cooking.
The most limiting station is Drying: it reaches 95 % at most.
Where the time is lost
- Breakdowns26 %
The machine stops because something fails and has to be repaired.
- Changeovers and adjustments22 %
Time between one product and the next: format change, cleaning, warm-up and fine tuning.
- Reduced speed21 %
The line runs, but slower than it can.
- Minor stops19 %
Short stops the operator clears without maintenance: jams, waiting, blocked sensors.
- Defects10 %
Product that comes out wrong and is scrapped or reworked.
- Start-up losses3 %
Product lost while the line settles after starting.
Split estimated from 3 studies of Snacks, coffee, tea and other foods, Forming, baking and cooking.
What most often stops lines like this one
Causes reported by the studies, from the most to the least frequent.
- Packaging machine breakdownappears in about 4 of every 100 lines studied
- Dryer equipment malfunction and downtimeappears in about 4 of every 100 lines studied
- Unspecified packaging defectappears in about 2 of every 100 lines studied
- Extruder changeover (die/recipe change and line clearing)appears in about 2 of every 100 lines studied
- Unspecified reduced-speed operation on packaging lineappears in about 2 of every 100 lines studied
Technical detail
Uncertainty intervals, physical models per station and sources, for anyone who wants to check each figure.
1Why it stops: the six big losses
Equipment failure (breakdowns)
26 %- Packaging machine breakdownPackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)4.4 %A1.9–8.4 %· 12 of 112 studies report it
- Dryer equipment malfunction and downtimeDrying3.6 %C0.9–9.2 %· 4 of 28 studies report it
- Reactive maintenance restart delayDrying1.1 %D0.2–3.6 %· 1 of 28 studies reports it
- Inadequate preventive maintenance (cleaning, lubrication, tensioning)Drying1.1 %D0.2–3.3 %· 1 of 28 studies reports it
- Unplanned equipment breakdownWhole line or unspecified equipment11 %A6.1–18 %· 30 of 127 studies report it
- Mechanical, electrical or pneumatic component failureWhole line or unspecified equipment1.4 %B0.5–3.2 %· 5 of 127 studies report it
Setup and adjustments
22 %- Extruder changeover (die/recipe change and line clearing)Extrusion1.6 %C0.4–4.2 %· 3 of 59 studies report it
- Syrup batching changeover and setup timeMixing and blending1.3 %C0.3–3.8 %· 2 of 31 studies report it
- Manual cleaning of mixing equipment during changeoverMixing and blending1.3 %C0.2–3.7 %· 2 of 31 studies report it
- Packaging Equipment Setup and AdjustmentPackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)1.0 %C0.3–2.5 %· 3 of 112 studies report it
- Changeover / setup timeWhole line or unspecified equipment11 %A5.6–17 %· 28 of 127 studies report it
- Cleaning and sanitation downtimeWhole line or unspecified equipment1.0 %C0.3–2.3 %· 3 of 127 studies report it
Idling and minor stops (micro-stops)
19 %- Packaging/filling seal and handling mechanism faultPackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)0.8 %C0.2–2.0 %· 2 of 112 studies report it
- Palletizer minor stoppage (misalignment, jam or blockage)Packaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)0.7 %C0.2–1.8 %· 2 of 112 studies report it
- Strapping machine malfunction / minor stoppagePackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)0.5 %D0.1–1.5 %· 1 of 112 studies reports it
- Fallen Product Requiring CleanupPackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)0.5 %D0.1–1.5 %· 1 of 112 studies reports it
- Idling and minor stoppagesWhole line or unspecified equipment1.9 %B0.6–4.1 %· 6 of 127 studies report it
- Workplace disorder / poor housekeepingWhole line or unspecified equipment1.0 %C0.3–2.4 %· 3 of 127 studies report it
Reduced speed
21 %- Unspecified reduced-speed operation on packaging linePackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)1.6 %C0.5–3.6 %· 4 of 112 studies report it
- HFCS transfer pump flow below design capacityMixing and blending1.2 %D0.2–3.7 %· 1 of 31 studies reports it
- Operator-limited line speedPackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)0.7 %D0.1–1.8 %· 1 of 112 studies reports it
- Reduced speed loss (cause not specified)Whole line or unspecified equipment1.2 %C0.3–2.8 %· 3 of 127 studies report it
- Station cycle time constraintWhole line or unspecified equipment0.7 %D0.1–1.8 %· 1 of 127 studies reports it
Process defects (scrap and rework)
9.5 %- Unspecified packaging defectPackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)1.6 %B0.5–3.7 %· 5 of 112 studies report it
- Flexible package seal/forming defectPackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)1.3 %C0.4–3.0 %· 4 of 112 studies report it
- Color deviation defectMixing and blending0.9 %D0.2–2.8 %· 1 of 31 studies reports it
- Heat seal defect (detached, wrinkled or folded seal)Packaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)0.8 %C0.2–2.1 %· 2 of 112 studies report it
- Unspecified process defectsWhole line or unspecified equipment1.7 %B0.6–3.7 %· 6 of 127 studies report it
- Rework of off-specification productWhole line or unspecified equipment1.5 %B0.5–3.4 %· 5 of 127 studies report it
Start-up losses (reduced yield)
2.8 %- Product damage during restart after maintenancePackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing)0.5 %D0.1–1.4 %· 1 of 112 studies reports it
- Product Loss in Transfer LinesWhole line or unspecified equipment0.9 %C0.2–2.1 %· 3 of 127 studies report it
- Product loss at start-up/shut-down due to line designWhole line or unspecified equipment0.5 %D0.1–1.3 %· 1 of 127 studies reports it
Other reported causes
- Miscellaneous and unclassified lossesWhole line or unspecified equipment · Not classifiable from the report10 %A5.3–17 %· 29 of 127 studies report it
- Raw material shortage or nonconformanceWhole line or unspecified equipment · Organizational or external stops (material or personnel shortage, utilities outage)3.1 %A1.3–5.9 %· 10 of 127 studies report it
- Maintenance Program Downtime (Planned and Reactive)Whole line or unspecified equipment · Planned downtime (scheduled maintenance, breaks, no demand)1.6 %B0.5–3.6 %· 5 of 127 studies report it
- Waiting for Raw Material or Ingredient SupplyWhole line or unspecified equipment · Organizational or external stops (material or personnel shortage, utilities outage)1.5 %B0.5–3.5 %· 5 of 127 studies report it
- Unspecified packaging line lossPackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing) · Not classifiable from the report1.4 %C0.4–3.2 %· 4 of 112 studies report it
- Miscellaneous non-specific line stoppageWhole line or unspecified equipment · Organizational or external stops (material or personnel shortage, utilities outage)1.3 %C0.4–2.9 %· 4 of 127 studies report it
The dot is the estimated probability and the band its 95% credible interval. All bars share one scale, from 0 to 20 %. The letter is the evidence grade: A is the strongest and D means the cause rests on one study or none.
Split of the lost time estimated from 3 studies of Snacks, coffee, tea and other foods, Forming, baking and cooking.
2Chain of unit operations
- Mixing and blendingPhysical model
- Cycle or residence time
- Theoretical47.0 sTypical54.0 s
- Throughput
- Typical13.1 m³/h
- Energy per unit of product
- Theoretical0 kJ/kgTypical0.0104 kJ/kg
- Quality
- Theoretical0.984
- Yield
- Theoretical0.999952Typical0.9970
- Availability
- Theoretical0.9844Typical0.859
- Performance
- Theoretical1.00
- OEE
- Theoretical0.968
- ExtrusionPhysical model
- Energy per unit of product
- Theoretical7.02 kJ/kgBest documented900 kJ/kgTypical1,404 kJ/kg
- Yield
- Theoretical1.00
- Quality
- Theoretical0.979
- Performance
- Theoretical1.00
- Availability
- Theoretical1.00
- OEE
- Theoretical0.979
- DryingPhysical model
- Energy per unit of product
- Theoretical7.96 kJ/kgTypical7,389 kJ/kg
- Throughput
- Theoretical0.0593 kg/kg
- Cycle or residence time
- Theoretical1.59 s
- Yield
- Theoretical0.9937Best documented0.974
- Quality
- Theoretical0.9987
- Availability
- Theoretical0.946
- Performance
- Theoretical1.00
- OEE
- Theoretical0.945
- Cycle or residence time
- Theoretical0.00911 sTypical0.300 s
- Throughput
- Theoretical158 1/minTypical89.6 1/min
- Energy per unit of product
- Theoretical0 JTypical147 J
- Quality
- Theoretical1.00000
- Yield
- Theoretical0.9982
- Availability
- Theoretical1.00
- Performance
- Theoretical0.986
- OEE
- Theoretical0.986
3Line-level physics-bounded OEE
- Upper value (ideal buffers)0.935 [0.842–0.975]
- Lower value (no buffers)0.884 [0.768–0.942]
Based on 4 of 4 operations.
Upper value: ideal buffers and synchronised unavoidable stops (the line is bounded by its most constrained modelled operation). Lower value: no buffers and independent unavoidable stops (downtime ratios add, quality factors multiply, the slowest operation sets the rate). Operations without a physical model are not yet included, so both values are upper bounds for the whole line.
4Composition of lost time
- Equipment failure (breakdowns)
- Setup and adjustments
- Idling and minor stops (micro-stops)
- Reduced speed
- Process defects (scrap and rework)
- Start-up losses (reduced yield)
- Equipment failure (breakdowns)Availability26% [13–42%]prediction 0–65%
- Setup and adjustmentsAvailability22% [9–40%]prediction 0–86%
- Idling and minor stops (micro-stops)Performance19% [8–34%]prediction 0–79%
- Reduced speedPerformance21% [8–37%]prediction 0–84%
- Process defects (scrap and rework)Quality9.5% [4.4–17.3%]prediction 0.0–33.4%
- Start-up losses (reduced yield)Quality2.8% [0.7–7.3%]prediction 0.0–52.1%
Dots are posterior means; thick whiskers are 95% credible intervals; thin whiskers are 95% prediction intervals for a new line.
5Most probable causes
- Unplanned equipment breakdownWhole line or unspecified equipment · Equipment failure (breakdowns)11% [6–18%]A127 studies
- Changeover / setup timeWhole line or unspecified equipment · Setup and adjustments11% [6–17%]A127 studies
- Miscellaneous and unclassified lossesWhole line or unspecified equipment · not classifiable10% [5–17%]A127 studies
- Packaging machine breakdownPackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing) · Equipment failure (breakdowns)4.4% [1.9–8.4%]A112 studies
- Dryer equipment malfunction and downtimeDrying · Equipment failure (breakdowns)3.6% [0.9–9.2%]C28 studies
- Raw material shortage or nonconformanceWhole line or unspecified equipment · organizational external3.1% [1.3–5.9%]A127 studies
- Idling and minor stoppagesWhole line or unspecified equipment · Idling and minor stops (micro-stops)1.9% [0.6–4.1%]B127 studies
- Unspecified process defectsWhole line or unspecified equipment · Process defects (scrap and rework)1.7% [0.6–3.7%]B127 studies
- Unspecified packaging defectPackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing) · Process defects (scrap and rework)1.6% [0.5–3.7%]B112 studies
- Extruder changeover (die/recipe change and line clearing)Extrusion · Setup and adjustments1.6% [0.4–4.2%]C59 studies
- Maintenance Program Downtime (Planned and Reactive)Whole line or unspecified equipment · planned downtime1.6% [0.5–3.6%]B127 studies
- Unspecified reduced-speed operation on packaging linePackaging (forming, sealing, wrapping, case packing, palletizing) · Reduced speed1.6% [0.5–3.6%]C112 studies
- Waiting for Raw Material or Ingredient SupplyWhole line or unspecified equipment · organizational external1.5% [0.5–3.5%]B127 studies
- Rework of off-specification productWhole line or unspecified equipment · Process defects (scrap and rework)1.5% [0.5–3.4%]B127 studies
- Mechanical, electrical or pneumatic component failureWhole line or unspecified equipment · Equipment failure (breakdowns)1.4% [0.5–3.2%]B127 studies
6Documented OEE
| Metric | Pooled estimate [95% CrI] | Studies / units | Best documented |
|---|---|---|---|
| OEE | 0.649 [0.567–0.709] | 4 / 4 | 0.925 · View studyShow verbatim quote13 98,96% 96,69% 96,67% 92,50% |
| Availability | 0.823 [0.747–0.872] | 4 / 4 | 0.990 · View studyShow verbatim quote13 48 0,5 98,96% |
| Performance | 0.817 [0.737–0.879] | 3 / 3 | 0.989 · View studyShow verbatim quote11 300.000 31,55 0,000104 98,89% |
| Quality | 0.930 [0.888–0.957] | 3 / 3 | 0.982 · View studyShow verbatim quoteTotal 240000 4246 98,231 |
OEE documented in other processes of Snacks, coffee, tea and other foods
| Process family | OEE | Studies / units | Evidence grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| Filling and packaging line | 0.671 [0.601–0.728] | 5 / 5 | B |
| Concentration and drying | 0.668 [0.578–0.757] | 1 / 1 | D |
| Milling, extraction and separation | 0.695 [0.619–0.781] | 2 / 2 | C |
| Whole plant or unspecified | 0.641 [0.553–0.703] | 2 / 2 | C |

